businessman using a laptop to check stock market data

Featured image: Thana Prasongsin/Getty Images

CLOs

Brevity of sell-off frustrates value-hunting European CLO managers

The April 2 announcement on US tariffs shook financial markets — but not enough for many CLO managers, with the window to buy the dip closing sooner than anticipated.

Want to see more? Fill out the form below.

I agree to PitchBook’s privacy policy

The April 2 ‘Liberation Day’ announcement on US tariffs shook financial markets, but not enough for the taste of many European CLO managers. Market volatility in Europe created buying opportunities, but also wider bid/offer spreads. Even more frustrating, the window to “buy the dip” closed sooner than anticipated.

“The sell-off was broad-based for only two or three days, and usually just during two or three hours on those days,” says Ben Rothberg, CLO portfolio manager at Arini. “This was a short window where you could pick names from your target list through the offers. It felt that the market was offered, not just the usual idiosyncratic names.”

Adeel Shafiqullah, head of European CLO Management at Sculptor Capital, notes that the “magnitude of the secondary price moves was nowhere as steep as during the Covid-driven dislocation of March 2020, or the rates-driven sell-off in 2022 when re-pricing occurred more broadly across sectors.”

EUR selloff chart 1b.png

Cash is king
What’s more, not all CLOs are equal in times of market turmoil as some have capacity to invest, while others have to sell loans or bonds to raise the cash needed to pick up cheap paper.

Bid/offer spreads in the secondary leveraged loan market widened to a range of roughly two points, compared to roughly half a point in regular market conditions, while loan prices generically dropped anywhere from 2-5 points in early April, depending on the issuer, sector, and tranche size, with some higher-beta names lower, Shafiqullah estimates. “However, for CLOs that are typically fully invested at all times, trading was more challenging due to the wider bid-ask spreads.”

According to another manager, dealers moved to 2-4 points on their bid-offer spreads. “We were able to identify some people still willing to trade at par or above and move out of some lower-margin names in favour of cash,” he explains.

Hayfin Capital Management was also busy during that brief period of volatility. “We saw the market volatility and price dispersion as an opportunity on several fronts,” says Gina Germano, partner and senior investment manager at Hayfin.

“We invested cash into loans trading below par and reduced fixed-rate exposure for FRNs at attractive prices, which boosted the weighted average spread of our vehicles notably.” Hayfin opted to de-risk positions that could be affected by low growth triggered by economic uncertainty and tariffs, while adding high-quality positions at better pricing, she adds.

Shopping list
Several managers were waiting in the wings, and had a shopping list ready by April 2. Sculptor’s Shafiqullah notes that “given the tight secondary market dynamics since the start of the year, the volatility in early April presented an opportunity for managers that had quickly refreshed their fundamental credit views to move up in credit quality and source loans at attractive levels.”

Arini, which during this time strategically switched from being underinvested to being overinvested, had some cash to invest in early April — a new issue was not fully ramped, and the CLO manager also negotiated some higher limits for a few ‘safe names’ with its warehouse provider.

The team already had a set list of safe names that were insulated from US tariffs and were not reliant on discretionary spending. The firm fine-tuned its strategy on April 5, and implemented it on April 7.

There seemed to be some consensus in the market that spreads could widen further, and nobody wanted to go long, Arini’s Ben Rothberg noted. But the rebound came sooner than most anticipated.

The somewhat muted reaction in loans in the midst of the wider market sell-off is largely explained by the dominance of CLOs, meaning the majority of the loan investor base is under no pressure to sell, CLO managers point out.

Another reason the sell-off was mostly contained is that March had been volatile, and many dealers had already de-risked. Moreover, several new CLOs had been priced at the end of February and were still ramping in March, thereby providing technical support to the market.

Despite the market uncertainty — especially around April 4 — bidders never fully disappeared. “The sell-off in loans was contained when compared with bonds,” commented a trader. “For each half-point move lower, buyers emerged.”

Meanwhile, the newsflow from the US improved gradually, and some CLO managers that had raised cash in early April had to redeploy this cash later that month, unwittingly contributing to the quick market rebound.

Bifurcated market
Despite these supportive factors, the April volatility did compound an already bifurcated market. Cyclical names — including those from the packaging and chemicals segments — had been unloved for some time, while the market remains nervous on consumer-facing names, explains Gianluca Consoli, portfolio manager at PGIM Fixed Income. “Those credits haven’t returned to pre-Liberation Day levels, which emphasizes the trend towards quality,” he notes.

EUR selloff chart 2.png

CLO managers only sold roughly €1.2 billion of loans in April compared to €3.5 billion in January, €5.3 billion in February, and €4.7 billion in March, according to BofA Global Research. In a report dated May 19, the bank’s strategists attribute the substantial decline in April on this measure to the pause in primary loan supply during the first two weeks following Liberation Day and CLO managers’ reluctance to sell loans at deflated prices. The limited CLO manager sales that did occur during April were mostly in the 98-100 cash price range, they note.

Cherry-picking
A sample of over 160 European CLO investor reports shows managers were active during the first two weeks of April, selectively buying and selling, according to data provided by DealX and analysed by LCD News. There were some purchases of Altice International/Altice Financing’s E+500 term loan due October 2027 just below 80, as well as a few disposals of Altice France’s 4% notes due July 2029 and Altice Financing’s 3% notes due 2028.

