Business for PC.jpg

Featured image: Ryan McVay/Getty Images

Private Credit

Europe’s private credit lenders size up competition as banks stage comeback

Participants across Europe are confident private credit is now an established part of the financing space, but they agree there’s significant scope for banks to retake market share.

Europe's private credit players recently gathered at the IPEM in Cannes and DealCatalyst European Direct Lending & Middle Market Finance conference in London to take the market’s pulse for the year ahead. And while market players at these events were confident that private credit is now an established part of the financing markets, they also agreed there is significant scope for banks to retake market share.

Despite this challenge from banks, private credit players insist their asset class remains on an upward trajectory, with one lender even suggesting the market is now moving into a “platinum era” for private credit — coining a new phrase in reference to the “golden age” moniker bandied about so frequently throughout 2023. “The private credit segment as a mainstream financing tool really started five years ago, since when some of the largest LBOs — including the two largest — have been financed with private credit,” one lender said.

Clash of the titans
There is though a general consensus that banks are staging a comeback in the European buyout market, after sitting on the sidelines for more than a year. One of the reasons for this return is tightening spreads in the market. Over the last two years, most direct lending deals have priced at roughly 625 bps to 700 bps over the benchmark rate, but these spreads are starting to tighten as bank competition returns. “The [typical] spread offered by direct lenders has come in to around 575 bps to 600 bps due to competition from syndicated markets,” confirmed an adviser.

Indeed, traditional lenders are now plotting their comeback in the market, thanks in part to a stabilization in interest rates and hopes of cuts to follow later this year. As a result, bankers are now returning to previous syndicated names lost to private credit with increasingly compelling refinancing offers. What’s more, as some capital structures near their maturity or move out of call protection, it is opening up a path for syndicated loans or bonds to return.

“Now is a very good time for syndicated markets to get back into the deals,” said a banker. “Bankers are drawing up lists of all the unitranches done in the last two years, where they are priced at 650 bps. Even if there is a 1% non-call fee, the savings in such cases would still be enough for borrowers.”

“Direct lending facilities usually have a one-year non-call period, so now the market is ripe to be refinanced. But this is not a threat — rather, it is a sign of a healthier market,” one direct lending manager said.

A case in point is Advent-backed German outpatient care group Deutsche Fachpflege, which presented a €420 million term loan with a lender call on Jan. 29 via a group led by Jefferies, RBC, SMBC, ING, Mizuho and NatWest, in a deal that will take out a Hayfin-provided unitranche.

Other borrowers, including April Insurance and Trescal, are said to be potential candidates to follow. Meanwhile, a mid-market direct lender told LCD that two of their last exits were financed by bank clubs.

Having said that, bankers agree it is easier for a borrower to go from a broadly syndicated loan to a unitranche, than it is to finance from a unitranche to a syndicated deal. “Doing first-time ratings is a major piece of work and a time-consuming exercise, which might also not work in a lot of situations,” noted a UK-based adviser. 

Broad shoulders
Furthermore, private credit managers are confident regarding the depth and breadth of their market. There are also expectations for an uptick in M&A activity across the mid-market and large-cap space in the coming months, which supports hopes among participants that the private credit and broadly syndicated asset classes can both compete for deals, sources suggest.

“I think both of these markets will coexist,” said a panelist at the European Direct Lending & Middle Market Finance conference on Jan. 29. “We have situations where even in a hot syndicated market, the borrower goes for private solutions — we are seeing that happen on a couple of situations. It is driven [when deals go to private credit] by a more structured solution, having more leverage compared to what the syndicated market can afford, and in Europe by multi-currency need or delayed-draw acquisition firepower.”

“I think there is something like $1.7 trillion of equity waiting to be deployed, so there is space for everyone,” another private debt manager said. The same manager added there are a number of parameters that go into a deal besides the headline pricing. “While we are seeing heavy competition from the syndicated market, what we need to see play out this year is the supply of deals. If that comes through, I think there is a lot of capacity for both the syndicated and private credit markets.”

Back to the future
Looking at the road ahead, sources expect to see more dual-track processes on deals — with both broadly syndicated and private credit options in play for borrowers — and also more hybrid co-investment processes, whereby both banks and direct lenders invest in the same structure. “Dual-tracking is definitely here to stay,” stressed one lender.

Meanwhile, one impact from tighter spreads might be that private lenders reprice, especially for a new unitranche financing. “But flexibility and swiftness come at a price, and we can’t really change that too much,” a private lender said.

In one interesting development, the fact the broadly syndicated market is competing against private credit for deal share in Europe does not negate the attraction that the private asset class holds for banks, which usually use their own balance sheets rather than external investors to finance deals. As a result, established banks keep trying to enter the private credit market themselves — and at numbers that are likely to grow.

For example, BNP Paribas’ asset management arm is looking to raise nearly €1 billion for a new direct-lending fund. The bank's strategy aims to offer unitranche financing solutions to lower- and middle-market firms, in a move that will allow it to compete with other direct lending funds, For the fund, the bank will use cash from balance sheet and also raise money from external investors. 

Similarly, HSBC Asset Management is looking to raise roughly €1 billion for a new direct lending fund targeting the European market, after launching its direct lending strategy for the UK. The European fund here will follow a similar strategy to the bank's UK fund, and invest in senior secured loans to mid-market, private equity-backed companies.

In addition, banks have reached out to lenders to work together. “We have been sitting down with banks a lot lately to find a way to collaborate. We do not know what shape that is going to take, but it there is certainly a lot of thought on this from both parties,” a private lender explained.

Another talking point at Europe's conferences in January was the private credit secondaries market (for trading private credit loans and some other investor commitments), and indeed as private credit tickets grow the idea of a sell-down market in this asset class becomes more logical. Some private lenders are already raising funds to move into that market, sources note, though they caution there might be some obstacles to the development of the private credit secondaries space.

One of these obstacles is information transparency — because while the syndicated market is generally transparent, that is not the case in private markets. Secondly, there is the question of ticket size. “If you are in a club, maybe your position is not big enough for a CLO, or if you want to shift only part of your position it would not work if it’s too small,” explained one lender. Lastly, the appetite from LPs to do such transactions might not be there in the current market.

Featured image: Ryan McVay/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.