A pick up in both issuance and defaults in 2024 will not be enough to disrupt the strong market technical supporting European high yield bonds, which this year propelled returns from this asset class to their highest level since before the pandemic.
Bank research desks are forecasting total returns in 2024 ranging from a modest 2.8% predicted by Deutsche Bank, to as high as 9.3% according Goldman Sachs. Combined with European high yield return projections of 3.6% from BNP Paribas, 4.5% from ING, 6.25% from Barclays and 8% from JP Morgan, analysts are therefore predicting an average gain of roughly 5.4% next year.
This projection is well below the 11.7% total high yield return posted in 2019, according to Barclays, and marks a steep decline from the stellar 10.44% return this year from the Morningstar Eurozone High-Yield Bond index (to Dec. 12) — which shot up from just over 6% at the end of October, helped by a historic move lower in sovereign bond yields in November. “2023 was basically a year of carry, and has mainly been about clipping coupons rather than spread contraction,” said a high yield fund manager. “Next year, the base case is that spreads will widen marginally and it is going to be a lot tougher to generate returns.”
But with investors now pricing in 150 bps of rate cuts next year following a sharp shift in inflation expectations, the high yield asset class in Europe is poised for a year supported by coupon income and lower government bond yields. Breaking down the 6.25% return forecast for 2024 by Barclays, the bank’s analysts predict 3.95% will come from carry and 4.41% from lower Bund yields — offset by roughly 1% apiece from wider spreads and a pick-up in defaults.
The support from underlying rates should give bonds the upper hand over loans, which analysts say will struggle in 2024 to beat the post-GFC high on the Morningstar European Leveraged Loan Index (ELLI), which is yielding a total ex-currency return of 12.23% in the year to Dec. 8. Deutsche Bank for example forecasts a 0.2% total return next year for European leveraged loans, while JP Morgan says a lower rating quality and higher average prices give the loan asset class “less capacity for capital gains next year” compared with high yield. High yield defaults are also only expected to increase to as much as 5%, according to ING’s estimate, but could be as low as 2.5%, according to Barclays and JP Morgan.
Technical talk
Even in periods of volatility this year, a strong technical backdrop of negative net high-yield supply, record demand from CLO buyers and issuers leaving the index through upgrades to investment grade more than offset steady but persistent outflows prior to November. But while stress in the real estate sector in particular should shift the focus towards fallen angels over rising stars in 2024 (Goldman Sachs and Barclays both predict €30 billion of downgrades from investment grade to high yield, versus €15 billion of rising stars), investors and analysts say there are few obvious factors to unwind the positive technical support underpinning the market.
Despite two-consecutive years of negative net new issuance for the first time ever across 2022 and 2023, according to Barclays, bankers and analysts are only expecting a marginal increase in high yield bond supply in Europe next year as issuers tackle upcoming maturities and bolster balance-sheet liquidity. According to LCD, European high yield issuance this year (to Dec. 8) is just shy of €43 billion, which is 91% ahead of €22.3 billion recorded in the prior full year, but still 52% behind the €88.4 billion five-year average for yearly volume across the period 2017-2021.
Estimates for 2024 gross non-financial high yield supply range from €50 billion on ING’s measure to €80 billion by JP Morgan and Deutsche Bank, with Goldman Sachs forecasting €65 billion and Barclays €70 billion. But from a net perspective, JP Morgan puts the figure at only €5 billion, while Barclays says there will be €25 billion of supply when taking into account redemptions. It should also be noted that some predictions include hybrid bonds issued by investment-grade companies, which are not included in LCD’s volume totals.
“I would be surprised if there is more than €60 billion of issuance in 2024,” said a head of high yield at one arranger. “I expect issuance to pick up because the bond market has been much slower than loans to refinance 2025 and 2026 maturities, but so far flow is concentrated on corporate double-Bs rather than sponsor-backed issuers.”
While record amend-and-extend activity in European loans has pushed the maturity wall on the ELLI out to 2028, a greater reluctance on the part of fixed-rate borrowers to replace low-coupon debt means high yield bond maturities in Europe peak in 2026, when €94 billion is due, according to Goldman Sachs. According to JP Morgan, meanwhile, only €11 billion of 2025 bond maturities were redeemed this year, leaving €63 billion remaining. For next year, Barclays analysts assume 70% of this will be refinanced, which by the bank’s estimates will yield €35 billion of bond supply. But for 2026 bond maturities — for which other than Ineos Quattro, issuers have scarcely approached the market this year — Barclays expects 10% of the bonds to be refinanced next year.
“There is a lot of talk about the looming maturity wall, but if sponsors think rates are going down materially, why on earth would they issue a high yield bond?,” asked a London-based fund manager. “If their companies are going to survive even in a recession scenario, you can see why they are playing a game of chicken, and going slower on the maturity wall.”
While refinancing volumes are roughly half the 2021 figures this year for both sponsor-backed and non-sponsored companies, private equity-backed firms were responsible for only €6.7 billion of the debt issued for high-yield refinancing purposes this year, compared with €20.3 billion for non-sponsored corporates. However, by rating category, double-Bs — which in Europe typically have plentiful access to bank financing — have accounted for €13 billion of refinancing volume this year, compared to €10.7 billion for single-Bs, according to LCD.
Buyout funding
The key driver to the upside for issuance will naturally be M&A and LBO financings, where bankers are not expecting any meaningful supply to come to the bond market in the first half of 2024. And after that, sponsors are still expected to favour the optionality of the loan market, or the certainty provided by private credit when financing buyouts, sources say. “Sometimes investors are pre-sounded in the early stages of LBO financings, but in the past six to eight months that hasn’t been the case,” said an investor source. “Instead, sponsors are effectively calling private credit funds directly.”
Whereas bond supply for buyouts swelled to a record of €21.3 billion in 2021 as acquisitions of existing issuers such as Modulaire and Arrow Global came to the bond market again under new sponsors (with the same being true in 2022 for Miller Homes, House of HR and Fedrigoni), the financing of Permira and Blackstone’s acquisition of Adevinta through a €4.5 billion private credit loan was indicative of a sea change in market attitudes towards direct lending.
That sponsors chose the private credit route for a known borrower with €2.4 billion of existing bonds and loans, which could have in theory been rolled over, was taken as a clear indicator regarding the relative strength of the two markets. But while private credit might offer deeper capacity, the emergence of clear blue water on pricing should tempt sponsors back to syndicated markets in 2024.
Cinven’s buyout of Synlab — which included a private element through a €500 million PIK loan provided by direct lenders — was supported by a package that included a €1 billion term loan priced at E+475 with a 0% floor offered at 99, and a €450 million seven-year bond at 7.875%. This compares with E+575 offered at 98 for Adevinta, and on the bond pieces represents a discount to the 9.18% single-B high-yield average for the three months ended Dec. 8, according to LCD.
“I don’t expect the majority of LBOs next year to go down the private credit route,” said an optimistic banker. “Adevinta [going to private credit] was an interesting decision based on that fact that it’s difficult to issue €4.5 billion in euros alone — but that doesn’t mean you can’t raise that amount in the syndicated market.”
Featured image by rbkomar/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.