Ask investors inside and outside Europe what is holding back the continent’s VC market, and most, if not all, would say a lack of pension fund participation.
Unlike other markets, such as the US, European VC has failed to bounce back. This year, deal activity is projected to land at its lowest level since 2016, while total deal value is unlikely to surpass last year’s, even with a boost from AI. Despite recent signs of improvement, the fundraising environment remains one of the harshest seen this decade.
Geopolitical headaches, mostly tariff-related, and slower economic growth in EU countries this year have affected the appetite for VC. Yet the continued pullback in activity underscores a deeper issue that Europe has been struggling with for a while: a funding gap that can be traced to a lack of deep-pocketed institutional investors.
“There’s a chronic lack in Europe of the types of LPs that you see in the US,” said Kinga Stanislawska, founder of European Women in VC. “Putting 1-2% of pension money to work for venture would be transformational for Europe and the pension funds themselves.”
Despite pension funds across Europe managing over €3 trillion (about $3.4 trillion) in assets, only around 0.12% is invested in VC and growth, according to a new report published by European Women in VC, Pensions for Purpose and Venture Connections. For their US-based counterparts, the allocation is around 10% for PE, including VC.
Stanislawska describes a closer relationship between the two as a “win-win.” Aging populations are straining European pension funds. With fewer workers contributing, they need to increase returns to support a growing cohort of retirees.
Traditional investments, such as government bonds, cannot deliver the returns necessary to bridge the gap. For VC, the benefit is billions of euros in long-term patient capital.
Risk appetites
There are many reasons why pension funds hesitate to invest in VC, but according to Karen Shackleton, chair and founder of industry group Pensions for Purpose, the main obstacle is a lack of resources.
“If you think about how pension funds direct their governance resources, the bulk of it is going to their biggest allocations,” she said. “The problem with VC is that it’s such a small part of their portfolio, if it is part of it at all, that they don’t have the budget or time to dedicate to it.”
Insufficient resources prevent pension funds from properly conducting due diligence or monitoring VC investments, leading to a lack of understanding about the asset class.
According to Shackleton, this lack of expertise creates the perception that VC is riskier than what the data suggest, which discourages more conservative funds. VC is often regarded as part of PE. As a result, resources become even more limited because the same team, or sometimes just one person, must evaluate opportunities across two asset classes that have very different measures of success and failure.
If you build bigger funds, you can counteract some tensions and hurdles in the marketplace. Larger pools can allocate greater resources and will be able to spend more time looking at VC.
A shortage of experienced senior professionals also hampers networks and relationships. This can affect access to top-tier funds and startups offering better risk/return profiles.
For many pension funds, investing in VC requires significant effort for higher risk. Its illiquid nature, lack of transparency and inconsistent performance between funds can make VC a hard pill to swallow, especially when you add a 2% management fee and 20% carry on top.
According to the report, VC’s perception problem hasn’t deterred all pension funds; countries such as Iceland and Sweden have been very active in the space. But much of that capital isn’t staying local.
“What we found is that pension funds allocate a certain portion [of their assets] to their local market, but the rest goes to the US,” Stanislawska said. “The assumption is that the US delivers better returns, which is often just not true. No one is thinking of cross-border Europe.”
The fund-of-funds route
While cultural mindsets and assumptions are hard to change, a practical way to overcome some major barriers preventing pension funds from investing is through fund-of-funds.
"[FoFs] offer access to top-performing VC funds that are otherwise out of reach, plus built-in diversification that mitigates the high-risk nature of the asset class,” Debbie Wosskow, co-chair of the UK’s Invest in Women Taskforce, was quoted as saying in the latest European Women in VC report. “In VC, where returns are concentrated and selection matters more than cost, a well-constructed FoF can deliver stronger net performance with lower volatility, exactly what long-term retirement savers need.”
The report adds that as diversification increases, the risk of investing in VC significantly decreases. It shows that the probability of a total loss is 0% for a diversified FoF, compared to 30% for a single direct investment and 1% for a single fund. The average loss within a FoF structure is 4%, versus 85% for a single investment.
This form of VC investing also attracts larger pension funds, which may not have explored the asset class due to low capital deployment.
Read more: UK to unlock $66B+ in pension fund capital for private markets
According to PitchBook data, this year’s median VC fund size is €50 million. Writing such small tickets isn’t practical or efficient for major institutional investors. FoFs solve that issue by pooling capital, which allows them to deploy meaningful sums with fewer administrative burdens.
Shackleton of Pensions for Purpose suggested that pension system reform, specifically consolidation, could boost allocations, at least in the UK.
“If you build bigger funds, you can counteract some of these tensions and hurdles in the marketplace,” she said. “Larger pools can allocate greater resources and will be able to spend more time looking at VC.”
For the EU, Stanislawska highlighted the importance of a capital market union, which would create a single, unified financial system to enhance allocations. Specifically, she mentioned that a single stock market would simplify exits and return liquidity to pension funds more effectively.
‘Seeds of hope’
Although allocations are small, efforts are underway to attract more pension funds into VC, especially by governments.
The UK’s Mansion House Accord, signed earlier this year, saw 17 workplace pension providers commit to allocating at least 10% of defined-contribution assets into private markets.
In France, the Tibi initiative, which aims to boost institutional capital for VC and tech-focused funds, has raised €12.5 billion since 2020. Germany launched the WIN Initiative last year to mobilize €13.9 billion in public-private investment for startups and scaleups by 2030.
Shackleton also noted a greater willingness from pension funds to pursue VC opportunities that were previously absent.
“There are seeds of hope,” she said. “There are a few who are starting to put their toes in the water, supported by policy work. There’s still a long way to go, but I’m hopeful that we’ll see bigger allocations coming forward from pension funds.”
Featured image by Adriana Hansen/PitchBook News
Learn about our editorial standards.