In the wake of several high-profile blowups in private credit, some managers have taken steps to improve transparency in an asset class known for its illiquidity and opacity.
Apollo Global Management announced last month that it had made daily asset-level pricing available for various private credit assets, including direct lending and asset-backed finance—a move the investment firm said is meant to “give investors greater visibility into their holdings.”
The firm didn’t specify which investors this initiative targets, but the shift comes as it courts a range of new investors, including wealthy individuals and regular retirees.
Daily pricing is one step in a broader plan to make private loans tradable, pairing it with standardized identifiers and a growing secondary market built around its own trading desk. The firm fully expects other lenders to follow its lead.
“Our goal is to make buying and selling of private assets as easy and familiar as possible,” said Marc Rowan, Apollo CEO, on the firm’s latest earnings call. “We will start with credit.”
Rowan’s belief in daily pricing is not unusual. Many argue that retail investors are used to seeing current pricing data on their brokerage apps and expect the same from alternative investments. Price transparency, combined with greater liquidity, could blow open the retail market across private credit, private equity and beyond, they argue.
So far, the private credit managers PitchBook spoke with about daily pricing demonstrated more skepticism than enthusiasm.
Some lenders agree that more frequent reporting gives investors added insight into their portfolios, but they question whether daily marks add much, especially for investors in retail funds that allow subscriptions and redemptions only monthly or quarterly.
Some took a harder line, arguing the move does more to offer investors psychological comfort than to inform them.
“It sounds good, but that’s precision, that’s not accuracy,” said Theodore Koenig, the chairman and chief executive at Monroe Capital, at an industry conference in October.
Prices for private credit loans are more reliable when they reflect borrowers’ updated financial information and are checked against independent valuation providers’ estimates, lenders told PitchBook.
Daily marks pegged to public benchmarks are likely to reflect only how macro shifts, such as interest rate moves or industry trends, move loan prices, rather than the loan’s credit quality.
Without a third-party valuation to check against, a fund manager can pick whatever benchmark it wants, which can introduce subjectivity, said William Sacher, the head of private credit at Adams Street.
Apollo disclosed that daily prices are estimated fair value based on its internal methodology and benchmarked to relevant public market data, such as comparable security prices, credit analytics, sector spreads, interest rate observations and borrower financial information.
Apollo declined to comment further.
Market-wide adoption?
Private credit doesn’t change hands daily. Fund managers typically strike marks periodically, and many of these lenders lean on an independent valuation provider to verify the math.
A valuation typically weighs market moves, industry trends and a borrower’s latest information, including its financials; amendments to the credit agreement; material changes at the business such as a sale or the move to exercise a PIK toggle, according to Brian Garfield, the global head of the portfolio valuations practice at Lincoln International, which provides valuation services to private credit funds.
Fund managers retain the final say on their marks; estimates from independent valuation providers like Lincoln are only one input determining the prices, Garfield added.
When a borrower’s performance slips or market spreads widen, the loan should be marked down accordingly—although critics, including bond investing giant PIMCO, argue that sometimes these marks don’t move in lockstep with public market valuations and have been slow to respond to market stress.
The valuation process is costly, and doing it on a daily cadence is out of reach for many.
An executive at a publicly traded BDC that extends loans to lower-middle-market companies said even running monthly marks would strain their team. The firm demands its borrowers deliver full financial statements every month. Each quarter, it marks every loan and sends it to its auditor for review. Meanwhile, third-party valuation firms independently review about two-thirds of its portfolio.
“Every quarter, we have all of our analysts, senior associates and associates working on all of the financials, loading it into our systems and creating an updated report on how the company is performing,” the person said. “If we were doing it on a daily or monthly basis, this company would basically be frozen all the time, just doing valuations.”
Frequency vs. substance
Some managers think that the push for daily pricing is solving for the wrong kind of transparency. Individual investors often only see the marks when they should see the inputs that went into producing them.
Sacher of Adams Street suggests that retail-facing private credit funds expand the scope of disclosure in their filings and reveal metrics that determine the credit quality of a loan portfolio, such as the underlying borrower’s loan-to-value ratio, interest coverage ratio and free cash flow.
“You are hard-pressed to find them in a typical BDC report,” Sacher said. “And they wouldn’t be able to draw on a daily basis.”
The amount of information institutional investors receive about their private credit holdings stands in stark contrast to the insight that wealthy and affluent individuals get into their BDC investments.
Daniel Gurvich, a managing director at private lender Beach Point Capital, said institutional backers of the firm’s private credit funds typically receive confidential loan tapes disclosing each borrower’s financial performance, such as revenue, EBITDA, leverage and liquidity position, along with key loan terms. If a valuation doesn’t square with their own analysis, they can request a memo and have the manager walk them through their thinking.
“They would have fundamental stats to assess and take a view on portfolio performance,” Gurvich said. “For them, the mark is one data point into understanding how each borrower is performing and how their overall portfolios perform.”
Recent News
Slush investors point to hardware and deep tech for defensibility
Meet the 300+ investors who bet on Anthropic before everyone else
Learn about our editorial standards.