Header image

Adriana Hansen/PitchBook News

Middle Market

LPs are lowering their return expectations, but don’t expect fundraising to get easier

Institutional investors are coming to the realization that the era of easy, outsized returns is over.
Header image

Adriana Hansen/PitchBook News

It has become harder in recent years for even the best private equity managers to deliver outsized returns. Limited partners have internalized this new reality and are adjusting their expectations, according to several placement agents and pension consultants.

From 2010 to 2019, ultra-low interest rates, rising valuations and a more active exit market enabled most PE firms to deliver strong returns.

Top-quartile funds consistently delivered net distributions above 2x across vintages from 2009 through 2014, PitchBook data shows. Funds of the 2010 vintage performed strongest in that period, generating a DPI of 2.35x and a net TVPI, which measures realized and unrealized returns, of 3.24x.

GPs came back to market more frequently during this stretch, raising ever-larger funds and confidently marking up the unrealized assets in their portfolios. Fueled by that momentum, many LPs came to expect gross returns of three to four times invested capital from their managers, according to David Conrod, the co-founder and CEO of FocusPoint Private Capital Group, which helps smaller managers raise funds.

This couldn’t last forever. A sharp hike in interest rates following the pandemic upended that sanguine mood, as the end of cheap debt and the changing math of valuations evaporated strong paper performance.

“DPI, overall, is down, even in the lower end of the market, compared to what it was a few years ago,” said David Smith, a senior vice president in Callan’s Alternatives Consulting group, which advises pension funds, endowments and foundations. “The higher interest rates have made a big impact on DPI across the board, and managers are holding companies longer.”

While many investors are still requiring meaningful returns from buyout funds today, especially for managers in the middle or lower middle market, their expectations have become more realistic.

Conrod said that for funds in the market today, LPs are generally expecting a net IRR of 15% to 20% for top-quality managers, with expectations for median managers closer to the low to mid-teens.

Sign up for The Daily Pitch newsletter

“A 2.5x to 3.5x MOIC deal-level return remains the gross target in 2026, but at the fund level, LPs are realistically targeting roughly 1.8x to 2.3x net MOIC, with top-quartile clearing at about 2.3x net,” Conrod said, citing data from pension consultant Cambridge Associates.

Other advisers suggest that some LPs are increasingly willing to accept returns of less than two-times net from top-quartile managers—not that they are necessarily willing to admit it.

“Everybody looks around and sees returns compressing, and everybody’s feeling this big disconnect,” said Brey Jones, co-founder of Thirdpath, which builds customized private investment portfolios. “But LPs don’t seem to want to say, ‘We were targeting 2x returns. Now we understand what’s going on in the marketplace, we’re really targeting 1.6 returns.’”

LPs are giving managers credit when judging the performance of funds raised during the pandemic era. Those closed between 2019 and 2021 have deployed capital amid an environment characterized by interest rate hikes, crushed valuations and limited exit optionality, causing a structural repricing of what returns are achievable.

“Raised interest rates mean sponsors must generate 12% annual earnings growth to achieve a 20% IRR with a five-year holding period,” Conrod said. This is more than double the 5% required in the prior cycle, according to Bain & Company’s Global Private Equity Report 2026.

Real-life performance flatters to deceive

The data suggests that many PE funds are falling below even the lowered expectations of LPs. Among the top-quartile of PE funds, the 2016 vintage—now nearing the end of its typical fund life—had achieved a net DPI of 1.55x as of the end of September 2025, while vintages since 2018 have remained below 1x, according to the most recent PitchBook Benchmarks report.

The picture is starker when you look at the median 2016-vintage fund, which has produced a net DPI of 1.27x. Every vintage in the years since has failed so far to deliver DPI of 1x.

US funds sized between $100 million and $5 billion delivered a net DPI of 1.41x and a net TVP of 2.19x for the 2016 vintage, according to PitchBook data. Every vintage since has shown a DPI of below 1x and TVPI below 2x.

At the lower end of the size range, funds between $100 million and $2 billion, the 2016 vintage showed slightly stronger performance, with a net DPI of 1.47x and net TVPI of 2.29x. This compares with a DPI of just 1.24x for US mega funds of the same vintage and TVPI of 1.93x.

Fundraising is a tougher task now

Some hope that the reset in investor expectations could ease fundraising pressure for smaller managers, since lower targets are, in theory, easier to hit.

“What it takes to be a top-quartile performer is relatively easier now than it was in that 2021 and pre-2021 era,” said Nicholas Pedersen, a partner at law firm Honigman.

At the same time, the lack of distributions over the past four years translates into less capital available to invest in new GPs.

LPs are playing it safe and concentrating commitments among established managers and larger, multi-strategy platforms with proven track records, according to Conrod.

GPs are spending longer on the road to close their next fund, as what used to take about a year is stretching to 24 months or more. Some managers have been in the market for three years and are still searching for capital. And for many, they may never be able to raise the next fund.

“That’s really just a flight to quality,” according to Smith. “When you go through any type of market dislocation, you will see this.”

Learn about our editorial standards.