Conceptual Business Finance growth Chart tends to decline

Featured by Sakchai Vongsasiripat/Getty Images

2024 Wrapped

Funds-of-funds swallow their worst year in fundraising in a decade and a half

Funds-of-funds are on track to finish 2024 with the lowest amount of capital raised in 16 years.

Private market funds-of-funds are on track to finish 2024 with the lowest amount of capital raised in 16 years, as new products overwhelm their prospective investor base.

While capital gathering across various private market strategies slowed this year, the decline in commitments to funds-of-funds signals a more existential threat to the strategy, which involves buying up shares in other private market funds.

Private equity fundraising, for example, declined 10.8% on a trailing 12-month basis as GPs grappled with higher-for-longer interest rates and struggled to return capital to their limited partners; venture capital fell 2.4%; and across private capital strategies, total capital raised dipped 3.4%, according to PitchBook’s Global Private Market Fundraising report.

Total capital raised by funds-of-funds, however, dipped 44.5% on the same trailing 12-month basis, second only to real estate as the strategy that saw the greatest plunge in fundraising this year. In fact, three out of four of the largest PE funds-of-funds experienced step-downs in their fund sizes, the report said.

The private market’s capital raising conundrum over the past two years is a factor in funds-of-funds’ decline: GPs held onto their assets for longer, waiting for more favorable bids, and without distributions, LPs across the board had less capital available to commit to new and follow-on funds.

Still, the wider berth between PE’s fundraising challenges and those of funds-of-funds has more to do with the product’s structure—and the(dwindling) value-add proposition.

Funds-of-funds have long been touted as a source of diversification and downside risk protection for investors.

The typical fund-of-fund structure allows the GP to build a fund of commitments to other private market vehicles. For example, MetLife Investment Private Equity Partners II, a $1.2 billion FoF and one of the few fundraising successes this year, bought a $860 million portfolio of PE and equity co-investment stakes from Lexington Partners to get the fund off the ground.

These vehicles provide their investors with exposure to an array of funds as opposed to writing a single check into one buyout product. A Vanguard analysis of the diversification benefits of funds-of-funds found that the fund type has a narrower return dispersion and lower downside risk relative to buyout and VC strategies.

But the emergence of evergreen and semi-liquid vehicles, which offer similar exposure to a selection of funds and don’t ask their investors to lock up their capital for years, has threatened the market of investors who would typically go for funds-of-funds, namely the private wealth channel.

Unlike traditional drawdown funds, evergreen and semi-liquid products allow LPs to make periodic redemptions. For investors looking to gain exposure to a portfolio of diversified assets without paying the illiquidity premium, evergreen structures are a more compelling option than funds-of-funds, according to PitchBook analysts. Analysts expect funds-of-funds to remain flat or decline by 2024.

Another factor in the decline of funds-of-funds is the chipping away of its greatest value proposition: access. In addition to offering diversification and a hedge against downside risk, funds-of-funds have historically been loved by LPs for their ability to get them into the best PE and VC funds.

“It’s hard for funds-of-funds to justify that there’s still a reason for that product to exist,” said Rush Harvey, director of the private capital advisory at investment bank Raymond James. “There are more and more entrants into private markets and more dedicated resources to analyzing fund managers. I just think the average private wealth platform, family office, institution, etc. believes they can do it themselves.”

Still, Harvey said the funds-of-funds that can retain their exclusive access to top GPs will stand the test of time.

“There’s some really great VC funds-of-funds that can get you exposure to those elite firms on Sand Hill Road that some of the best institutional investors just can’t [reach] because they’re capital constrained,” said Harvey.

Featured by Sakchai Vongsasiripat/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.