wooden jigsaw puzzle pieces on black background

Songsak Paname/Getty Images/iStockphoto

Private Credit

Europe’s private credit market finds solutions amid signs of stress

Signs of stress are showing in European private credit, with a raft of debt-for-equity swaps this year and sponsors negotiating behind closed doors.

The European private credit market has started to show signs of strain amid broader market volatility. While the asset class has had a strong run over the last several years — fueled by the retreat of the syndicated loan product in 2022, and a rush by LPs to partake in the market boom — various factors have taken their toll. Among these, higher interest rates have been good for yields but have placed stress on sponsors’ portfolio companies, and geopolitical shocks have added to the pressure.

“Stress across direct lending portfolios has broadly increased over the last couple of years as a result of a higher interest-rate environment, cost inflation, changes in consumer behavior, the emergence of new technologies, and regulatory changes including taxes and tariffs,” sums up Alexander Robb, partner at Ropes & Gray.

Debt-for-equity swaps
Though the data is difficult to track due to the opaque nature of the European private credit space, the market has seen a number of debt-for-equity swaps this year, including for Parcel2Go, Vitronet, and Away Resorts. Tikehau has recently taken ownership of SPVIE, and Atlas for Men (which has Arcmont as a lender) is now in receivership.

In September, S&P downgraded the rating of private credit-financed firm Enstall Group (previously Esdec) to CCC on its unsustainable capital structure and weak liquidity. S&P said the company’s adjusted EBITDA — at roughly €65-70 million in 2025 — is insufficient to cover interest and debt redemption of €120 million to service outstanding financial debt of about €1.1 billion. In 2023, the Blackstone and Rivean-backed Dutch provider of rooftop solar-mounting solutions placed a €600 million term loan via a club of direct lenders to support a shareholder dividend. More situations like this could emerge, and indeed an advisor told LCD that a few more debt-for-equity swaps are in the works.

Robb at Ropes & Gray says there comes a point when a borrower’s negative prospects and/or liquidity issues can’t be solved via a liability management exercise, or changes to its business plan. “In situations where a sponsor isn’t prepared to inject sufficient new money, lenders need to take enforcement action to protect their interests, and we are sometimes seeing this happen on a consensual basis,” he notes.

Furthermore, market participants say more than a dozen debt-for-equity swaps have already taken place behind the scenes this year, given the opacity of the market. “There’s a lot more happening than what you can see in any statistics that are out there,” noted one advisor, adding that these situations are occurring not just in challenged cyclical sectors, but also in ‘hot’ areas such as software and business services that have hitherto been considered safer, or even immune from such stress.

“Management mistakes, the impact of higher interest rates, and broad economic uncertainty have started to affect even the so-called ‘safe’ sectors,” confirms Michael Josenhans, partner at Freshfields’ Global Transactions Group and the Private Capital Sector Group.

Creative workarounds
Private credit defaults are a fairly nuanced concept, and while headline default rates remain low and typically below 2%, some market participants suggest such numbers mask the real picture, explains Aymen Mahmoud, European head of finance and co-head of both the London Transactions Group and the London Finance, Restructuring and Special Situations Group at McDermott, Will & Schulte.

Participants also note that many struggling businesses are avoiding formal restructurings and are instead negotiating behind closed doors, with an increase in lenders quietly offering maturity extensions and restructuring debt terms to prevent defaults.

Freshfields’ Josenhans notes there is a willingness on the debt-fund side to be constructive and avoid taking the keys to a business, and possibly to PIK the interest. “We are seeing this a lot in the mid-cap market,” he says. “These situations are not public but are happening as we speak.”

In its valuation report that tracks changes in the enterprise value of US privately held companies, Lincoln International in August said that a higher default rate could be disguised by significant amendment activity to avoid potential defaults. “I think the problem is that a lot of traditional private credit funds are not good at restructurings,” added a direct lender. “They want to hide it, either via amend-and-extends or through PIK interest.”

Some market participants have even observed the emergence of small, structured tranches designed to cover cash interest obligations on highly leveraged deals.

Meanwhile, another market participant noted an uptick in covenant resets in the market. “When there is a prolonged slowdown like the one we are seeing, if an asset is non-performing or struggling, it will eventually breach covenant — and that’s what’s happening right now.”

The same advisor notes he is working on four covenant resets at the moment, while another says she is currently working on a couple of private credit deals for which the maturities are two-to-three years away. “Given PIK features in those businesses, the equity is increasingly challenged, and sponsors are looking at this and saying we have to do something now, because if we don’t the equity is going to be completely underwater,” the second advisor added.

Buying time
Sponsors are also trying to buy time for portfolio companies in distress. Robb at Ropes & Gray said he is seeing sponsors pre-empt financial covenant breaches and ask for resets based on revised business plans, and providing equity commitment letter backstops where additional funding becomes available subject to certain conditions. Robb added that sponsors are also requesting interest deferrals or PIK interest, and either engaging in liability management exercises or threatening to execute them to encourage consensual restructurings.

In other cases, market participants have come up with an interesting new concept whereby sponsors agree to put their shares in a trust, and in return are given some time — typically 12-18 months or so — to turn things around at the company that’s struggling. The trust then becomes subject to clearly stipulated milestones such as selling the business by a certain period, selling part of the business for a specific minimum price, or achieving a particular revenue or EBITDA number. If the milestones are missed or not achieved, the trust gets activated, and the trustee will then sell the shares for the benefit of the lenders.

“In a way, it’s a win-win for everyone,” says Freshfields’ Josenhans on the trust approach. “For an equity sponsor there is an upside potential that the business might turn around, while for lenders, they don’t have to go through the painful process of enforcement,” he explains, while adding he has seen these structures in play a few times now.

Moreover, the stress in private credit is unlikely to dissipate anytime soon. “The next two years will see more stress than the last two,” warned a direct lender. “How managers navigate this period will be a true test of their ability.”

Patient capital
Having said that, some sources are keen to emphasize that a private credit strategy provides participants with a more flexible, and patient type of capital. “Just because traditional lenders would have been quicker to act, that doesn’t mean this route is always the right decision,” said one market source, adding that a default doesn’t necessarily imply distress. “It could be a trigger for a sponsor to engage new management, or it could be a very benign misrepresentation. Lenders and sponsors using bespoke tools could be described as buying time, but equally they could be preserving value.”

Indeed, defaults in the private credit space are rarely a cliff-edge moment, says Mahmoud at McDermott, Will & Schulte. “They are often a negotiated pause. That flexibility can look like opacity, but it is patient capital at work,” he notes, while adding that public market defaults are by their nature binary and noisy. “Part of why the private credit asset class has scaled so quickly is because it can adapt to stress instead of simply crystallizing it,” Mahmoud concludes.

Songsak Paname/Getty Images/iStockphoto

Learn about our editorial standards.