Switch at a railroad track

Featured image by Fhm/Getty Images

Private Credit

A ‘tale of two markets’ in private credit emerges as fundamentals diverge – S&P

The downgrade-to-upgrade ratio of borrowers with credit estimates has jumped to 1.8x, the highest since Q2 2024.

Many of the strongest private credit borrowers have continued to improve their fundamentals, according to S&P Global Ratings, though pockets of weakness and a growing gap between the best and worst borrowers tell a more nuanced “tale of two markets.”

The analysis was conducted based on data collected from private credit borrowers with credit estimates. Credit estimates are indications of a likely credit rating on an unrated entity, which S&P provides for some private credit borrowers whose loans are held in CLOs.

The downgrade-to-upgrade ratio among borrowers with a credit estimate from the agency jumped to 1.8x, the highest ratio since Q2 2024, according to a Nov. 20 report from S&P.

Fifty borrowers, representing more than half of the downgrades made during the quarter, were sent into the ‘ccc’ category, from ‘b-‘ or above previously. (S&P denotes credit estimates in lower case to distinguish them from credit ratings, though they share the same scale.)

“Weaker borrowers continue to face pressures on both revenue and margins, as well as a still-high cost of financing relative to the pandemic era,” S&P analysts wrote.

“Although selective defaults have declined recently, the number of traditional defaults has gradually picked up since 2022 as weaker issuers have less runway given pressure on their liquidity,” they added.

Software sector businesses stood out as a bright spot, according to the report. S&P has tracked 18 downgrades for software companies so far in 2025, against 32 upgrades. Healthcare companies and professional service businesses also outperformed the average downgrade-to-upgrade ratio.

The construction and engineering sector, by contrast, has a downgrade-to-upgrade ratio of 7.0x, and the hotel, restaurants and leisure sector had a ratio of 5.0x, in line with trading companies and distributors. Each has faced headwinds in 2025, including cost pressures and labor shortages, as well as first-order tariff impacts for traders and distributors.

At the same time, across all borrowers, the median cash interest coverage ratio improved to 1.69x, from 1.61x at the end of 2024. Revenue and EBITDA rose year-over-year for 72% and 62% of companies, respectively, and the proportion of companies generating negative EBITDA declined to 17%, from 24% at the end of 2024.

S&P also noted private credit’s increasing competitiveness among the largest class of financings.

“While borrowers on the margin have favored the BSL market this year, the direct lending market has still been able to finance an increasing number of larger borrowers as the private market continues to develop,” S&P analysts wrote.

In the first three quarters this year, the share of borrowers in S&P’s credit estimate universe with more than $1 billion in debt increased to 9%, from 6% in 2024 and 2% in 2021.

S&P said that it expects the trend of large issuers turning to private credit will continue, albeit moderated by an ebb and flow between the private credit and BSL markets.

The report, titled “Private Credit Shows Resilience Despite Pockets Of Weakness,” was authored by S&P analysts including Tyler Udland, Stephen Anderberg, Ramki Muthukrishnan and Evan Gunter.

Featured image by Fhm/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.