Downtown Nashville, Tennessee Skyline from the Northeast Bank of the Cumberland River

Featured image: Jeremy Poland/Getty Images

Private Credit

Direct lenders assess private credit market at DealCatalyst/LSTA conference

One lender speaking at the conference likened the current market to a “feeding frenzy” for deals.

Attendees at the 2025 DealCatalyst US Private Credit Industry Conference, which was held in partnership with the LSTA, may have differing opinions on whether Florida beaches or Music City make for a better destination for a credit conference. (DealCatalyst, for its part, confirmed 2026 would bring the market back to Nashville.)

But they all seemed to agree they will need to wait some time for a pickup in M&A. Just how long a wait remains unclear. “Our backlog just keeps getting bigger and bigger and bigger,” an advisor said. “Eventually, the tsunami is going to hit.”

According to a poll taken at the conference, more than half of attendees in Nashville this year said M&A would return to historical levels in the first half of 2026. That could mean dealmakers will work double-time this summer to make up for the inactivity of recent months. But for actual deals closing, the next few months could be crickets.

“If deals trail processes by the typical 60-90 days, then we’re due for a slow July and August. At this rate, we’ll have the kind of Q4 we expected to have at the beginning of the year,” one panelist said.

There was no debate that pricing competition had been fierce. One lender likened the current market to a “feeding frenzy” for deals. Several lenders told the crowd of investors that middle market direct lending isn’t the relationship business it once was: For many deals, the main driver behind winning a deal is only the ability to beat fellow market participants on spread.

“How many deals did we lose because we tried to hold the line at S+500, or 525, as the market tilted?” a middle market panelist asked.

Upmarket, borrowers have won even greater concessions. Speaking to dynamics in the large-cap segment of the market, another panelist bluntly laid out how to win deals: “It’s about price. It’s about docs. Our teams will try to be brave, to eke out 25 basis points. I tell them, ‘Do you want to win the deal?’”

Though the market remains borrower-friendly, several middle-market lenders said they have seen covenant trends tilting in lenders’ favor to some degree since early April, when the Trump administration unveiled its tariff plans.

Also overheard in the corridors of the Omni Nashville Hotel, where much of the private credit market set up shop from May 12-13, in addition to discussions of souvenirs of cowboy hats and boots:

  • Most deals are being done around S+475 these days. Pricing is less differentiated, i.e., riskier deals are not being priced very differently from great deals as a result of heavy competition among lenders.
  • Traditional upper middle market lenders, who are desperate to deploy capital, are reaching lower into the market to get deal flow, with everything “north of $15M in EBITDA” considered fair game.
  • Many lenders are relying on refinancings and add-ons for activity, with sponsor sell-side backlog hovering at an all-time high.
  • Software is the “elephant in the room,” with many private credit lenders heavily or over-exposed to the sector. Some of these software companies, many of which are borrowers of recurring-revenue private credit loans, will face disruptions brought about by AI, with the historic moment seen as comparable to the demise of Blockbuster in terms of value destruction and low recoveries.
  • Logistics sector borrowers could be hurt badly (trucking, shipping) if trade softens due to tariffs.
  • Convergence of the broadly syndicated loan market and direct lending continues to mean more BSL terms entering direct lending documents, creating room for LMEs in private credit deals.
  • Some market participants are skeptical of bank partnerships, forcing borrowers into the unenviable task of working with two distinct investment committees. Partnerships themselves are likely to have mixed success.
  • Private credit secondaries investors note that there is a huge dispersion of marks among GPs, with some GPs marking everything at par until something goes wrong, and others being more aggressive with markdowns.
  • The secondary market for private credit loans is slowly evolving. Secondary market participants are sensitive to private equity sponsors’ reactions. Some private equity sponsors are more accepting of the trading of their portfolio companies’ debt, while some block any attempt to do so.

Featured image: Jeremy Poland/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.