Participants at the early November SuperReturn conference in Amsterdam, including buyout firms, direct lenders, advisers and lawyers, described a market that has split in two.
A narrow group of tangible companies seen as safe from AI disruption draws crowded auctions and aggressive financing. On the other hand, assets that raise questions over AI, consumer demand or current trading struggle to attract bids, and even though software deals get done, they get done only selectively.
“The market has become very binary,” said Robert Falk, a partner at Benelux buyout firm Bencis. “Either there is broad enthusiasm and an asset still achieves a very strong price, or it simply doesn’t sell. In the past, buyers were sometimes willing to accept a few imperfections in return for a lower price. Today, if they find something in due diligence they don’t like, they walk away.”
The split is not a sign of distress. European private credit is in a stable but increasingly differentiated state, with core portfolios performing well and deals carrying more conservative structures and lower leverage than in the US, panelists said.
“There is no systemic stress, but there is clear dispersion between strong and weak companies,” one panelist said.
Pressure is concentrated in sectors hit by higher rates or strained government budgets, such as construction, chemicals and care homes, while over-levered 2021-vintage structures are being kept alive through extensions, the panelist said.
More launches, fewer trades
The mood in Amsterdam was cautiously upbeat. Activity has picked up since a quiet September, and advisers have seen a rise in processes coming to market that could make December busy, as evidenced by the LCD M&A pipeline, which has seen a flurry of activity. The Netherlands, the UK and the Nordics are busier than France and the DACH region, where investors are holding back, a direct lender said.
“Much of the year went on portfolio upkeep such as incremental debt, repricings and extensions,” said Folko de Vries, debt finance partner at Clifford Chance in Amsterdam. “New transactions are now arriving quickly, with many aiming to sign before Christmas,” he said.
“It’s probably too soon to tell, but based on the deal flow I have seen, I think Q4 will end up being very busy,” De Vries said.
“The core mid-market remains very attractive and proved foundational to our record quarterly deployment in Q3, and we expect this momentum to continue through year-end and 2027 too, given the backlog of processes that had been deferred earlier this year,” added Joost de Pauw, partner at Ares.
But more launches won’t necessarily mean more deals.
Processes that do launch are taking longer, as buyers scrutinise current trading month by month and a single weak month can be enough to derail a sale, Falk added.
“You see a pipeline and they’re prepping five deals for Q3, and then Q3 comes and you see one deal actually come to market,” a debt adviser added.
Even deals that get going are dragging as buyers scrutinize targets harder in due diligence. “We’ve had a few situations that kicked off and then turned into ‘a chewing-gum process’,” Max Mayer, partner in the finance practice at DLA Piper, said. “Information isn’t coming through, or new information is coming through, maybe a trading update, possibly resulting in valuation issues, and then parties are going back to the drawing board.”
That stop-start pattern is wearing on dealmakers. “It’s a lot of start, stop, go, reassess,” another leveraged finance lawyer said. “And that drives people mental.”
Artificial intelligence is also seemingly adding to the process timelines and deal workload. “Parties are using AI to assess data room information, resulting in substantial Q&A lists. Those lists are then also responded to using AI, resulting in a game of AI ping-pong,” Mayer said, adding that parties are receiving far more questions and therefore processes are taking longer.
Bricks, not bytes
In a market with that kind of dispersion, selectivity becomes the central challenge. Competition has risen, particularly at the larger end of the market, while the lower and middle market has held up better, some panelists said.
Lenders financing small and mid-sized, largely sponsor-backed companies stress that access to the best deals depends on strong relationships with sponsors and management teams, deep credit research and a reputation for trust. Investors are also placing more weight on the conviction of entrepreneurs and sponsors, with more equity going into deals. Opportunities are being found in niche sectors such as energy, construction and “blue-collar” services businesses.
An emphasis on discipline and transparency shapes the manager landscape. Larger platforms are consolidating while smaller managers are squeezed, making fundraising harder for newcomers. “Those who succeed bring patience, a clear strategy, a simple story and institutional-quality infrastructure. Family offices and foundations usually back them first, with large institutions following later, and trust is built through in-person meetings and structures that protect capital in downside scenarios,” one panelist said.
