As the books close on 2023, US leveraged loans are on track for an exceptionally strong annual return, though rising interest rates and economic uncertainty has constrained primary market activity, especially for lucrative M&A deals. A slowing economy and high interest rates could present challenges for leveraged borrowers in 2024. Indeed, market forecasters see similar themes playing out next year: High coupons will keep returns for the asset class elevated, and while new issuance will improve, it will remain below historical averages.
It was a remarkable year for the loan market. Through Dec. 12, the Morningstar LSTA Leveraged Loan Index returned 12.08%, its best performance since 2009 and second-best ever. For additional context, 2009 featured a whopping 51.6% return after a 29% loss in 2008. Setting the unprecedented Global Financial Crisis period aside, the 2023 gain would be the strongest year since the inception of the index in 1997. Of course, given that loans are a floating-rate asset class and the rapid rising of rates, the interest component provided the bulk of the gain, at 9.26% as of Dec. 12.
On the flip side, supply remained suppressed this year as high rates deterred M&A activity, leaving refinancing and extensions to take a larger share of new issuance. Total 2023 institutional loan issuance of $233.5 billion as of Dec. 12 barely surpassed the 2022 total of $225.3 billion, and was well below the annual average of the prior 10 years ($380 billion). Refinancing accounted for 58% of the total this past year, while M&A was a slim 30%. That flipped the script from 2022, when just 26% of activity was tied to refinancing while acquisition-related issuance accounted for 63%.
Through Dec. 12, M&A volume this year, including sponsored and corporate activity, was $69.8 billion, its lowest level since 2010 ($62.8 billion) and down from $142.6 billion in 2022 and an all-time high of $330.4 billion in 2021. New LBO supply was also at a 13-year low, at just $31.2 billion. By contrast, refinancing issuance was elevated, at $136.2 billion, the fourth highest total on record, as issuers focused on extending maturities. That does not include a record amount of amend-and-extend volume that totaled $80.9 billion of institutional loans, or the $78.7 billion of repricing activity (including re-syndicated repricings), which gathered considerable steam later in the year.
Looking to 2024, that tilt toward refinancing is likely to remain as borrowers continue to chip away at the maturity wall. Market prognosticators see potential for M&A-related issuance to top 2023’s anemic levels, but do not expect a strong rebound as interest rates remain challenging.
Strategists at JP Morgan see rising deal volumes in 2024, though still well below historical averages. The bank is forecasting gross institutional issuance of $375 billion next year, a roughly 10% increase from the estimated 2023 level. On a net basis, excluding refinancing and repricings, issuance is projected at $120 million, or a gain of 50% over 2023. “A stable yield and rate backdrop will be an important factor in loan issuers’ ability to access the primary market in 2024, particularly for refinancing,” the bank says in a Nov. 21 research report. The JPM report suggests issuers will be “even more aggressive” in addressing upcoming maturities over the coming year.
Following 2023’s refinancing and extension activity, there is still wood to chop. According to LCD, the 2025-2026 maturity wall stood at $277 billion as of Dec. 8, with $96 billion of that due in 2025 and $181 billion in 2026. Issuers have made some headway this year, as that total figure is down from $433 billion as of December 2022, while the 2025 maturity wall is less than half its $198 billion total a year prior.
However, riskier credits constitute a larger portion of the remaining amounts: 51% of the 2025 maturity wall is from issuers with a B-minus rating. That can be troublesome if financing costs for these issuers remain high, and investors remain risk-averse. Looking a bit further out on the timeline, loan maturities in 2027 are currently $256 billion. They then swell to a peak of $532 billion in 2028.
Likewise, Barclays research expects US leveraged loan issuance to “materially increase” next year, to a range of $320-350 billion, with “the vast majority dedicated to refinancing.” Amend-and-extend transactions will again be a popular tool for managing approaching maturities. “M&A and LBO issuance is likely to remain quite subdued, as it was this year, as elevated rates make many such transactions non-viable,” Barclays says in its 2024 market outlook. However, it also noted that such activity could pick up in the second half of the year if there’s additional clarity on the trajectory of rates.
While rising debt costs have thrown a wrench into the economics for LBOs, BofA Research still sees sponsor-driven buyout activity rising 10% year-over-year. BofA argues that “faced with the need to generate returns and return capital, sponsors will be incentivized to make deals work even if that comes at the cost of providing more equity and lower expected returns.” Still, the bank also expects overall volume to be driven by refinancing once again. In total, BofA is forecasting total new-issue volume in 2024 of $240 billion, an 8% increase on an assumed $220 billion final level for 2023, by its calculation.
