puzzle.jpg

malerapaso/Getty Images

Private Credit

Europe’s private credit managers ponder exit puzzle

Buyers and sellers are struggling to make common ground on pricing, with sponsors and lenders finding exits challenging — especially for jumbo deals.

Want to see more? Fill out the form below.

I agree to PitchBook’s privacy policy

Europe's dealmakers may be feeling more optimistic than last year, as activity picks up and transaction flow improves. But in a still-difficult M&A market, private equity sponsors are attempting to solve the puzzle of how to exit their big-ticket holdings.

This very topic was a key discussion point at the two-day IPEM private asset conference earlier this month in Paris. Participants at the event said buyers and sellers are still struggling to find common ground on pricing, and with the IPO market dislocated, sponsors and lenders alike are finding exits challenging — especially for jumbo deals.

And while the M&A pipeline looks stronger, exit conversations are taking a lot longer, and in many cases stalling. “Exit conversations are ongoing, and we are still seeing people holding back and struggling to find common ground when it comes to the right value of the business,” said Roxana Mirica, partner and head of capital markets at Apax Partners in Europe.

“There is also the issue of the PE funds that bought 'beautiful' companies with crazy multiples,” noted an M&A banker. “They now have a portfolio that is way too expensive for potential buyers, so it is paused.”

Size is everything
For direct lenders, difficulties at the larger end of the exit market mean jumbo unitranches are out of favour. What’s more, private debt must also deal with resurgent competition from the syndicated market. “Below 10% loan to value, banks are very much active. At the other end, for very large deals that are above a billion, then you have access to other pockets of capital including insurance money, so private lenders are making the deals in the middle,” another lender explains.

“Jumbo deals are much harder to exit, especially with the IPO market not really functioning at the moment,” Mirica added.

Given that arranging a syndicated deal is a time-consuming process, there are also cases where direct lenders are being used as a bridge to a public market deal in either bonds or loans. “This is essentially where sponsors are using direct lenders until the time they arrange a syndicated financing for very large jumbo deals,” added a banker.

There is also an ongoing fundraising struggle to contend with, especially as the market in Europe is concentrated among fewer and larger managers. These bigger players are not only able to deploy large pools of capital quickly, but also have no difficulty in raising billions when required.

Deal machine
Meanwhile, there is agreement across the market that the deal machine is still a little congested, even if bankers and managers are preparing for a strong restart in 2025. For direct lenders 2023 was a friendly year for their asset class as spreads widened, leverage reduced and documentation tightened. These conditions arose against the backdrop of a competitive advantage for private credit as Europe's syndicated markets dislocated, and ensured a good year for many direct lending funds despite reduced M&A activity.

Now in 2024, the pendulum has swung back to a much more borrower-friendly environment, and — encouragingly — M&A volume seems to be picking up a little. “We have been saying it’s coming back for a while, but now we think 2025 is the most likely finishing line,” said one source on the full return of this market.

The problem with M&A gridlock is that “the highest quality companies are few and far between [in terms of coming to market],” one lender said. “However, the situation is better now than it was a few months ago,” the same person added.

In this context, lenders are keeping busy with add-on/refinancing-related activities in the absence of 'proper' deal flow. “As M&A hasn’t quite come back, we are seeing significant add-on/refinancing activity in our portfolios,” added Stuart Mathieson, head of Europe & APAC private credit & capital solutions at Barings. The data also reflects that observation, as so far this year nearly 70% of direct lending deals were acquisition-related, down from 76% in 2023, according to LCD.

Sector selectors
As for M&A trends, these appear to be homogenous across the whole of Europe. “Sponsors now look at sectors, and they don’t look at countries,” said a source. Indeed, the three major sectors this year in terms of direct-lending deal share — as they have been consistently since 2020 — are Computers & Electronics; Professional & Business Services; and Healthcare. This year so far, these segments account for respective market shares of 23%, 22% and 11%.

Looking at geography, the UK, Germany, France, Italy, and Benelux are all strong sources of unitranche activity, according to an M&A advisor. “The UK especially is a market where you can see the dominance of debt funds at the moment, as the banks have retrenched to some extent compared to last year.” 

Then there is the interesting case of Italy, which keeps attracting lenders to its direct lending market. “We are making quite a few deals in Italy at the moment, whereas we never used to do any there,” confirms another lender.

New order
What's more, the way of making deals has changed a little too. “We are seeing a reduction in the number of players invited to actually look at opportunities,” reveals a lender source. “This means you don't now get the usual cast of 30 to 35 lenders coming to pitch with their views on a financing opportunity.” 

“The ability to provide capital at scale, grow with the company and have a relationship with the sponsor is very important,” another lender adds.

A further feature that seems to have become established in the market is club deals. When the broadly syndicated market was dislocated, private lending was the main game in town, and this state of play pushed lenders to clubs as a means of assembling such large deals.

The move to clubs has not been comfortable for European lenders, however. Previously, a desire for full control and a fear that LPs would not have a sufficiently diversified investment, made the asset class solitary. “Clubs are here to stay — the sponsors prefer that as it gives them more control over lenders,” one M&A banker notes. 

Back in 2020, alternative lender clubs accounted for 2.5% of European direct-lending buyout deals, while so far in 2024 the same share stands at 12.5%. “The important thing is to keep some kind of control, and we will try to be the lead lenders on deals,” one lender concludes.


 

malerapaso/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.