There is no denying the economics of private equity have been more challenging lately. Higher interest rates, economic instability and a liquidity logjam have stalled dealmaking and put pressure on returns.
The IRR across PE funds globally was just 2.26% in Q3 2023, according to the most recent PitchBook Benchmarks, and preliminary data suggests it was -0.43% in Q4 2023.
Should PE investors be feeling jittery? Emphatically no, says Oliver Gardey, head of private equity fund investments at ICG Enterprise Trust—an investment trust that invests with buyout-focused PE managers—who stresses that PE is inherently a long-term business.
Investment trusts are companies listed on the London Stock Exchange that invest shareholder capital in other businesses in order to generate a profit.
PitchBook sat down with Gardey and Colm Walsh, a managing director on ICG Enterprise Trust’s investment team, to discuss the firm’s approach to PE investing, why it believes there is plenty of life left in the buyout model and how its own investor base continues to diversify.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
PitchBook: How does ICG Enterprise Trust decide which GPs to invest with?
Gardey: Let’s go back to first principles. Private equity has been one of the best-performing asset classes over several decades, but it is also riskier. The dispersion between a top-quartile fund and a bottom-quartile fund is larger than in other asset classes. Therefore, picking the right managers and funds is especially important in private equity.
We target returns of around 12% to 15% net IRR.
How do we achieve those returns while also managing risk? Number one, we only invest in buyout funds. With venture and growth equity investing the loss ratio is somewhere around 60% to 75%, whereas with buyouts it is around 10%, so it is completely different risk profile. We also don’t allocate into private debt, real estate or other alternatives.
We only focus on markets where there is very deep knowledge, expertise, and a strong pipeline of quality managers and deals. Which effectively means the US and Europe, where we do a 50/50 split.
Walsh: You can still get good managers in other geographies, but the overall depth of the ecosystem is not the same.
Gardey: The next part is we target top-tier managers, specifically the mid-to-large cap market. We believe that funds of over $1 billion have the necessary investing experience and the team and resources to deliver what makes private equity perform better than other asset classes.
The long-term investment approach of transforming good companies into market-leading companies is very resource-intensive and requires experienced professionals across a range of disciplines, and that’s what we’re looking for. Funds that have the resources and operational capacity to source good companies and then to transform them.
The final part is that we look for managers and strategies that are aligned with our defensive growth theme, i.e., focused on companies and sectors where performance is not cyclical or seasonal, but not so defensive that there is very limited growth potential.
Market conditions have challenged the LBO model recently and led some to question its long-term health. Do you still believe there is a lot of value to be found in buyouts?
Gardey: We take a long-term view. You have to if you want to succeed in private equity. Fundamentally, we believe that there is long-term viability and sustainability in the asset class. You are transforming businesses, but transformation does not happen overnight.
Of course, there are certain cycles where returns get an extra boost, such as when there are lower interest rates. But looking at our portfolio, in our analysis, roughly a third of returns are generated by financial engineering, where lower interest rates help. But two-thirds are generated from the more fundamental transformation of a company, expanding sales and profitability, etc.
Walsh: We also back managers for whom this is not their first time at the rodeo. Many have invested and generated strong returns through high interest rate cycles in the past. We also typically don’t invest in managers who are excessive users of leverage.
You paint a relatively upbeat picture of PE’s long-term health. In the shorter term, have you been concerned by the relatively low level of realizations and distributions?
Walsh: There has been a significant fall in realization rates across the market, but if you look at M&A activity, it is no massive surprise that there has been a fall in realizations, not to mention the interest rate volatility, etc., that has made a lot of transactions undesirable.
There has been a lot of chatter about how everyone is suddenly very focused on DPI. We have always been focused on it. It’s very important to us in managing an evergreen vehicle and we tend to back managers that understand the importance of regular realizations.
Not to overstate the recovery, but we have started to see some larger deals coming to market, which is encouraging, and we will have to see if that is part of a broader pattern
What does your own investor base look like?
Gardey: Roughly half of our investors are retail investors who come through trading platforms. The other half is more institutional, whether that is pension schemes investing on behalf of members that would like exposure to private equity, private wealth platforms and private banks who recommend it as a product to their clients or small asset managers who do not have enough capital to execute a diversified private equity investment strategy directly but would still like that exposure.
Currently, our investor base is fairly UK-centric, but over recent years international interest has increased and we do have some investors from other jurisdictions.
What has been interesting in recent years is that the number of investors investing via trading platforms has been increasing, and we put that down to a younger audience of more digitally savvy investors taking an interest.
What have traditionally been the main barriers for noninstitutional investors to gain exposure to private equity?
Gardey: To put it bluntly, it comes down to having enough capital to invest. The minimum ticket size to invest in a buyout fund is typically around $10 million, and that is only one fund. To get decent diversification within private equity you would need to invest in 20 to 30 funds, so you’d need around $300 million. You also don’t want to put all of your assets into private equity, let’s say more like 15% to 20%. Therefore, it is really inaccessible for the majority of the market. Whereas with our structure, investors are able to get access to a diversified portfolio of buyout funds for the price of a share.
Walsh: Relationships with fund managers is also important. Individual investors do not have those relationships and so there does need to be some kind of intermediary. As an institution with a long heritage and relationships with many leading managers, we are able to offer investors that exposure to a mature private equity portfolio straight away.
Featured image by Nico De Pasquale Photography/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.