KKR picked up 5.375% notes due October 2029 from Solenis (Olympus Water US Holding Corp), rated B-/B3, at 85.50 for its Avoca XII and Avoca XVI CLOs. This was roughly 5 points below marks seen for this bond, rated Caa2, at the end of March and end of April.

Sona Asset Management, meanwhile, bought Virgin Media O2 (Vmed O2 Uk Financing) 3.25% notes due January 2031 at 87.50 on April 7, when prices were bottoming out.

EUR selloff chart 3a.png

Tricky timing
But timing the sales is no easy task, and with hindsight, the quick rebound made some sales look hasty. For example, Blackstone managed to purchase MasOrange (Lorca Finco E+275 term loan B5), rated BB/Ba3, at 97.25 on April 4, according to Glenbrook Park CLO’s April investor report. Another manager bought the same loan on April 10 at 99.00. This loan traded a few times just above 99 at the end of March, and by mid-May it was wrapped around par.

Breitling’s TLB due October 2028, rated single-B, was meanwhile sold by CLO managers on April 3 in a 93.75-95.00 range, but on April 7 the sale price for that loan was 91.00, before rebounding to 94.25 on April 10. The TLB had changed hands at 97.75 on March 18, but there were also trades slightly above 93 in the following days. The loan went on to dip in early May, but has recovered to roughly 93/94.

In the case of Barings Euro CLO 2023-1 — a CLO that’s slated for refinancing — the investor report dated April 16 shows some brisk trading. Indeed, seven sales were made in the April 7 to April 10 period, in a price range of 97.375 to 100.800. Meanwhile, 25 purchases were made during the April 3 to April 15 period, at prices between 93.50 and 99.75.

In the spotlight
In their May 19 report, BofA strategists note that some names have been in the spotlight for a while, and that price declines started well before April.

For example, the facility B of Seqens (Sirona Bidco), rated triple-C, sold off sharply in April, but CLO managers had already sold substantial volumes in the fourth quarter of 2024 and the first quarter of 2025, BofA said. Bain Capital CLO Euro 2023-1’s investor report dated April 10, 2025, shows a sale of Seqens’ facility B at 78 on April 4 (this facility was marked at 86.2 in the March 10).

Seqens is an SK Capital-backed maker of pharmaceutical ingredients, and was downgraded by Moody’s in November by one notch to Caa1 on negative outlook, with the agency citing a slower-than-expected recovery to the firm’s EBITDA and weakening liquidity.

BofA noted that in the case of Cerba, prices peaked around the end of February and dropped sharply during March as investors anticipated a potential LME. Cerba’s E+375 term loan due June 2028 (Chrome Bidco), rated B-/Caa1, was sold by a manager on April 9 at 79. This loan was traded a few times by CLO managers around 86 in mid-March. Poorly received results at the start of this week brought a bumpy week for the loan, which was in a rough 77.625/78.625 market by May 21.

Under pressure
Sales of distressed name Colisee spiked in March 2025, but this credit has remained under intense pressure, being the top loser among European secondary loans in the March 28 to April 11 period, according to LCD. Some Colisee (Cobalt Bidco repriced B loan) was sold at levels of 55.85 and 57 on April 8, having been sold around 67 on April 3.

This TLB changed hands in the 80s in early March, and in the 60s in the middle of March within a relatively wide range. A few sub-60 trades occurred for the name around March 20 and 21. S&P downgraded the France-based nursing homes operator’s term loan B to D (default), from CCC- on May 12, and upgraded it back to CCC- on May 14.

Sources report decent activity in the name this week, following reports that sponsor EQT is planning a €220 million equity injection into the group in return for a 36% write-down in debt. By Wednesday, the loan was up by as much as eight points in a mid-60s area.

Babilou’s TLB-4 was also among the top decliners, and it raised the interest of some CLO managers. Babilou’s Babar Bidco facility B4, rated triple-C, was purchased by CLO managers on April 2 at 88.5, while King Street bought the name at 87 on April 4 for its Rockford Tower Europe CLO 2021-2 deal. That loan changed hands in the mid-90s from February to the last week of March.

The group’s downgrade to CCC+ from S&P in the week of the Liberation Day tariff announcements helped fuel the week’s sell-off, as did a downgrade by Moody’s to Caa1 for Rodenstock, and poorly received results from House of HR.

As a CLO manager put it, losses from April have generally been retraced, but triple-C names are trading according to their credit story.

Volatility in the leveraged finance market may be back soon, as negotiations on tariffs with key US partners may stall or collapse. It’s still unclear whether the best strategy in early April was to step in or just sit still, but the small gains made in early April could prove valuable.

As Arini’s Rothberg puts it, “CLOs don’t lend themselves to big, outsized bets.” In early April, Rothberg says Arini maintained discipline and added small amounts in targeted names, for the purpose of accommodating further volatility, which resulted in small increments of par build. “Now we are looking how to reinvest these returns and how to further protect our portfolios from potential downside,” he concludes.

— Michael Rae and David Cox contributed to this analysis.

Featured image: Thana Prasongsin/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.