Lori Chavez-DeRemer
Public-Private Convergence

Outlook for alts after 401(k) proposal: Hazy, with chance of more lawsuits

It could take several years for big employer-sponsored retirement plans to adopt private assets despite the big push for alternative managers.
Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer

Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer is aiming to shield the retirement plan industry from litigation and excessive regulation.

Jason Ardan/Getty Images

The Trump administration’s new proposal on diversifying the range of assets in employer-sponsored savings plans has been hailed as a big win for the alternatives industry. But a major obstacle stands between private credit funds and your 401(k) plan: the threat of being sued.

Retirement plan managers technically are allowed to offer private-market options already, but they’ve long eschewed them for fear of litigation over high fees and poor performance. The proposed new rules, released last week by the Department of Labor, aim to make it harder for retirement savers to successfully sue plan sponsors and their fiduciaries.

And still, there’s little sign of plan sponsors shedding their cautious stance any time soon.

Analysts said the new rules aimed at offering plan fiduciaries “safe harbor” from litigation won’t make much of an impact until they are affirmed in the court system. Within the next couple of months, the Supreme Court is set to weigh in with a closely watched ruling.

More on public-private convergence

Why Wall Street wants to trade AI compute like oil

A new boom in tech industrialization changes the face of Silicon Valley’s capital stack.

Why is Apollo pushing the private market to act more like the public market?

CEO Marc Rowan has pledged $350 million to reduce the opaqueness and illiquidity that have kept the private market from including individual investors at scale.

Anthropic’s Wall Street debut to cast long shadow over private AI stocks

For better or worse, a segment that lacked public benchmarks will soon get a fast-growing leader—and an untested business model.

The stakes couldn’t be higher for alternative asset managers, who need to make up for their decline in fundraising from institutional investors.

Assets sitting in retirement plans are seen as a lucrative backup plan. The nation’s 401(k) and other employer-sponsored plans now total roughly $15 trillion, representing a juicy opportunity to drive future fee-earning revenue streams.

Following the Labor Department’s guidance, however, any moves to expand private market offerings in defined contribution plans will likely be modest in the early going, with small and medium-sized plan administrators being the first to test the waters. Most of the bigger counterparts are more risk-averse and are expected to wait and see how the early adopters navigate the new landscape. “Because the bigger the plan, the bigger the target is on your back,” said Winfield Evens, vice president of financial services at Alight Solutions, a corporate benefits administrator.

Target-date funds, a roughly $5 trillion segment in the US alone, are considered the most practical wrappers for introducing private-market assets to 401(k) plans, rather than offering them as standalone products. Top-tier alternatives firms have been positioning themselves to be able to funnel their products into this channel.

Blackstone recently struck a deal to market private funds via Empower, another benefits administrator, which has partnerships with firms including Apollo Global Management, Franklin Templeton and Neuberger Berman. Additionally, Blue Owl Capital intends to create products for distribution through Voya Financial retirement plans.

In a cruel twist of timing, the fund industry has had to contend with a steady drumbeat of negative news headlines surrounding the private credit market, even as it has been campaigning to shape the Trump administration’s policy on private investments in retirement savings accounts.

Latest Research

PitchBook Analyst Note: How Safe Is the 401(k) Safe Harbor?

The Department of Labor has released its long-awaited 401(k) investment rules proposal, but the outcome may not be what the organization intended. Rather than a green light for private equity and crypto, the new framework focuses on fiduciary process and litigation protection. Will it actually move the needle? Read our analysis to find out.

Representatives from the money management and private capital industries formed Washington-based advocacy groups like the Institute for Portfolio Alternatives and the Defined Contribution Alternatives Association, which were at the center of dialogue with federal officials and lawmakers to expand access to employer-sponsored benefit programs regulated by ERISA, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974.

They found a friendly ear in the Trump administration. Regulators with the Employee Benefits Security Administration, which enforces retirement benefit law, made plain in the new proposal their desire to give retirement plan fiduciaries maximum leeway in formulating financial products for their beneficiaries.

In essence, the agency aims to shield the retirement plan industry from litigation in pursuit of enhanced investment returns.

“The fiduciaries, not Washington bureaucrats or plaintiff lawyers, determine what investments belong in retirement plans,” Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer wrote in a Wall Street Journal op-ed outlining the proposal.

One of its key provisions is to provide safe harbor for fiduciaries as long as their investment selection is grounded in a “duty of prudence,” a legal standard for diligence that takes into account risk, return, liquidity and other attributes to determine appropriate strategies. A plan sponsor meets this bar if they act with the care and skill expected of a hypothetical prudent person.

“If finalized in its current form, this standard could reduce the risk of lawsuits tied to including higher-cost, more complex alternative investments,” Morningstar analysts Jason Kephart and Janet Yang Rohr wrote in a research note about the government’s proposed rules. Morningstar is PitchBook’s parent company.

The new framework drew kudos for taking a neutral stance on which asset classes can be added to 401(k) plans, and instead attempting to codify standards and processes that determine if plans pass the duty-of-prudence test. But it still leaves room for disputes over any kind of asset’s performance or the management fees attached to it.

“From the litigation perspective, it doesn’t solve the problem, which is, quite frankly, rampant out there,” said Brian Benjet, a DLA Piper lawyer specializing in employee benefits. “To the extent that any asset class performs poorly, or some segment of an asset class performs poorly, no matter the underlying cause, it will provoke litigation, and class-action litigation. That’s just the way it is.”

According to Benjet, even when the duty of prudence is met, courts over the years have allowed plaintiffs to plead their case when they allege that an investment has underperformed against some benchmark of their choosing. The new Labor Department rules, he said, don’t address what benchmark should be used, and lawyers are looking to see whether the courts define that in the future.

A pending Supreme Court ruling in a class-action suit may add some clarity on the issue. In a lawsuit claiming breach of fiduciary duty against Intel, some retirement plan participants alleged that the chip giant’s 401(k) program was mismanaged by including higher-cost, opaque alternative assets in a target-date fund.

The high court is expected to rule on whether federal law governing retirement plans provides a “meaningful benchmark” requirement that has to be met for legal claims based on fund underperformance to proceed.

The Labor Department’s framework for investment selection may give plan sponsors some legal cover, but it largely ignores performance monitoring. It doesn’t address a potential plaintiff’s argument that even if an asset was prudently selected, the plan sponsor should remove it quickly once its performance falters. That’s where much of the litigation risk remains, Benjet says, but the government’s new guidance punts on it.

Sign up for The Daily Pitch newsletter

Learn about our editorial standards.