“I think that PE sponsors are selective at the moment and careful how they deploy their capital,” Danielle du Bois-Buné, PE/M&A partner at Hogan Lovells Cadwalader, said.
Mayer added that the market is increasingly selective, with various ‘hot topics’ or ‘concerns’ reappearing on processes. “What’s the hot topic for this one? What’s the topic I should avoid? How can I convince myself that a deal is okay? There are a ton of questions and selective conviction,” he added.
The businesses that do sell in the region share a profile — physical, recurring and hard for software to replace. Market participants pointed to infrastructure and property maintenance, roofing, grid contractors, manufacturing and food as examples. Defense has joined the list.
“There’s strong sponsor demand for cash-generative, asset-based businesses with large moats around technology risk and that’s probably going to continue given the role these companies will play in replacing Europe’s existing infrastructure in the years ahead,” said de Pauw from Ares.
The divide is clearest in the types of businesses attracting interest. Falk said Bencis has seen renewed demand for food companies, which offer resilient consumption and predictable earnings, as well as for defense assets and other businesses with tangible, proven models.
“For a long time, food was not regarded as the most exciting sector,” Falk said. “Today it attracts a lot of interest because investors value its stability. Growth may be modest, but it is very consistent.”
But a popular theme is not automatically an easy credit. A direct lender said the possible outcomes for a drone-detection company were so wide that it was difficult to assess how much debt it could support.
“Would I be surprised if this business has €500 million EBITDA in five years’ time? No. Would I be surprised if this business has €20 million EBITDA in five years’ time? Also, no,” the lender said. The equity story might be compelling, he added, but lenders need a clearer view of cash flow and downside risk.
SaaS anxiety
Software faces a sharper financing test. Investors are asking whether products can be replicated, customers can switch providers and AI could erode margins over a five- to seven-year holding period.
Du Bois-Buné added that buyers are increasingly asking whether a business would change dramatically within their holding period because of AI. “Is this a business that will change dramatically in my holding period or not due to the AI development? Is this then the right time to invest in it?” she said.
The concern is influencing lending even where companies are performing. A market participant described a SaaS borrower who was approaching the fifth year of a seven-year loan and was seeking an extension. It was trading in line with expectations, had paid interest and fees, and offered to pay more for an extension. The lender declined because the business sat in its internal SaaS category and the fund wanted to reduce that exposure.
The borrower sought a refinancing. “Twenty lenders said, ‘No, I’m not doing it,’” the partner quoted above said.
The reluctance is not necessarily a verdict on each company’s performance. One market participant said lenders had become more cautious about adding software exposure after LPs questioned managers’ concentration in the sector, and not because the companies were bad.
For deals that still attract lenders, that reduced appetite has pushed margins 25 to 50bps higher than six to nine months earlier.
Rewriting the playbook
Meanwhile, sellers are adapting. “Broad auctions are now reserved for assets expected to spark a bidding war, while others sound out strategic buyers early,” du Bois-Buné added.
“When it fails, then of course the asset will be slightly tainted, and then you need to either put a pin in the sale process for a year or two, or look at alternative exit routes such as continuation vehicles,” she added.
Sponsors are also buying time. Amend-and-extend deals have run all year, and holdco PIK and other subordinated instruments are more common than a few years ago, De Vries said.
When deals do run into trouble, or when investors need an exit, secondaries and continuation vehicles offer a useful source of liquidity, with rescue and solutions capital earning returns of roughly 12% to 14%, according to one panellist.
Waiting for a reset
For sponsors still holding assets, the valuation gap remains a central obstacle. Buyers want evidence that earnings are durable, while sellers are reluctant to accept a lower price that could reset valuations elsewhere in their portfolios.
Appetite has recently shifted towards Europe, and investors debate whether to be Europe-focused or global. Some argue that investing locally makes sense and that regulatory changes may steer more capital to credit, while others remain invested in the US, where opportunities continue to arise as investors rebalance. Europe is where many feel most comfortable, with activity across France, the UK and Italy supporting diversification.
Meanwhile, market participants say a change in return expectations could unlock activity. “If everyone says, you know what guys, we don’t need 20%, we’re okay with 15%, I reckon then you’ll get deal flow,” one said.
Karl Hendon/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.