Trading levels of troubled loans are as low as they’ve been since the Federal Reserve began raising interest rates in March 2022, pointing to potentially lower recovery rates down the road.
According to Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index data, the average bid price of loans in the below 80 bucket — a borderline for distress in the asset class — fell to 59 in April, matching the lowest month-end reading in three years.
This is down from 60 in March, and reflects a significant decline in the valuation of distressed loan facilities since the post-pandemic average bid price high of 69 in June 2022.
Furthermore, at the height of distressed loan market volume in late 2022, the average bid in the below 80 cohort was in a 65-66 range.
April’s average bid of 59 in the distressed bucket of the loan index sits relatively close to where loans typically are bid at the time of default, according to LCD’s data of loans closed between 1995 and Q1 2023.
Of the 418 defaulted loans LCD has tracked from origination, the average bid price at the time of default was 57.
Differing methods
Recovery rates, of course, can be measured in a variety of ways.
In its simplest form, the trading price of the instrument is taken 30 days after default.
However, determining the best approach to calculate actual recovery is difficult because there is no one true method.
LCD conducts its recovery studies based on analysis by S&P Global’s LossStats, where the nominal recovery value can be calculated one of three ways:
- The trading price of pre-petition debt at emergence;
- The settlement pricing (earliest public market values of the new instruments a debt holder receives in exchange for the pre-petition instruments);
- The liquidity pricing event (or the final cash value of the new instruments that were acquired in exchange for the pre-petition instrument).
Using discounted recoveries, which values the nominal recovery back to the last date at which a cash payment was made on the pre-petition debt (thereby eliminating the noise of time), the average discounted trading price recovery value in the LossStats database was 53.82 for term loans defaulting between 2007 and 2022.
This aligns closely with the average trading price of 53.06 cents on the dollar 30 days post default.
In addition to trading off potential post-default enterprise values, a number of factors can influence average trading prices of distressed credits, including credit conditions and sentiment around volatility, and market access with respect to supply and demand.
In this regard, the largest difference between the April sample of loans below 80, and the cohort in December 2022 can be found in the ratings composition.
In the current cohort, only 16% of loans (by outstanding volume) are from companies rated B-minus or higher. This compares to 57% in December 2022.
In essence, when breaking down by ratings, what’s left are the companies that, for the most part, do not have access to traditional capital markets.
Case in point, LCD data shows that of this year’s heady pace of refinancings through the end of April (totaling nearly $103 billion for the third highest reading for any comparable period on record) 98.6% refinanced term loans from companies rated B-minus or higher at S&P.
Furthermore, companies being given breathing room via amend-and-extend transactions, where a company approaches existing lenders rather than refinancing into a new credit (which would require marking the entire loan to a new market of lenders), were by-and-large not immediate default candidates. Roughly 84% of the amendments completed in the year to date are rated B-minus or higher, following 82% in 2023.
By default
Looking at the December 2022 sample of loans bid below 80, 22% were later recorded as a payment default in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index, and thus left the performing index calculation, and 17% would eventually be involved in a liability management transaction deemed a Selective Default or Default by S&P Global Ratings, and recorded by LCD in its blended default rate.
Ultimately, between the refinancings and payment defaults of the “haves and have nots,” what is left in the April cohort is a greater share of companies in the double-C or triple C-ratings bracket (77%), versus 41% in December 2022. While access to the primary broadly syndicated loan markets is starting to normalize, riskier triple-C rated credits will likely have to find other avenues to address their financing needs. Direct lenders could provide a solution, as was the case for high-end fitness facility operator Equinox Group.
A final note on recovery calculations: while trading price recovery levels at emergence align closely with trading prices at 30-days post default, recovery rates can vary widely when using other methodologies. In the 2007 to 2022 default sample used in this report, recovery rates, where settlement pricing (the earliest public market values of the new instruments a debt holder receives in exchange for the pre-petition instruments) was used, the average discounted recovery rate for term loans was 74.97. There were too few observations in this drill-down for the liquidity pricing event methodology.
Peter Dazeley/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.