Default and restructurings continued at pace in May, with one bankruptcy filing and four out-of-court liability management transactions among companies in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index. Nevertheless, with big-ticket issuers rolling off the 12-month calculation, the payment default rate by amount fell to its lowest level in 15 months.
As of May 31, the trailing 12-month default rates of the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index were as follows:
- Payment default rate (PDR) by amount: 1.08%
- PDR by issuer count: 1.83%
- Dual-track default rate (DTDR) by issuer count: 4.35%
LCD’s monthly default report features the legacy payment default rate and a dual-track default rate that includes distressed exchanges. More details and the methodology can be found here.
Starting with the payment default rate (excluding distressed liability management transactions): three issuers rolled off the trailing twelve-month calculation in May, including sizable defaults across three facilities at Envision Healthcare; two facilities at Monitronics International; and one facility at Venator Materials Corp. Together, $4.16 billion left the default calculation in May.
With one new joiner courtesy of a Chapter 11 filing by Dynata, formerly known as Research Now, the payment default rate by amount fell to 1.08% in May, from 1.31% in April. This marks a 15-month low for the default rate, and is 67 bps lower than the recent peak of 1.75% in July 2023.
By issuer count, the payment default rate remains more elevated by comparison. The rate eased to 1.83% in May, from 1.99% in April. Though down from a recent peak of 2.07% in February, it remains above its 10-year average of 1.62%.
Running in tandem with the legacy payment default rate, the dual-track calculation includes both payment defaults of the legacy rate and distressed transactions stemming from out-of-court restructurings, exchanges and sub-par buybacks. On that front, four companies in the index conducted distressed liability management transactions in May. With five issuers rolling off, the dual-track 12-month trailing default rate by issuer count eased to 4.35%, from 4.42% in April.
Loan to own
Dynata, formerly known as Research Now Group, filed Chapter 11 in bankruptcy court in Wilmington, Del. with an agreement to write down almost 40% of its total debt from approximately $1.3 billion to $780 million, in exchange for the first- and second-lien holders to own 100% of the equity in the company.
The company said, “The restructuring is supported by the required percentage of Dynata’s lenders, including its revolver, first-lien term loan, and second-lien term loan lenders and its sponsor, who committed to support the prepackaged plan.”
According to the court disclosure statement, several factors led up to the restructuring, including increasing competition in the data intelligence industry, a slow M&A market environment stifling demand for data and analytics, the pandemic and soaring interest rates almost doubling the amount of cash interest obligations for the debtors.
The first-lien term loan due 2024 had approximately $920.77 million outstanding at the time of filing.
Dual-tracking
Turning to liability management transactions contributing to the dual-track default rate, broadcasting company Cumulus Media completed a restructuring where it swapped out the majority of existing debt obligations due 2026. This included the company’s $329.5 million senior secured term loan due 2026, a constituent of the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index. Lenders received about 95% of par in the form of a new term loan with an extended maturity date of May 2, 2029. The spread on the new senior secured term loan only increased by 125 bps, which S&P did not view as adequate offsetting compensation.
Cumulus is the third-largest radio broadcaster in the US by revenue behind iHeartMedia Inc. and Audacy Inc., each of which have filed for bankruptcy, in 2018 and 2024, respectively.
S&P Global Ratings lowered the first-lien term loans backing EyeCare Partners to D in May, after lowering the company to SD in April. The downgrade of the term loans due 2028 followed a distressed transaction to convert cash interest to paid-in-kind interest, a less than par exchange, an extension of maturities and lower priority given the addition of new superpriority term loans.
The Missouri-based eyecare service provider has been dealing with staffing shortages, higher inflationary costs and pressure from rising interest rates, causing its liquidity and covenant cushions to tighten.
Also from the healthcare sector, air and ground medical transport service provider Global Medical Response Inc. (Air Medical Group Holdings) was lowered to Selective Default at S&P and its term loans due 2025 were dropped to D. The transaction targeting its index loans extended maturities to 2028 and changed interest to a cash interest spread of 475 basis points (bps) and a payment-in-kind (PIK) interest spread of 75 bps, which the agency doesn’t view as adequate compensation for the maturity extension.
Finally for liability management transactions in May, education technology company Astra Acquisition Corp. (d/b/a Anthology) exchanged all of its outstanding senior secured first-lien term loan due October 2028, a constituent of the loan index, and a portion of its senior secured second-lien term loan due October 2029, at a discount to par, for several tranches of secured debt.
Sponsor-backed
When excluding distressed exchanges, breaking down sponsored versus non-sponsored companies shows the rate of hard defaults of payment misses and bankruptcy filings among sponsored companies has topped that of non-sponsored companies since March. Prior to then, this hadn’t happened since late 2022. This bucks prior trends during elevated default periods, such as the 2016 uptick in defaults driven by increased oil prices and the 2020 pandemic, when sponsored companies typically defaulted at a much lower rate.
While default rates are falling and secondary market prices are rallying, distressed metrics are trending less favorably.
The share of performing loans priced below 80 — a marker for the loan distress ratio and a demonstrated indicator for heightened default activity — increased for a third consecutive month in May, rising 52 bps to 4.47%, from 3.95% in April. In February, the distress ratio was sitting at 3.35%, which was the lowest level since August 2022. The metric hit a recent high of 7.36% in December 2022.
Meanwhile, ratings agency activity also skewed more negatively in May. The ratio of downgrades to upgrades on a rolling three-month basis climbed to 2.24x, from 1.82x in April. This metric hit a recent high of 3.32x in February 2023.
Finally, looking at the breathing room of companies and their ability to service interest payments shows a still-elevated share of issuers with an interest coverage sitting at critical levels of less than 1.5x.
Per LCD’s analysis looking at public filers, amounting to 158 companies in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index, the share of issuers with cash-flow coverage of less than 1.5x dipped to 23% in the first quarter, from 26% in the third quarter last year and a 2020 peak at 29%. However, that group remains much larger now than in the third quarter of 2021, when less than 9% of the sample was at the outer edge for coverage, amid record-low funding costs at the time.
Featured image: KTSDESIGN/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY/Getty Images/Science Photo Library RF
Learn about our editorial standards.