As financing costs skyrocketed and buyout activity plummeted, fewer of the sponsor-owned companies that did come to market to raise debt in 2023 supported their first-lien funding with a second-lien term loan or an unsecured bond issue. The result was a near-negligible debt cushion.
According to LCD data tracking the financials of leveraged buyouts, the buffer of subordinated debt in last year’s (albeit lighter) sample fell to just 6%, from an already relatively low watermark of 18% in 2022.
A thinning debt cushion has historically reduced the recovery rate of senior debt in the event of a default. There are several variables at play, however. The narrowing cushion last year coincided with a reduction in total leverage, as sponsors became more dependent on the equity piece of the capital structure to provide their backing. Furthermore, this issuance, on average, carried better ratings at the company level. Of the sponsored companies raising debt for buyouts, only 5% were rated B-, versus 69% in 2022 and 56% in 2021, LCD data show, meaning that although the thinner debt cushion could impact recoveries in the event of default, the likelihood of default to begin with may be lower than in past vintages.
Subordinated debt
Second-lien loans, or the share of loan debt subordinated to the first-lien term loans in LCD’s analysis, were for the first time in more than 20 years completely absent from the broadly syndicated US leveraged finance market in 2023.
The negligible second-lien loan issuance in the syndicated primary market since the start of 2023 contrasts with the $14.8 billion average annual issuance amount over the prior 10 years, and from a recent high of $26.2 billion in 2021.
With the spread to maturity of outstanding second-lien loans peaking at over 1400 bps at the start of 2023, the universe of second-lien loans contracted.
Indeed, companies refinancing this more expensive debt drove the count of performing second-lien loans in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index to the lowest number since August 2013, at 82 facilities as of the end of January. That’s down from 107 in January 2023, and at its height, 187 in February 2019. Note that the index excludes privately placed loans. Five of those loans were absorbed by private credit lenders in high-profile takeouts, including Hyland Software and Finastra (Misys).
Pledging collateral
While PE firms did turn to bond issuance to layer debt for their buyout financing in 2023, this came entirely via secured issuance for the first time in the historically unsecured market. This also could impact recovery rates for senior lenders in the event of default.
For perspective, in 2022, 50% of high-yield issuance supporting buyouts by sponsors were secured bonds, and in 2021, it was 47%.
Through the end of 2022, secured debt comprised 27% of sponsor buyout issuance from the time LCD began tracking the market.
This uptick in secured bonds, over unsecured, was in part facilitated by higher underlying base rates negating the reach for yield into riskier unsecured debt on the investor side, while lower-rated issuers generally have tapped the market with secured bond issuance at a greater share than their higher-rated counterparts.
For first-lien lenders, however, this transition from unsecured to secured bonds could ultimately impact the overcollateralization rate of the issuer’s assets.
To that end, the thinning debt cushion behind last year’s first-lien loans is further evident in leverage multiples.
In 2021 and 2022, second-lien loans backed 0.8 turns of total leverage, but in 2023, that trimmed to 0.1 turns, the lowest full-year reading since 2010.
LCD studies have demonstrated that debt cushion and seniority have a direct impact on recoveries. Loans with more than a 75% cushion, for example, have a 94% average discounted recovery. The average discounted recovery is 87% for bank loans with a 51-75% cushion, 73% for those with a 26-50% cushion, and 70% for a cushion of 25% or less.
Looking ahead, a second-lien loan by Applied Systems that launched in the broadly syndicated market in February suggests companies are gearing up to refinance at better rates following the surge of take-outs last year.
The refinancing of its existing $565 million second-lien loan due September 2027 shaved 150 bps off the spread and extended the debt to 2032. However, with consensus leaning toward the Fed beginning to cut rates in June, the demand for unsecured debt in a higher-yielding environment could keep focus on secured bonds in the financing stack of buyouts. Indeed, of the seven buyouts launched with first-lien loans so far this year, only Shearer’s Foods tagged on junior debt, choosing secured high-yield bonds alongside its $1.22 billion term loan B in funding its acquisition by Clayton, Dubilier & Rice from Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan Board.
Featured image: krisanapong detraphiphat/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.