The gap between direct lending and broadly syndicated loan market spreads has grown to its widest point since 2023, with banks holding a clear lead by volume in winning new-issue LBOs.
Direct lending spreads have widened since the year began, following a wave of software pessimism and redemption pressures that led lenders to make fewer new investments. In Q3, the average direct lending spread on new-issue LBOs was 520 bps, up from 494 bps in Q2, according to LCD data.
Among BSL investors, LBO financings are in high demand, pushing spreads lower. At the same time, the average credit quality of borrowers has improved, with issuers generally carrying less debt and healthier interest coverage.
BSL spreads on new LBOs declined to just 307 bps in Q3, down from 332 bps in Q2. Broadly syndicated lenders are being paid less for risk on LBO loans than at any point since 2007.
“There has been a lot of activity this year in the public market,” said Vivek Bantwal, global co-head of private credit for Goldman Sachs Asset Management, speaking at a conference in October.
“There have been a few examples of recent LBOs done in the broadly syndicated loan market where the first-lien term loan might have launched at 300 or 325 over, and ended up clearing at 250 bps over,” Bantwal said.
In Q3, 41% of LBO-related term loans tightened pricing during syndication, according to LCD Research.
In January, a $7.25 billion TLB for the medical technology company Hologic priced at S+225, the tightest spread for a B+/B1 buyout borrower since the GFC.
Meanwhile, more than two-thirds of LBOs completed in the private credit market in Q3 featured spreads at or above 500 bps, according to LCD data. The market has shifted from its low-water mark in Q1, during which many borrowers were able to secure spreads as low as S+450.
Given the limited volume of LBOs reaching completion, market participants say that deals from more desirable sectors or with stronger credit stories benefit from healthy competition among private credit lenders. Some “A+” credits are still able to achieve pricing at S+475, even as spreads on average have widened.
With such a gap in pricing, it should come as no surprise that the broadly syndicated loan market has increasingly been winning new LBO volume against direct lenders.
In the three months ended Oct. 31, broadly syndicated lenders financed $24.25 billion in new-issue LBO debt. Direct lenders financed just $9.34 billion of new LBOs, the lowest three-month total since 2020.
Direct lenders continue to lead by count, rather than volume, although that gap has narrowed since the year began.
As it wins share among new-issue LBOs, the BSL market is also taking out existing private credit debt. BSL lenders poached a record $12 billion of direct lending deals in Q3.
Among those deals poached by the broadly syndicated market was a $4.1 billion refinancing for the contract development and manufacturing organization (CDMO) Catalent, which wrapped in August. Pricing on the dollar portion of the cross-border term loan, led by JPMorgan, was S+300; the deal refinanced a private credit loan priced at S+500.
For more information on the state of competition between the private credit and broadly syndicated loan markets, check out LCD’s latest US Private Credit Monitor.
ANDREY DENISYUK/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.