Restructuring activity picked up in February with four out-of-court liability management transactions and four issuer payment defaults among companies in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index.
As of Feb. 29, the trailing 12-month default rates of the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index were as follows:
- Payment default rate (PDR) by amount: 1.41%
- Payment default rate (PDR) by issuer count: 2.07%
- Dual-track default rate (DTDR) by issuer count: 4.32%
Note that LCD’s monthly default report will feature the legacy payment default rate and a blended default rate including distressed exchanges.
Starting with the legacy payment default rate (excluding distressed exchanges): Four additions lifted the legacy default rate by issuer count to 2.07%, its highest level since April 2021, when pandemic-related defaults began rolling off the trailing calculation.
By amount, the default rate at 1.41% is down slightly from 1.47% in January.
The rate by amount remains below the historical average default rate of 2.66% and the 10-year average of 1.83%. By issuer count, the rate exceeds the 10-year average of 1.59% and is just 40 bps below the historical average of 2.47%.
Liability management
Running in tandem with the legacy payment default rate, the dual-track calculation includes both payment defaults of the legacy rate and distressed transactions stemming from out-of-court restructurings, exchanges and sub-par buybacks. Four companies conducted distressed transactions targeting index loans, raising the blended 12-month trailing default rate by issuer count to 4.32%, from 4.03% in January.
Payment misses and bankruptcy filings among leveraged loan issuers are clearly rising from lows since the start of the pandemic; however, distressed exchanges as a share of overall default activity are skyrocketing.
In 2019, for example, leveraged companies conducting distressed exchanges targeting index loans represented just 10% of default activity, versus 90% for payment and bankruptcy defaults.
In 2020, this rose to 22%.
Since then, distressed exchanges have accounted for a considerable chunk of the default landscape. During the relatively low default period of 2021, these transactions as a share of defaults jumped to 55%. As default activity picked up momentum with rising interest rates, the share of distressed exchanges remained elevated, at 53% of defaults in 2022 and 47% in 2023.
For the 12 months ended February 2024, LCD data show distressed liability transactions as a share of the total default landscape again crept higher, to 52%.
Zooming in on restructuring activity targeting index loans in February, Robertshaw Controls Company has kept legal advisors busy this past year with two out-of-court restructurings utilizing uptier transactions, two state court litigations on behalf of spurned lenders and finally, a Chapter 11 filing in February.
Via its bankruptcy petition on Feb. 15, the appliance component manufacturer is seeking to eliminate approximately $670 million of debt, as well as using the Chapter 11 process to resolve litigation claims.
Before reaching bankruptcy court, the company in May last year exchanged its $510 million first-lien term loan and $110 million second-lien term loan for new junior-priority term loans, prompting a downgrade of the company and the affected debt, to SD and D, respectively. More specifically, participating lenders of the first-lien term loan swapped into new second-, third-, and fourth-out debt facilities, while participating lenders of the second-lien term loan received a new fifth-out debt facility.
Robertshaw returned in December to enact a second restructuring that would further prime the second-out term loan, prompting another Selective Default designation of the company and a downgrade of the loan to D.
The company’s prepetition second-out superpriority term loan due 2027, with $382 million outstanding, and its prepetition third-out term loan due 2027, with $73 million outstanding, are constituents of the loan index.
Elsewhere, Cano Health on Feb. 5 filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in Delaware after inking a restructuring support agreement (RSA) with the majority of its lenders.
Mark Kent, CEO and board member of Cano, said in his first-day declaration that the company filed for Chapter 11 after depleting its liquidity. Over the past couple of years, Cano pursued an “aggressive” acquisition strategy that failed to realize “material synergies” while experiencing sustained operational efficiencies, added expenses and “industry and regulatory headwinds,” such as increased competition in the Medicare Advantage insurance market, according to Kent.
As of the petition date, Cano’s $933.1 million of secured funded debt obligations included $631.5 million under its Credit Suisse-arranged term loan due 2027, a constituent of the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index.
Trade claims
Also on the chopping block in February, construction staffing agency Tradesmen International failed to pay the interest and outstanding amount due on its first-lien term loan on the maturity date. Citing minimal cash balances, S&P on Feb. 21 downgraded the company to D, with the agency citing its expectation that Tradesmen would not make the payments due within the grace period.
The company’s challenges stemming from the Covid-19 pandemic and macroeconomic headwinds were compounded more recently by tightening credit conditions and costly debt terms. Tradesmen’s $255 million (initial amount) first-lien term loan due Feb. 23, 2024 was placed in 2017 to fund its acquisition by Blackstone.
Finally for payment defaults, Toronto-based commercial real estate service provider Avison Young failed to make required quarterly principal and interest payments on its senior secured term loan. The company’s liquidity position took a hit from depressed commercial real estate activity and its high debt burden. The company’s $325 million (initial amount) term loan B due 2026 was allocated in 2019 to finance an acquisition and refinance debt.
Turning to liability management transactions that, in addition to payment defaults, contribute to the dual-track rate, software company GoTo Group (formerly LogMeIn) completed a debt exchange with 78% of its existing term loan lenders and 57% of its 5.5% senior notes holders for a mix of first-lien/first-out and first-lien/second-out term loans and secured bonds due 2028. GoTo’s $1.75 billion (initial amount) term loan B due 2027 was allocated in 2020 to fund its buyout by Francisco Partners and Evergreen Coast Capital Corp., the private equity affiliate of Elliott Management.
Elsewhere, home healthcare provider AccentCare completed an exchange of its $852 million (outstanding amount) term loan due 2026 for new second-out loans as part of a broader transaction.
Radiology Partners completed a transaction that extends the maturities and modifies other terms of its debt obligations, along with repaying $168 million of an outstanding term loan. In addition to lowering the company to SD, S&P also downgraded the company’s first-lien term loan to D, from CCC+, with the agency saying it believes lenders received less than originally promised.
Finally, Apex Tool Group exchanged existing first-lien term loans for new tranche A term loans issued at a discount.
Returning to the default data, media and healthcare providers took the top shares in the 12-month tally by issuer count for payment defaults, at 17% apiece.
For distressed transactions, healthcare providers and IT services were in the top spots, at 17% and 14%, respectively.
The volume of legacy loan defaults stemming from payment misses and bankruptcy filings eased for a second consecutive month, to $19.61 billion in the trailing 12-month calculation, down from $20.57 billion in January.
Staying with payment defaults, the legacy loan payment default rate (PDR) by issuer count in February was 1.75% for sponsored companies versus 2.53% for non-sponsored. This is measured as a trailing 12-month calculation of defaults among performing sponsored and non-sponsored companies in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index.
To reiterate, this metric does not include distressed exchanges, which are more likely to preserve the equity stake held by private equity owners and their control of the company, a particular pain-point for PE firms during market downturns, explaining the lower instances of sponsored defaults during busier default periods.
Turning to forward measures of potential stress, the share of performing loans priced below 80 — a marker for the loan distress ratio and a demonstrated indicator for heightened default activity — eased to 3.35% in February, the lowest level since August 2022 and down from 4.54% at the end of the year.
Rating agency activity also continues to trend more favorably. The ratio of downgrades to upgrades on a rolling three-months basis has eased from a seven-month high of 2.42x in December, to 2.13x in January and now 1.97x in February.
Featured image: EschCollection/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.