Business People in the Office while Working. Blurred

fotograzia/Getty Images

Private Credit

Europe’s direct lenders respond to bank challenge, patchy M&A outlook

Many private credit managers are calling 2024 ‘the year of adjustment’, as they grapple with an M&A slowdown and increased competition from the broadly syndicated market.

Want to see more? Fill out the form below.

I agree to PitchBook’s privacy policy

With no clarity yet on when a meaningful M&A revival will come and amid increased competition from the broadly syndicated product, many private credit managers are now calling 2024 'the year of adjustment'. Reflecting the challenging conditions, Q1 2024 was Europe’s weakest quarter for M&A deal value since the Covid-19 lockdowns of Q2 2020, according to PitchBook data, which shows a 12.1% year-over-year decline in total European M&A deal value in Q1 and a 26.2% decline quarter-over-quarter.

“There is no scarcity of transactions, but it’s the deal conversion that remains lower as buyers and sellers fail to agree on valuation,” said Luis Mayans, head of private debt at CDPQ. “For every 8-10 deals we may be considering at any moment in the current market (which would normally be a good scenario), the probability of being left with 1-2 valid options is not negligible.” 

This situation represents a double whammy for direct lenders, as on the one hand they're grappling with an M&A slowdown, while on the large-cap side of the market the return of the broadly syndicated product has meant increased competition, with pretty much every sale becoming a dual-track process.

Bank challenge
The data also bears this out, with the count of European LBOs financed by direct lending versus the broadly syndicated loan (BSL) market falling sharply this year. This ratio stood at 5:1 in favour of direct lenders across the first quarter, down from 10.5:1 in Q4 2023, reflecting the challenge from banks. However, it rebounded slightly in April, to 7:1, with 60% of direct lending deals supporting LBOs in that month.

Publicity shy
Furthermore, sponsors are shying away from publicizing their sale situations, and are instead launching bilateral processes for deals, so a lot of activity is happening under the radar, debt managers and advisors say.

“There are relatively fewer auction processes happening where everybody gets invited, and there is a greater percentage of deals where it is a lot more bilateral or two to three people,” said Richard Oliver, partner in Ares’ European Direct Lending strategy, adding that this is also reinforcing the need to have a strong origination franchise to maintain the activity level.

Against this backdrop, it’s the refinancing, add-on and recapitalization activity that has been keeping managers busy. Indeed, the data also shows there has been a significant uptake in refinancings this year — the most on an annual basis since LCD started tracking this data — with refinancings accounting for 20% of the direct-lending deal count so far in 2024 (to April 25).

Back to basics
Meanwhile, after a year of attention on jumbo unitranches and the upper end of the market, activity has become more varied in terms of deal size. That said, four jumbo deals so far this year — from Ardonagh, Ottobock, Iris and Audiotonix — have boosted the share of direct-lending deals sized above €1 billion to 25%, which is currently higher than all previous annual readings on LCD's records for that measure.

Permira Credit, meanwhile, notes that if the story of 2023 was one of direct lending groups moving up the size spectrum to finance larger companies, 2024 will feature a return to the mid-market as activity starts to normalize at all size levels. “The leading indicator of this is what we see in the market, with many companies with EBITDA of €20 million to €50 million seeking financing,” the company said in its Q1 market update.

CDPQ's Mayans said that the pricing and documents in mid-market deals are more favorable to lenders. “For larger transactions, there is competition from the syndicated market, which allows for more negotiation on terms,” he added.

Mattis Poetter, partner and co-CIO of Arcmont Asset Management, says the mid-market financing environment is in much better shape today in terms of activity. “There is lots of activity right now, we are working on very many transactions, and it is very clear several will happen,” he said, adding that it feels very different from last year for M&A activity, as people are pushing a little bit further down in terms of the quality of the assets. “Last year [M&A activity] failed as only the best assets were being sold," he added.

Ares’ Oliver notes that they are seeing a steady run rate of activity in the mid-market for companies that have less than €50 million EBITDA. “That’s the part of the market where we see the most consistent level of activity,” he said. According to LCD, the median EBITDA for European direct lending deals (in cases where this metric is made public) in the second quarter to April 25 is €30 million.

Nicolas Nedelec, partner at Eurazeo’s private debt team, added that while in the upper middle-market there is a subdued level of activity, with probably 10-20 lenders competing for the same assets, in the lower mid-market there is still decent volume, and competition remains limited.

Pictet Asset Management’s Gareth Payne, head of credit & alternative fixed income client portfolio managers, says there is less competition in the lower middle market, and the key lies in the origination of deals. “Teams are busy, and selectivity is key in the lower middle market,” he said, adding that they expect the market to unlock M&A activity in the latter part of the year.

Creative thinking
In such a market, lenders are becoming creative to help sponsors get deals done. While the deal structures are often the 'plain vanilla' ones — with first-lien senior debt, for example — lenders are now having to think differently and offer a lot more flexibility.

One example here is that PIK-toggle debt is now prevalent on deals, notes Arcmont's Poetter, while adding that not all, but most European deals include the feature. “It is a great safety net for sponsors, as it provides flexibility of turning off some of the cash pay interest to allow borrowers to navigate some of the challenges or uncertainty in the future,” he says.

In another emerging feature, LCD has previously reported that direct lenders are increasingly using chunky delayed draw term loans to sweeten deals, while managers are also padding transactions with uncommitted capital that borrowers can tap into after using the DDTLs. “Sponsors are finding us to be reliable as they can tap us in volatile markets to buy committed lines like DDTL, and even uncommitted lines,” Poetter adds.

Meanwhile, sector selection continues to be an important tool for direct lenders, as they seek to avoid cyclical industries — with LCD previously noting that Europe’s private credit funds have been targeting certain sectors to mitigate risk — and that trend has only been bolstered in a volatile M&A environment. “We have always had sector bias, but we have now increased the bias while diversifying within those sectors. We realized that in a volatile environment, it [sector selection] is a massive boost,” Poetter notes.
 
Back to the future
Amid tough conditions, debt managers and advisors say today's sponsors are keen to hold assets for longer, and time their exits. “We have a general election coming soon to the UK and the US Presidential elections are later this year, so I doubt any material changes in the level of activity will occur until the next calendar year,” said Alexander Griffith, partner at Proskauer Rose. “There will obviously be some deals done, but decent assets that in a good market would have been sold, will continue to be held back.”

However, Griffith adds that rate cuts will further drive refinancing activity, as lenders will be keen to hold onto the decent assets in their portfolio with a refinancing, before any sale opportunity may arise: “Lenders will be looking to roll the debt on key assets in their portfolio with some price adjustment. We are likely to see a stronger demand for portability provisions with a view to the M&A window opening wider next year.”
 
 

fotograzia/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.