What are the private markets, and why should you care?

Featured image: Kupicoo/Getty Images

Distressed & Defaults

Leveraged loan default rate holds steady at 0.82% by amount, LMEs remain in focus

When including three distressed LMEs, the combined rate with payment defaults jumped to 4.31%, from 4.18% in February.

Want to see more? Fill out the form below.

I agree to PitchBook’s privacy policy

Restructuring activity among companies in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index stepped up a notch in March as a contentious bankruptcy filing, a missed interest payment and three distressed liability management exercises joined the calculation.

As of March 31, the trailing 12-month default rates of the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index were as follows:

  • Payment default rate by amount: 0.82%
  • Payment default rate by issuer count: 1.23%
  • Dual-track default rate by issuer count: 4.31%

LCD’s monthly default report features the legacy payment default rate and a dual-track default rate by count that includes index issuers conducting distressed liability management exercises (LMEs). More details and the methodology can be found here.

Starting with the payment default rate, one issuer (Jo-Ann Stores) rolled off the trailing 12-month calculation, and two joined. While this left the payment default rate (excluding distressed LMEs) by amount nearly unchanged, at 0.82%, the rate by issuer count rose 10 bps, to 1.23%.

The payment default rate by amount is now 93 bps lower than the post-rate-hike cycle peak of 1.75% in July 2023.

The 10-year averages are 1.56% by amount and 1.67% by issuer count.

When including the three distressed LMEs that prompted a downgrade to ‘D’ or ‘SD’ in March, the combined rate with payment defaults jumped to 4.31%, from 4.18% in February. That compares to the recent high of 4.70% in December 2024.

Focusing solely on distressed LMEs, the trailing 12-month calculation of issuers in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index conducting these out-of-court transactions remained at 35. This compares to 28 in March 2024 and 10 in March 2023.

As the above chart shows, while payment defaults were relatively contained in 2024, distressed LMEs were plentiful last year, shifting the landscape for managing unsustainable debt burdens away from conventional defaults.

Indeed, the trailing 12-month count of LMEs has outpaced payment defaults and bankruptcies in every month in 2024 and the trend has continued so far in 2025.

In 2023, defaults via interest payment misses or bankruptcy filings outnumbered LMEs in every single month of the year.

In terms of share of the restructuring landscape, for the 12 months through March 31, LMEs made up 71% of the count, down from 73% in the February reading. The February share set a new high watermark, eclipsing the previous peak of 71% reached in both October 2024 and September 2021.

Looking more closely at the March default culprits, Mitel Networks headlines as the latest example of the murky world faced by loan lenders where the priority treatment of payouts — which traditionally would have followed a path to a designated waterfall at bankruptcy — instead rests on the outcome of aggressive or coercive out-of-court LMEs that change the goalposts ahead of the day of reckoning and, in Mitel’s case, also hinge on a few words of documentation language.

The Canadian communication services provider enacted an “uptiering” balance sheet maneuver in 2022 that left excluded lenders pushed further down the repayment line. A lawsuit followed that would later be ruled upon on the exact same day that Serta Simmons undertook a similarly structured transaction, but with differing outcomes to the detriment of Mitel’s excluded lenders.

Mitel Networks on March 9 filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in the Southern District of Texas with a restructuring support agreement (RSA) supported by an ad hoc group of senior lenders, plus certain junior lenders and stakeholders. More specifically, holders of 72.1% of the company’s priority lien claims, 81.1% of its non-priority term loan claims and all its ABL loans agreed to the RSA. Mitel’s term loan B due 2025 was issued in 2018 to fund its take-private acquisition by an investor group led by Searchlight Capital Partners.

Also contributing to the payment default rate, Francisco Partners-backed Rugs USA missed a March 3 interest payment, prompting a downgrade of its term loan B due 2028 to D at S&P Global Ratings. The agency said it didn’t expect Rugs USA to make the interest payment within the debt’s five-day grace period given “ongoing liquidity issues,” noting that the company’s $75 million revolver due 2026 was fully drawn as of Sept. 30.

Maneuvering
Turning to LME defaults, Apollo-owned staffing provider EmployBridge completed an exchange transaction in which the company issued a new money term loan and second-out exchange term loan to replace an existing delayed-draw term loan and first-lien term loan B. The swap prompted S&P on March 14 to downgrade the company to Selective Default, and its term loan B due 2028 to D.

“We consider the transaction distressed because in our view, the lenders have received less than originally promised. Additionally, our view is that there was not adequate compensation for the maturity date being pushed back until 2030,” the agency stated.

Pharmaceuticals maker Alvogen completed a comprehensive debt-restructuring transaction in which existing lenders of its $727 million first-lien term loan due June 2025 will be paid about 83.5% of outstanding principal in cash. The remaining holdings will be exchanged at par for a $115.6 million second-lien loan due 2029 and receive an interest rate step-up of 200 bps, 800 bps of which is payment in-kind (PIK).

According to S&P, to fund the cash payment, the company will issue $553 million of first-lien debt, which will have priority over the $115.6 million of second-lien notes. The agency on March 7 downgraded the company to Selective Default (SD) from CCC+ and CreditWatch Negative, citing the first-lien loan refinancing. The loan was downgraded to D, from CCC+.

“In our view, the transaction constitutes a shortfall relative to the original promise of the term loan due to the delay in maturity, revision of some of the interest to PIK, and the subordination to new debt,” S&P said.

Finally, Pretium Packaging returned with its third distressed transaction. The plastics packaging manufacturer bought back a portion of its second-lien term loan due 2029 at a substantial discount to par, prompting downgrades by S&P of the issuer to Selective Default, and the loan to D. This follows a separate sub-par repurchase of the same loan in September, and a distressed exchange that in 2023 targeted a majority of its then-$1.3 billion first-lien lenders.

By sector
Sticking with distressed LMEs for the last 12 months, Healthcare Providers & Services and Media held an equal share, at 14%, at the end of March. Software fell from the top spot, with an 11% share of transactions, down from 14% in February. Containers & Packaging was also at an 11% share at the end of the month.

Defaults 5.png

Meanwhile, with Mitel Networks filing for Chapter 11, the percentage of companies that conducted an LME in 2022 only to later default on payments or declare bankruptcy has risen to 44%.

Downgrades ease
In forward-looking measures, the ratio of downgrades to upgrades plunged in March after surging higher over the past few months. The three-month rolling measure of downgrades to upgrades fell markedly to 2.96x, from 4.69x in February, which was the highest reading for this metric since July 2020.

Finally, looking at price-based measures, the distress ratio ticked higher, but remains range-bound at a historically low base. In March, the distress ratio (by par amount) climbed to 3.21%, from 3.05% in February and 3.02% at year-end. This compares to the 10-year average of 4.16%, and a high of 7.36% in December 2022, ahead of an interest rate-driven uptick in defaults in 2023.

Featured image: Kupicoo/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.