gettyimages-1158192539.jpg
Leveraged Loans

After 20-year boom, leveraged loan asset class shrinks amid M&A drought, volatility

Tightening credit conditions have triggered a rare cycle for leveraged loans: The asset class is shrinking.

Want to see more? Fill out the form below.

I agree to PitchBook’s privacy policy

Tightening credit conditions have triggered a rare cycle for leveraged loans: The asset class is shrinking.

For the last two decades, the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index has enjoyed staggering growth, nearly tripling in size since the Global Financial Crisis alone. Rapidly rising interest rates and declining risk appetite, however, have derailed M&A activity over the past 18 months, cutting off a key supply source for new loan assets. Bond-for-loan and private credit take-outs have further eroded supply.

Smaller size
The Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index has shed $30 billion since its all-time peak in September 2022. On a rolling twelve-month basis, outstanding loan volume has declined every single month since April.

index-size-1a.png

Prior to the $10 billion contraction in 2023, the index contracted in only one other year in the post-GFC period.

The average facility size in the loan market has declined, as well. This was $920 million in mid-October, down from a peak of $954 million in May 2022. The number of jumbo-sized M&A deals has dropped — only 16 new loans over $1 billion have launched this year, down from 40 in 2022 and 84 in 2021.

index-size-2.png

Graying universe
With fewer transactions in the market, the population of leveraged loans has aged. Tighter credit conditions and the disincentive to retire debt is keeping repayment rates near recent lows. For single-B rated index loans, the average age has ballooned to 27.52 months. Five years ago, the average loan age was 13.75 months. The current reading is the highest for single-B rated issuers since LCD began tracking this metric on a monthly basis in 2014, and it tops all full-year readings since 2010.

index-size-3.png

The older a loan, the higher its propensity to default. Among loans to have entered the index since 1998, only 1.4% defaulted within one year of origination. By year four, this increases to 5.5%, LCD data show.

index-size-4.png

Repayment lows
Leveraged companies are not paying down existing loans at anywhere near the pace they once did.

Only 15.8% of loans outstanding in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index that were outstanding as of 12 months ago had been repaid by the end of September 2023. This was up from April’s 12.8%, the lowest reading since 2009, but was just one half the 31.7% historical average.

While refinancing has increased in 2023, prepayment activity has dwindled as a result of declining sponsor exits in PE portfolios.

index-size-5.png

The ramifications of falling repayments extend beyond the aging of the loan population. Fewer loan repayments translate to lower principal collections for CLOs — the main buying base for leveraged loans. This, in turn, results in fewer proceeds for amortization for deals that have left reinvestment, potentially weighing on returns if investors are left with aged loans paying lower spreads, Street analysts point out.

Quality mix
On the ratings side, the share of B-minus rated companies seemed to peak last year. After jumping from 19% of the index at year end 2019, to 29% at the end of 2022, the share of B-minus rated companies in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index fell off to 27% by mid-October.

Nevertheless, amid continuing downgrades, the share of companies in all of the “C” ratings brackets — deemed highly speculative by rating agencies — has grown to nearly 8%, from 5% in 2021, and 6% in 2022.

index-size-6.png

Some of the index’s biggest historical growth industries have fallen off the most. With the slowdown in dealmaking, and with large loans taken out and refinanced via private credit, the Software industry — a driver of M&A volume in recent years — has seen its index share fall by $3.7 billion since the end of last year. The biggest decliner, however, has been the Media sector, which shed $5.3 billion during the period.

index-size-7.png

Bucking the trend, Machinery and Specialty Retail have added roughly $4 billion and $3.5 billion, respectively, to the index.

The market contraction has not moved the needle on issuer concentration. The post-GFC boon years brought significant dilution in the size of top-10 issuers as a share of market outstandings. In 2009, for example, the top 10 issuers represented 16% of the market. By 2022, this had fallen to 5.5%, and despite the decreasing market size, it remains just above 5%.

index-size-8.png

A final word on this unusual cycle: In addition to stifled M&A activity, a shift in funding sources has accentuated the declining size of the loan index. Borrower companies have increasingly turned to the private credit market to finance transactions that in the past would have been done in the syndicated loan market, LCD data show.

London-based payments group Finastra via a $4.8 billion unitranche refinanced its $2.6 billion (original size) loan out of the US index. That transaction was the largest takeout of an institutional loan by private credit on record, by a large margin, according to LCD.

LCD data shows that the private credit transactions in 2023 have covered a range of uses — including, add-on acquisitions, recapitalizations, and dividends. That is, borrowers have turned to private credit for deals that those same companies and private equity sponsors had previously executed in the syndicated loan market.

On the buyout side, private credit deals supporting US buyouts have exceeded syndicated transactions for buyouts at an eye-catching ratio 6.26-to-1 in 2023, through September.

Bond-for-loan takeouts are also chipping away at the index. LCD has tracked $22 billion of bonds issued to take out institutional term loans so far this year, versus $3.2 billion in 2022.

Featured image by Westend61 / Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.