Uli Grabenwarter

Featured image of Uli Grabenwarter, the European Investment Fund’s director of equity investments, courtesy of the EIF

LPs

Q&A: European Investment Fund director on adding value in VC

A discussion with EIF’s equity investments head about navigating the challenging European VC market.

European entrepreneurs have long faced challenges accessing cash to start and grow businesses, even before the market put a squeeze on venture activity.

The European Investment Fund, a development finance institution, has been one of the most active investors in the continent’s startup and high-growth economy for the last 30 years, primarily via venture capital and private equity funds rather than acting as a direct investor. As a limited partner, it has a clear commercial focus as well as a bigger mission: support the long-term development of the continent’s risk capital ecosystem.

PitchBook spoke to Uli Grabenwarter, EIF’s director of equity investments, about its investment model, how it differentiates itself from other LPs and his biggest concerns about the current funding environment. This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

PitchBook: What are the EIF’s strategic aims and how does its role as a publicly backed institution impact its role as an LP?

Grabenwarter: We are probably the most sizable investor within European venture capital. The EIF has a very strong focus on this asset class, but our objectives are broader. We are commercially minded, but our overriding goal is to be a value-added investor. Not just for individual funds but also to contribute to the development of the ecosystem for risk capital in Europe.

I joined the EIF more than 20 years ago, in 2000, and I still remember those first months well as it was right at the time of the technology crash. It was a very sobering time for anyone working in venture capital, but it also posed fundamental questions for the EIF about how to frame its investment strategy for the long term.

Our approach, particularly in that climate where VC funding really dried up, could have been to position the EIF like an ATM that people could readily use to access capital as part of a fundraising process.

But we decided that we wanted the EIF to be a genuinely value-added investor and to demonstrate to the private sector that investing in European VC makes commercial sense. We have applied a selective method to our investments from that time onwards, acting as a cornerstone investor, playing a catalytic role within the market.

Although that overarching approach has remained the same, our delivery has had to evolve in line with market changes. Different market segments or geographies require more attention than others at different times—for instance, emerging areas of technology or thematic areas such as sustainability or impact investing. Certain areas are well-funded by the private sector, whereas for others there is a clearer benefit to EIF involvement.

Can you foresee a world in which the EIF has performed its role so effectively that it is no longer needed?

I think that any development finance institution should have a corporate mission to ultimately make itself redundant. We really only exist to fill market gaps and we should be aiming to develop a market that can be sustained by private sector capital.

How this really plays out in the market is along the market-segment-specific lines I just mentioned. As and when the private sector is able to provide sufficient capital in a market segment without our input, we are able to shift our focus to other areas.

What are some of the market segments that the EIF is currently focused on?

We are in a particularly challenging and interesting time, where several major events have impacted the market environment. That started with the pandemic, which has prompted the reshaping of many sectors, supply chains and ways of doing business that we had previously taken for granted. There has also been significant geopolitical instability, macroeconomic uncertainty and the entire dimension of energy transition and climate challenges that we are facing.

In light of these multiple overlapping crises, our investment approach has adapted considerably in the last three to five years. We have become much more thematic and developed dedicated strategies that target the impacts of these crises. Whereas previously we were serving the market in a more undifferentiated way, we are now much more focused on areas that are relevant to the major issues that society is facing.

How does the EIF identify the funds it will back?

We probably see north of 95% of all the potential private capital investment opportunities in the European markets, just by looking at the deal flow. We see more than 1,000 investment opportunities every year, and in the venture capital sector we probably make around 80 investments. So that gives you an indication of the level of selectivity we apply, given the resources we have available.

In specific market segments, where we are more proactively trying to support the development of a funding ecosystem, we will directly engage with GPs in the market. In many cases, we will support them to shape their investment proposals to bring them to a level that would meet the requirements of institutional investors.

That is very important because we feel we can only add value and play our catalytic role where the opportunities are at an institutional investor level of quality. And for me, it is important to stress the interactivity of that process. We are not acting as a judging panel; we are working with funds to develop the market.

What do you see as the biggest issues currently impacting Europe’s private markets?

One issue that really strikes me is how there is still a great deal of uncertainty impacting VC and private equity activity. We continue to see significant hesitation within the market. We still don’t know whether we have seen it all, in terms of adjustments to valuations, the macroeconomic repercussions of the high inflation environment, etc. In the real economy, many of those effects are only just landing now.

So, many fund managers are still in a “wait and see” mindset in terms of holding back on investments in order to be able to invest in an even more attractive valuation environment or manage when they want to be in the market to improve their chances of successful fundraising. From the perspective of an individual fund manager, this is all logical and understandable behavior but, as the EIF from a macro perspective, we are interested in the knock-on effect on the wider industry.

The slowdown in investment activity is now slowing down innovation in the wider economy and reducing the capital available for innovative companies from European VC funds, which means those businesses need to look beyond Europe to get that capital—or don’t get funded at all.

We are concerned about what the effect of this slowdown is going to be three to five years down the road. And as the EIF, we are very mindful of what our role within that environment is.

Is there anything that EIF or other market players should be doing to address this uncertainty?

We are prepared to step up our investment activity in difficult markets to allow funds to close and reach critical target sizes. That helps liquidity shortfalls to be contained over the short term and builds broader market confidence in resuming investment activity. However, we are ourselves bound to operate with our own limited funding resources—which in times like these, compete with many other priorities in public and private sector capital allocation.

Featured image of Uli Grabenwarter, the European Investment Fund’s director of equity investments, courtesy of the EIF

Learn about our editorial standards.