Business People in the Office while Working. Blurred

Featured image: Fotograzia/Getty Images

Private Credit

More zombies, less info: Study warns about consequences of private credit growth

Private credit lenders may be incentivized to not recognize losses in troubled borrowers, making “zombie firms” more common, the article said.

The “meteoric rise” of private credit into a market potentially larger than the combined size of syndicated loan and bond markets has significant consequences for corporate governance, corporate valuations, and distress, among other issues, according to an academic paper.

The article, entitled “The Credit Markets Go Dark,” by Jared Ellias and Elisabeth de Fontenay, discussed the recent reversal of dispersed ownership in corporate debt toward private credit, a trend the authors describe as “de-democratization and consolidation.”

“The transition from bank-intermediated finance to private credit will transform not only corporate finance, but also firm behavior and economic activity more generally,” said the article, dated July 8.

The article warned that the information about many companies and whole industries will disappear from the public gaze.

“Consider a world in which consumers, the general public, and even regulators and policymakers know virtually nothing about the companies that sell the goods and services on which we rely. That world may be close at hand,” the article said.

In addition, ownership of companies will become concentrated at large and growing investment funds, which could potentially own both a company’s equity and debt.

“These funds will influence everything from firm operations and strategy to corporate distress, with uncertain consequences for social welfare,” the article said.

Previously, large sets of shareholders, who were mainly unsophisticated retail investors, owned companies directly, raising concern about weak shareholder power. Concern has now shifted to the potential for “excessive shareholder power” of both public and private companies where ownership is concentrated in the hands of investment funds.

Companies owned by private investment funds are lightly regulated, actively managed, and incentivized to take risk and seek big gains, all while fund managers have discretion in their hunt for returns. It’s not all bad — it could propel companies to operate efficiently and productively, the article noted.

“On the other hand, because most private investment funds are not overly concerned with how their returns are generated, such funds’ complete control of US companies may come at the expense of non-investor stakeholders or impose negative externalities at greater rates than other models of corporate ownership, such as family-owned private companies or public companies that are otherwise comparable in business and size,” the article said.

The article said that ownership of US companies by private investment funds has the potential to reshape the entire US economy “because such funds can only finance certain types of firms and on certain terms.”

For example, venture capital funds focus on tech investment and traditional buyout firms target mature companies with stable cash flows.

“These types of firms therefore raise capital with ease, while other firms and industries find capital to be scarce,” the article said.

More zombies?
In the past, information about private companies emerged via those companies’ borrowing in public or quasi-public markets.

“Now, however, with the rise of private credit, corporate debt is increasingly held in purely private hands, even for some very large firms. As a result, the entire chain of ownership and investment from the company to the ultimate investor is private, on both the equity and the debt side. The consequences of this are significant and potentially troubling: a very large segment of the US economy may go dark entirely,” the article said.

An obvious consequence is increasingly difficult corporate valuation, with greater potential for errors in assessment and trades “involving severe information asymmetry between buyer and seller.”

“In sum, all of the advantages of market efficiency in the public and quasi-public markets are lost in a world in which everything is private all the way down,” the article said.

Bankruptcy law will likely need to adapt to private credit, which will likely become a larger part of corporate financial distress, according to the article.

Private credit lenders may be incentivized to not recognize losses in troubled borrowers, making “zombie firms” more common, the article said.

“Private credit lenders may choose when and where to take losses in many situations. As a result, private credit lenders may choose to simply delay taking losses, to avoid informing limited partners or potential problems with their portfolio,” the article said. “A private lender can accomplish this by simply agreeing to extend the terms or repayment or by providing forbearances.”

Sicker companies, fewer options
Sophisticated private credit asset managers may be more eager to own assets or liquidate them in bankruptcy court, the article said.

The article used the recent example of the Chapter 11 filing of restaurant chain Red Lobster, with $250 million of term debt from private credit lender Fortress Investment Group dating from 2021. Fortress acquired shareholder voting power according to its rights under the term loan agreement, and was able to acquire full control of the borrower before the bankruptcy filing.

Traditional commercial lenders, or regulated banks, typically cannot own a company’s equity, and will take aggressive action when a company runs into trouble, the article noted.

A lack of claims trading in Chapter 11 cases involving private credit loans could slow down bankruptcy proceedings or compromise fair-sales processes. The article cited the example of JC Penney’s Chapter 11 case, in which the debtor proposed a reorganization and simultaneously sought to incentivize other potential buyers to come forward.

“In a world without claims trading, the expert distressed investors who would finance a reorganization or purchase a company’s assets may not already have a seat at the table. To the extent that the business would be worth more alive than dead, the investors who might seek to save it may need time and the opportunity to perform due diligence,” the article said.

Featured image: Fotograzia/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.