Stack of One Hundred Dollar Bills

Alan Schein/Getty Images

Credit

Deep Dive: Are credit investors whistling past stagflation?

Prices are rising faster and employers are hiring more slowly than the Federal Reserve would like.

Over the past few years, the financial press has speculated about the possibility of the US economy entering a period of stagflation. The term alarms investors who recall the damage to the US economy and capital markets caused by the last serious bout of stagflation, which spanned from the early 1970s to the early 1980s.

But what exactly is stagflation, and should credit investors be concerned about it today?

Portmanteau
Stagflation is a portmanteau of economic stagnation and price inflation, two metrics that have been generating concerning data points lately.

The most recent US inflation reading, released by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) on Oct. 24, showed headline inflation at an annual rate of 3%, above the Federal Reserve target of 2%. While not nearly as bad as full-year 2022’s 8% reading (according to the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis), inflation has remained stubbornly above the Fed’s target, and economists generally predict the Trump administration’s tariff policies will keep prices elevated.

Job growth, meanwhile, has slowed to a near standstill since April. The BLS reported that job creation in the US was negative 13,000 in June, positive 79,000 in July and positive 22,000 in August. The BLS also noted that the unemployment rate in August was 4.3%, up from 4.2% in July and 4.0% in January.

With the government shutdown delaying September’s official employment data, recent reports using alternative data sources indicate that the jobs picture has probably changed little.

In short, prices are rising faster and employers are hiring more slowly than the Federal Reserve would like. But while inflation and unemployment are worse than ideal, the numbers don’t come close to the 1970s stagflation data points.

1970s
Investors are quick to explain away the 1970s stagflation by pointing to the period’s two oil embargoes, in 1973 and 1979. But that isn’t the whole story. Inflation started rising in the mid-1960s, as shown in the graph below. The headline consumer price index (CPI) broke above 2.0% on a monthly basis in 1966 and reached 6.4% in 1970, three years before the first embargo.

Deep Dive 1.png

The 1960s-era inflation was an outgrowth of rapid US economic growth, propelled in part by the huge material needs of the Vietnam War and President Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society legislation, according to a research paper from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Back then, the Fed saw its mandate as ensuring full employment while keeping prices stable, essentially the “dual mandate” of today, but without the formal mission statement spelled out in the 1978 Humphrey-Hawkins Act (formally the Full Employment and Balanced Growth Act).

The Fed’s dual mandate forces its members to choose one or the other as its primary enemy, because monetary policy that helps employment generally exacerbates inflation, and vice versa. During the 1970s, until Paul Volcker took over as Fed chair in 1979, the central bank leaned toward combating unemployment. That meant allowing inflation to run hotter than officials desired.

However, that was an acceptable risk, given that supporting Fed policy in the 1970s was the belief in the validity of the Phillips Curve, an economic theory that posited a somewhat negative correlation between inflation and unemployment. In simple terms, the Phillips Curve predicted that lower unemployment would drive demand for goods and services, thereby increasing inflation.

At the time, to spur the economy, the Fed increased the money supply. But while that demonstrably led to rising prices, the employment picture deteriorated.

Not helping matters were global oil prices. In 1973 and again in 1979, OPEC oil embargoes against the US and other countries, following turmoil in the Middle East, caused oil prices to triple the first time and nearly triple again the second time. Since oil is an ingredient in so much of US economic output — from plastics to gasoline — the embargoes drove US inflation higher still, and the unemployment rate followed it upward.

For context, in 1964, inflation was around 1.5% and unemployment 5%. By 1980, inflation neared 14.5% and unemployment was above 7.5%.

Deep Dive 2A.png

When Paul Volcker became Fed chair, he switched the Fed’s focus toward fighting inflation, specifically by taking action to limit money supply growth. Though this pushed the US economy into back-to-back recessions in 1980 and 1981, it ultimately broke the inflationary upward spiral as the economy improved.

But credit investors took a pounding on their fixed-coupon positions. For instance, holders of 10-year US Treasuries watched their yields go from a low of 5.60% in April 1971 to a high of over 15.5% in 1981, decimating mark-to-market valuations.

Deep Dive 3.png

Dynamics today
While today’s environment doesn’t exactly mirror the 1970s, it’s not altogether different, either. For starters, Jerome Powell’s Fed has made it clear that unemployment is currently the primary concern — as it was in the 1970s — and has lowered the target fed funds rate to stimulate the economy, which could give inflation room to rise.

Peter Cecchini, principal and head of research at asset manager Axonic Capital, argues that the US is already in a stagflationary period. He says the 3.0% headline CPI annual rate “stands in stark contrast to the slowdown in employment.” He notes that CPI excludes asset price inflation, including high (and rising) equity valuations, as well as the rise of gold and bitcoin prices.

Indeed, Fed Chair Powell said in prepared remarks at his Oct. 29 press conference, “We have upside risks to inflation, downside risks to employment, and this is a very difficult thing for a central bank.”

Cecchini also notes that economic metrics are coming in at low-growth ranges. Supporting that view, economist Mark Zandi of Moody’s said in a recent report that 22 US states are currently either in recession or close to it.

Given the US economic situation, a high-yield sell-side market source said he sees demand for bonds declining and prices falling as inflation fears inhibit investors from locking in yields. Since the Fed is also lowering interest rates, the result is a steepening of the US Treasury curve.

The source points out that as the curve steepens, if the economy remains resilient — even if it is growing at a slower rate than hoped for — lower short-term rates will lead to healthier leveraged companies, notwithstanding inflation.

That is, businesses leveraged through the broadly syndicated loan and private credit markets will see their debt carrying costs decline. Lower interest rates will not only free up cash flow for investment in growth but will also lead to higher valuations. That may enable private equity firms to sell portfolio companies and return cash to investors.

In summary, the sell-side source notes that even if stagflation is present, lower rates could extend companies’ financial runways until the US economic engine reaccelerates.

Alan Schein/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.