What new LBOs investors saw in the institutional market this year indeed featured lower leverage and higher equity checks, as issuance was limited to higher-quality borrowers. LCD’s compilation of company financials at the time of issuance show that the average debt/EBITDA ratio of newly minted broadly syndicated LBO debt in the US fell to 5x for large corporate borrowers as of Nov. 30 — the lowest annual reading since 2010. Equity contributions topped 50% for the first time on record.
While the shadow calendar for potential acquisition financing in the loan market is thin, there have been in the fourth quarter several new M&A announcements from leveraged issuers with bank-led financing commitments, including the tie-up of amusement park operators Six Flags and Cedar Fair, along with Amentum’s merger with the government services businesses of Jacobs, and CD&R’s buyout of Sharer’s Foods.
On the demand side, bank research estimates for CLO issuance in 2024 swing between marginal increases to decreases from 2023 levels. Deutsche Bank, JP Morgan, and Morgan Stanley all forecast $115 million of CLO issuance in 2024, while BofA sees that issuance at $110 billion, and Barclays estimates $100 billion. CLOs, which account for roughly 70% of the investor base for the institutional loan market, have generated $112 billion of issuance in 2023 as of Dec 11, down 13% from the full-year 2022 issuance level of $129 billion, according to LCD.
Outflows from loan mutual funds and ETFs were a drag on the loan market in 2023, totaling $14.2 billion for the year through Dec. 6, according to data compiled by Morningstar. “Retail is expected to remain a sideshow, though ETFs, which are correlated to the equity market, will drive temporary dislocations in either direction,” BofA notes.
Market observers also single as potential detriments to new issuance in the broadly syndicated loan market continued encroachment by private credit, as well as increased bond-for-loan takeouts if the Fed begins cutting rates. Deep-pocketed private credit funds have aggressively taken market share from traditional BSL arrangers, trumpeting certainty of closing. As private credit has increasingly financed large LBOs that have historically been the territory of arrangers in the broadly syndicated market, new sponsored deals are now being dual-tracked between the two markets. Some examples of jumbo LBO loans in the private credit space in 2023 were Merchants Fleet ($3 billion), New Relic ($2.65 billion), and Guidehouse ($1.9 billion).
What’s more, some borrowers gravitated to private credit to refinance their existing traditional institutional loans, including high-profile deals for Finastra ($5.3 billion), Hyland Software ($3.4 billion), and PetVet Care Centers ($3 billion). Those three combined included some $8.5 billion of repayments of institutional first-lien loans that were due in 2024 and 2025. In the year to Nov. 30, $14 billion of institutional loans have been repaid from the Morningstar LSTA Leveraged Loan Index with direct lending financing proceeds, based on deals where the new private credit transaction was covered by LCD News. This number will increase following recently reported transactions for Greenway Health, Synamedia, BeyondTrust and Consolidated Precision Products. Ratings agency Moody’s, looking toward a revived buyout market, believes large banks in the publicly syndicated loan market will aggressively compete for new LBOs. “As LBO competition grows, stronger credits will access the broadly syndicated loan (BSL) market, which provides cheaper pricing and more flexible documentation than private credit,” the agency said in a September report. “When targeting the BSL market, most private equity-sponsored entities now build their balance sheets to achieve a B2 or higher rating. This is because growing investor risk aversion has pushed many B3 credits — once favorites of the BSL market — into private credit, which caters to smaller, more highly leveraged companies,” the report said.
In fact, just four LBO deals from issuers rated B-minus were completed in the syndicated market in 2023; Aramsco, Cvent, and Fogo de Chao.
In terms of return, investors should expect another strong year for leveraged loan performance. BofA is forecasting a 7% figure in 2024, and JP Morgan 9%. “Carry is likely to once again be the key driver of returns next year thanks to elevated base rates, which have risen over 500bp over the past two years, and which we expect to remain elevated through 2024,” Barclays says. The bank is forecasting total returns of 5.5%-6.5% in 2024.
Conversely, borrowers could continue to feel the pinch of high coupons on floating-rate debt if the Fed only begins easing rates later in 2024. “In our opinion, higher for longer rates will make unviable the capital structures built primarily on their ability to borrow at low cost,” says BofA, which expects US loan defaults to reach 3.5% next year.
A more dovish tone from the Fed out of the December FOMC meeting added to speculation around when cuts would begin and how many would come in the year ahead. The market is currently projecting the first 25 bps rate cut to come in March, according to the CME FedWatch.
Featured image by Luca Aimone / 500px / Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.