DOWN

Featured image: Eoneren/Getty Images

Distressed & Defaults

Deep Dive Revisited: Inverted yield curve may still have a story to tell

The four most recent US recessions were preceded by the inverted US Treasury yield curve going right-side-up.

Want to see more? Fill out the form below.

I agree to PitchBook’s privacy policy

On Sept 6, the US Treasury 10-year yield rose and stayed above the two-year Treasury yield for the first time since 2022, flipping right-side-up an inverted Treasury curve that had served as a recession warning since at least 1978.

While the US economy has not fallen into recession, history says it’s too soon for investors to lower their guard. In fact, the warning bells may have just gotten louder.

Backstory
On Sept. 18, the US Federal Reserve’s Federal Open Market Committee lowered its fed funds target rate by 50 bps from its peak of 5.25-5.5%, where it had been since July 2023. The move comes as investors consider whether the Fed can engineer a soft landing and avoid a recession.

A US recession has been a heightened investor concern since the 2/10 curve inverted in 2022, as every recession since 1980 was preceded by an inverted Treasury 2/10 yield curve. A chart from the US Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis graphically displaying the 10-year Treasury yield minus the 2-year Treasury yield, against recessionary periods (the grey bars) shows it clearly:

When the US two-year Treasury yield to maturity finished higher than the 10-year Treasury yield on April 1, 2022, for the first time since August 2019 (ahead of the 2020 pandemic recession), analysts were unsure how to interpret that curve inversion, since at the time, few saw a recession looming (see Deep Dive: The inverted Treasury yield curve – is it different this time?).

Beyond the possible differences, another significant relationship exists between the inverted two-year/10-year Treasury curve and subsequent recessions: before the last four recessions officially began, the inverted curve went right-side-up. That is, in every recession since 1990, the inversion flipped back to an upward sloping yield curve before the recession struck.

Coupled with the Fed’s target rate cut on Sept. 18, that is precisely where markets find themselves today.

Today’s story
In the six instances since 1978 where the two-year/10-year curve inverted then recession followed, the economic declines were never immediate. The table below provides time horizons.

LCD data shows that the shortest timespan from inversion to recession was 158 days, from August 2019 to February 2020, as the pandemic pummeled the US economy and asset markets alike.

The longest timespan from inversion to recession was 1,010 days, at the end of the decade-long 1990s bull market propelled by the dot-com asset bubble. At the time of writing, the time gap between the April 2022 inversion is 902 days and counting.

Regarding timing of the two-year/10-year curve’s flip back to right side up, as the table shows, the shortest time lapse from the yield curve inversion ending to the start of recession was 62 days, and the longest gap was 177 days, before the Global Financial Crisis.

Look-alike
Since the 2/10 yield curve inverted in April 2022, analysts have been wondering which prior inversion-recession period this present one most resembles. The 2001 recession appears to be a likely answer.

Two important similarities between 2001 and now are its length, and possible equity market frothiness. As for length, before the 2001 recession the 2/10 curve was inverted for 948 days, 80% longer than the next-longest period, while the latest inversion, 902 days, is nearly as long.

And regarding froth, the 2001 inversion was preceded by the tech-driven dot-com bubble, and many analysts see similarities with the recent all-things-AI adoration propelling equity markets higher.

The 2001 recession began 62 days after the 1998-2000 inverted curve righted itself. At this writing, we are 13 days since the most recent inverted curve un-inverted, so we have time.

Featured image: Eoneren/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.