Happy September! The month when the leaves turn, college football season kicks off and university endowments start releasing fiscal year return figures.
“We’re seeing some double-digit returns,” said Laura Wirick, a managing principal at LP consultant Meketa, where she advises public funds, endowments, foundations and pensions. “You’re definitely seeing an environment where the more public equity exposure you had, the stronger [the return].”
Subscribe to the newsletter here
In FY 2024, endowments across the US scored an average one-year annualized return of 11.2%, up from 7.7% the year prior, carried by a strong US economy, easing inflation and steady consumer spending, according to data from last year’s NACUBO-Commonfund study of endowments.
Tim Yates, president and CEO of Commonfund’s OCIO business, said he expects FY 2025 returns to land anywhere from 4%-13%.
So far, 2025 has been a uniquely challenging year for universities and their vast endowments. After years of shrinking PE and VC distributions, they were hit by federal funding cuts under the Trump administration, new excise taxes on select private endowments and a simmering legal battle between the White House and Harvard.
The federal cuts created pressure on endowments to increase their spending rates, the portion of an endowment’s returns used to support university operations.
Several institutions attempted to cushion the blows from lower private market returns in their portfolios by freeing up liquidity: Both Harvard and Yale offloaded billions of dollars worth of PE stakes on the secondary market.
Related read: PitchBook’s university endowment return tracker
While the Ivies report later in the season, some public university endowments have already posted their FY 2025 results. Ohio State University’s $8.6 billion endowment generated an 11.8% return for the one-year period ending June 30, 2025, exceeding its benchmark of 9.5%.
The endowment has a smaller—but significant—portion of its capital invested in private markets and alternatives relative to most Ivy League endowments, with 27% of its portfolio in PE and the rest in a mix of public equities, hedge funds, cash and infrastructure.
“You’re going to see the folks that have a lot of private markets exposure have slightly lower returns,” Wirick said.
Endowments, like those at Ivy League institutions, long benefited from established relationships with top-quartile alternative asset managers and growing private market portfolios. Harvard’s endowment, for example, one of those slated to report its FY 2025 results later this fall, had a 39% allocation to PE in FY 2024.
But that model is slowly unraveling, with a bulk of institutional capital locked up in PE and VC funds that have put off exits in an unfavorable pricing environment. Smaller endowments, like those at Baylor University and the University of Iowa, with more liquidity on hand and higher allocations to public equities, outperformed all but Brown among the Ivy League endowments in FY 2024.
In fact, in both 2023 and 2024, top-performing smaller endowments outperformed those with larger pools of capital, due to smaller institutions’ higher allocation to public equities, according to the NACUBO-Commonfund data. In 2025, consultants and outsourced chief investment officers expect this dynamic to continue.
“Based on the allocations, I would venture to guess that [2025] will be the third year in a row where this dynamic persists,” Yates said. “What will begin to garner some attention is that underperformance of the privates relative to public equity has now seeped into the three-year [return] numbers.”
What’s different about 2025, in terms of equity exposure, is that endowments with diversification across global equity markets— international, developed and emerging—will benefit most, Wirick added.
Despite shorter-term challenges to endowment returns, Yates noted that endowments are meant to last forever, and do their investing with longer 10- and 20-year performance markers in mind.
“There’s no endowment on the planet that targets a one-year or three-year return,” Yates said.
Larger endowments still have the advantage because while long-duration, long-natured investments may or may not outperform in any given year, Yates said, over time they “will generate the type of excess return that they need to support their missions.”
Historic Ohio Stadium, also known as The Shoe or Horseshoe , is located on the Ohio State University campus in Columbus, Ohio. College football is played here in the fall.
Featured image by aceshot/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.