Crossing Rings with Spheres

MirageC/Getty Images

Private Credit

Life insurers lend to private credit funds they back, adding risk – Clearwater

Life insurers have played a massive role in funding the rise of private credit.

Life insurers’ deep ties to the private credit industry have drawn regulators’ attention in recent years, but a new report from Clearwater Analytics identifies what it describes as a subtle concentration risk that has been underappreciated in life insurance portfolios, as the firm estimates that 10-20% of insurers with LP exposures to private credit funds are also exposed to the underlying fund’s debt.

The June 24 report states that private credit does not pose “systemic” risks, but that the greater risk identified in its dataset of insurer portfolios was the potential for “cross-contamination” risk that occurs when a life insurer holds both an equity-like interest in a private credit fund as an LP while simultaneously lending to the same vehicle by holding a senior note issued by that same fund.

The life insurer in these instances has gained exposure to the private credit fund as both an equity investor in the fund and as a holder of the debt that the fund uses to lever its portfolio. “The insurer has, in effect, taken correlated exposure to the same risk pool through two ostensibly different channels and asset classes,” the Clearwater report says.

Life insurers have played a massive role in funding the rise of private credit. Clearwater data show that median US life insurer allocations to private credit are at about 9% of total portfolio assets, growing 110% since 2021. Additionally, the upper quartile of life insurers’ exposure to private credit as a share of the total portfolio is 31.3%, Matthew Vegari, head of research at Clearwater, told PitchBook LCD.

A report from the Wall Street Journal, which first reported on the Clearwater data, estimates that life insurers lent about $24 billion to private credit funds in which they owned stakes valued at roughly $12 billion. The lending figures could be higher, WSJ said, because Clearwater does not track most very large insurers, which are more likely to lend to private credit funds.

The Clearwater research is based on data sourced from the investment portfolios of institutional investors on its platform, with the report focusing on US insurers with at least $500 million in assets.

The Clearwater report notes that its scope is limited, and that it does not address the role of PE–owned and affiliated insurance platforms, the use of synthetic risk transfers as a channel between bank and nonbank balance sheets, or the proliferation of private credit ratings issued by smaller agencies for regulatory capital purposes, stating that “each is a real and well-documented concern, and each is worthy of its own treatment.”

The tie-ups between insurers and private credit have raised questions from several regulators and rating agencies. Last year, the IMF scrutinized the links between insurers and private credit firms, noting that a growing share of insurers’ private credit exposure is sourced through affiliated private credit managers or partnerships with private credit managers, “which requires special attention because of potential conflicts of interest and the lack of transparency.”

The Federal Reserve Board of Governors also drew attention to “arguably opaque” investment structures between life insurers and private credit firms in a separate report last year.

Sign up for The Credit Pitch

Weekly coverage of US and European loans, bonds, private credit, and more.

That report highlighted several life insurers that have partnerships with asset managers, such as Athene (affiliated with Apollo), Blackstone Insurance (which includes life insurance businesses formerly operating under AIG and Allstate brands), Global Atlantic (affiliated with KKR), MassMutual (affiliated with Barings and Jefferies), American National Financial (affiliated with Brookfield), Aspida (affiliated with Ares), Equitable Life (affiliated with AllianceBernstein) and Talcott (affiliated with Sixth Street).

Clearwater is backed by private credit lenders as well, as Private Credit at Goldman Sachs Alternatives provided committed debt financing for the firm’s $8.4 billion take-private acquisition by Permira and Warburg Pincus, according to a June 25 company statement. The deal was backed with $3.5 billion of debt.

The full Clearwater report can be accessed here.

MirageC/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.