While volatility sparked by the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank and the forced rescue of Credit Suisse in March appears to signal the start of another challenging era for banks, direct lending seems undeterred, with some sources predicting an exciting new vintage for the asset class.
Indeed, the strain threatening to spread through the financial sector is merely the latest in a series of challenges thrown at banks, with the impact of Covid-19 barely in the rearview mirror, and could leave them increasingly confined to ancillary roles in favor of private credit-provided deals, sources suggest.
“UBS and Credit Suisse have been smashed together, so there is one less large bank out there,” said one direct lender at the first PitchBook-LCD Private Credit Forum in London in March, adding that such developments represent “a great opportunity for direct lenders like us.”
What’s more, the collapse of banks in the US could have a minimal impact on private debt funds in Europe, which did not have major relationships with any of the now-insolvent US institutions, or any related lines or credit facilities in their funds or capital structures, sources explain.
Global view
Private credit still has to operate in the global economy, however, and so portfolio companies have to face the same headwinds as the wider corporate sector. In response, sources point out that private credit has evolved to focus on business-to-business borrowers, which means some of the risks that companies are grappling with elsewhere in consumer-facing segments might be less of an issue for funds.
But as private credit empires have grown rapidly they aren’t as nimble anymore, while much of this growth has come during what some are dubbing an “artificial environment” due to zero (or near-zero) interest rates. Now, the market is operating against a backdrop of higher rates and a more dynamic pricing environment. “This is good but also puts more pressure on lenders, and therefore we need to be more careful about leverage,” one direct lender explained. Furthermore, today’s European private credit market has to grapple with new issues, among them a general shortage of labor following the pandemic, and in the UK due to Brexit. This situation has contributed to an increase in costs, which private credit players have to pass through to their client base.
Golden ticket
Although market observers have been calling this recent period a “golden era” for private lenders, sources say the shift has been in play for a long time, dating back to the Global Financial Crisis. Moreover, direct lenders’ ability to provide bigger tickets is pushing up average syndicated deal sizes, and is making bank-provided first-lien loans more scarce.
Going back to 2009, tickets sized under €250 million represented 79% of first-lien institutional deals in the European broadly syndicated loan market that year, according to PitchBook | LCD data, with none sized at more than €1 billion. Fast-forward to 2021, and first-lien institutional tickets of less than €250 million represented just 8% of transactions, with a significant 20% portion sized at more than €1 billion. This data suggests smaller deals have increasingly moved from the coffers of banks to direct lenders.
And at a time when banks are risk-averse on underwriting, direct lenders have even come to the rescue of large-cap deals. “Today, direct lenders are singularly or together [as a club] taking on the hung bank deals,” said a mid-market direct lender. The same lender added that private credit firms will continue to increase their portion of the financing markets at the expense of traditional sources of funding, even as banks come back.
Market evolution
It’s no secret that in the last two years, the balance between syndicated buyout deals and direct lending has shifted in favor of the latter — and this is the period that has been relentlessly challenging for banks, which have had to face crises including Covid-19, rising inflation and interest rates, and war in Europe.
Now, the collapse of SVB and forced rescue of Credit Suisse could tip the balance in favor of direct lenders even further, as financial conditions inevitably tighten. In the first quarter of this year, direct lending financed an average 88.9% of buyout deals by count, up from 66.7% in 1Q20, according to PitchBook I LCD data.
In a further development, market players are expecting more dual-track processes moving forward, whereby companies that would have traditionally chosen a syndication are now also looking for a private solution on the side. “I would expect the two markets to converge, so there is a likelihood that public deals will start to look like private credit deals,” another direct lender said.
The market could also see more private-public hybrid structures, such as private credit funds entering a deal to help a larger bank underwrite. Indeed, experts agree that banks and private credit players are looking at more ways to work together — for example a bank may concentrate on an RCF and ancillary services, with the aim of then already being in the borrower’s capital structure ahead of any potential future refinancing deals. “The market is definitely evolving,” said one lender. “Private credit will continue to grow, and banks will adapt to that new reality.”
Home guard
Away from these broader trends there are also geographic factors at play in Europe’s private credit market, and against a challenging economic backdrop it seems direct lenders remain cautious about the UK, with that country accounting for 28.4% of Europe’s direct lending deal count in 2022, down from 33.3% in 2021.
The most recent change of Prime Minister — with Rishi Sunak taking the keys to 10 Downing Street — helped market confidence, but the UK was at some point considered the most problematic among the G7 economies, while the Bank of England implemented two rate rises. That said, with energy prices beginning to cool and signs of inflation slowing, there is now some confidence returning to the country’s markets.
“It is no secret that M&A activity has been low in the UK especially in the upper mid-market, and relative to the strong bounce we saw post-Covid,” said Nick Holman, director at Kartesia, who is responsible for the origination, execution and monitoring of investments across Europe, with a focus on the UK. Holman adds that deals can be brought to market, but the kind of valuations they were expecting 12 months ago would only be reserved for the best credits — and even then M&A processes have been elongated with a great risk of failure, while many sponsors are “sitting and waiting on the side.”
Meanwhile France and Germany saw rises in their proportions of European deals compared to 2021, as their shares increased to 19.3% and 17%, respectively, in 2022. The Netherlands also posted strong growth, with its share rising from 7.2% in 2021, to 10.2% in 2022. “We never used to have a presence in Benelux but now it’s definitely a market we want to break into, as the opportunities there are many,” one mid-market direct lender said. Another notable territory is Italy with a 6.8% slice of the deal count, up from 6.5% in 2021 and just 3.8% in 2020.
Technical talk
As for market sectors, Computers & Electronics — which acts as a proxy for the technology sector — continues to be the major focus of Europe’s private credit lenders, accounting for a quarter of the direct-lending deal count in 2022. This segment is followed by Healthcare, with a 15% slice.
Amid today’s environment of uncertainty, many sponsors have refocused their efforts away from certain sectors, lenders say. “If you are raising for a software business, then there is plenty of liquidity available and increased competitive intensity for that kind of sector,” said one source, adding that when raising for a cyclical or consumer-facing business, then there is often very little or no capital available.
Similarly in markets such as the UK, most of the deals have been in areas such as B2B, healthcare and financials, which tend to be the more resilient sectors. “Most things in the UK are B2B, and that’s where risks around inflation and supply chains have had a lesser impact,” Holman said. “Most of these businesses have decent margins, good cash flow and have been largely able to pass on price increases to their customers and maintain margins, and these firms will continue to see good traction.”
Buy and build
Looking at deal purposes, acquisition-related financing is still the main reason to call on private lenders, with such transactions representing two-thirds of European direct-lending transactions in the first three months of 2023 (to March 10), PitchBook I LCD data shows. There has also been an acceleration in terms of buy and build strategies, said one lender, adding that more companies are now turning towards private credit to bankroll their strategies.
Having access to private credit funds has also been a catalyst for add-ons, with many sponsors having postponed their exits, said a direct lender. “This trend was a key theme of 2022, and we will continue to see it this year as well,” the lender added.
So whether trying to facilitate club deals, looking at hybrid structures to work alongside banks, or focusing on refinancing or growth capital, it seems the private credit flexibility during a time of crisis will further solidify its position across Europe’s financing markets. “This is a phenomenal vintage for private credit if you get the underwriting right,” concluded one lender.
Featured image by YRABOTA/Shutterstock
Learn about our editorial standards.