When a Spain-based direct lender planned for its third fund the firm expected to hit first close by December, but now it’s April and the fund has yet to wrap.
“Most of our existing LPs are reupping, but to a lower extent — and that’s the problem,” a manager from the Spanish firm said, adding that the days are gone when it was possible to raise funds in just 15 months. “It is taking a lot longer now,” he added.
A stretched fundraising timeline is just one of the issues facing managers in Europe, as they look tap into opportunities presented by the ‘golden age’ of the private credit market, which is expected to touch $1.7 trillion of assets under management by the end of 2027, according to PitchBook data.
Fundraising has been especially challenging since the second half of last year, said one manager: “With heightened interest rates, LPs are investing in other asset classes — mainly government bonds, corporate bonds, and high-yield bonds where you can get decent yields, which you couldn’t get for the past 6-7 years.”
The private credit market has been growing ever since the Global Financial Crisis — when regulators clamped down on bank lending to riskier, highly levered businesses — but the real acceleration came in the last year or so as war in Europe, inflation and fears of recession spooked the syndicated loan market, giving private credit firms a one-of-a-kind opportunity to fill the void left by the banks.
And while the mini-banking crisis seen in March may further hinder banks’ participation in financing markets, concerns over what might come next to threaten stability could amplify the need for private credit funds even more. However, direct lenders are slowly realizing that more demand is not always a good thing, and some investors worry it might even lead to a slowdown in the private credit market. “Saying private debt can absorb everything [in terms of financing] is a bit overstated, because while the depth of the market is increasing, it cannot take it all,” said a private debt manager, while noting that over-deployment could slow it down.
There are roughly 2,700 limited partners in the world, said one advisor source, who added that while this figure “looks like a lot, with all the funds that are raising equity, infrastructure funds, credit and so on, it becomes quite small.”
Record breaker
2021 was a record year for direct lending funds, which raised a total of €49.05 billion, as per the PitchBook data. Last year, that number reduced to 13 funds raising €23.7 billion, the data showed.
LCD earlier this month reported that six funds are looking to start the process of raising more than €15 billion between them, this year alone, but it is now becoming increasingly challenging to raise funds.
What’s more, the euphoria for fundraising is emerging at a time when M&A volumes have come down amid market volatility, and while valuation levels are not what they used to be.
The speed at which managers have been coming back to market has increased over the past three years, said Alexander Odysseos, director of the Private Funds Group at Houlihan Lokey. “There is demand for capital at a time when LPs are not receiving the levels of distributions they used to,” he notes, adding that M&A activity has slowed down over the last year, which has only added to the pain.
Meanwhile, limited partners have either slowed down or have hit the pause button to work through imbalances and ascertain the impact of the ‘denominator effect’ on their portfolios, and this has made fundraising hard for direct lenders.
“We are heading into a more challenging environment for fundraising, but remain optimistic that private debt remains a long-term strategic allocation in investor portfolios,” Natasha Sahi, managing director at Barings said, adding that while managers with established platforms and strong performance should fare well, it’s a trickier backdrop for first-time funds and those managers with limited track records.
“We are seeing corporate pension fund LPs review, reallocate and restructure their broader portfolios, so while we will see some private debt commitments continue, others have fallen away,” said Simon Males, executive director and head of UK Institutional Business at Tikehau Capital.
Evidence of returns
And of those firms that are able to raise, they have to produce compelling evidence of returns and track records against their peers if they want to raise fresh funds, as investors are very selective in the managers they back, thereby adding to the increased fundraising timelines.
“This is as good as it gets,” said Michael Small, partner at KKR, during a recent panel discussion organized by BVCA. “A lot of institutions don’t know what their allocation system could look like for 2023, 2024 or 2025, and as they figure it out they will start deploying again. It is frustrating for all of us.”
A New York-based fund manager which was looking to close a $1 billion-plus, Europe-focused fund is also expecting to extend the fundraising period. “It is quite normal to do that in the current market,” said the manager. “Anybody who says they are not going to extend the funding period is not telling the truth.”
Against this backdrop, the increasing shift towards impact funds is adding to pressure in the market. ESG is also an important factor, said one of the advisors, adding that it’s less difficult to raise an impact fund these days than a normal fund.
Meanwhile the desperation to raise funds is visible, as investors today are bombarded with calls for capital raises as they come back to the fundraising market faster than they are deploying, said an advisor.
“We have seen an increasing number of high-profile managers approaching us for assistance in fundraising, in a way we would not have expected had the markets been more benign,” said Odysseos, adding that managers understand the market is tough, and that they need additional assistance to secure new capital.
And to attract new investors, some managers are also offering to sell half of their previous fund so the LPs get to cash in, and then the same LPs can re-invest in the new fund. “We see a lot of that,” confirmed another fund advisor.
Funds turn picky
While there is enough dry powder for the time being, private credit firms are becoming pickier when it comes to investing against the backdrop of uncertainty around sources of capital. The concerns here include the question of when the fundraising market opens, and how much depth there is to feed medium-term liquidity, said a UK-based mid-market lender.
Amid such concerns, investors have refocused away from certain sectors. “If you are raising for a software business, then there is plenty of liquidity available and increased competitive intensity for that kind of sector,” said the same direct lender, adding that when raising funds for a cyclical business-like consumer, then there may be very little or no capital available.
There is also pressure from limited partners to deploy faster and not hold on to capital, said another mid-market manager. This manager notes that LPs are desperate to ensure their capital is deployed before any further uncertainty hits.
As for sponsors, many are testing the market quietly — and for some deals the sponsors are not even holding auctions, said one of the lenders. “In an environment where there is uncertainty of capital, some sponsors quietly gauge the demand for an asset within their networks of investors. If it trades, it trades, but if it doesn’t, it’s fine — as not many people know about it, and they can come back some other time.”
The constraints that private credit investors are now facing appear to be more complex compared to challenges in the past, when their only concern was competition with banks, while there has been a secular growth dynamic in private credit flows, said Males. “There is a new era dawning for private credit firms as they meet new challenges for secondary liquidity provision and private investor allocation,” he concludes.
Featured image by EtiAmmos/Shutterstock
Learn about our editorial standards.