shutterstock-683371945.jpg
PB Q&A

Nova’s Chris Beall on how infrastructure investing hedges against inflation

Chris Beall, who has been investing in real assets for over two decades, is managing partner at Nova Infrastructure, a middle-market infrastructure investing firm. We spoke with Beall about how infrastructure assets have managed to weather the current environment.

Infrastructure’s reputation for offering low, dependable, inflation-resistant returns was put to the test in early 2021, when the Consumer Price Index (CPI)—a US inflation benchmark—leapt above 3% for the first time in a decade and kept rising.

Two years later, the asset class continues to be a safe haven even as high inflation has held up. As volatility and asset markdowns drag on venture capital and private equity fund performance, institutional investors are moving more capital into the strategy.

And recently, the typically low-risk strategy has also been delivering higher returns. For real assets, one year-horizon IRRs—a measure of fund performance—were on average 18.7% during the period ending in September 2022, making it by far the most lucrative private investing strategy, per our latest Global Fund Performance Report.

Chris Beall, who has been investing in real assets for over two decades, is managing partner at Nova Infrastructure, a middle-market infrastructure investing firm he co-founded with Allison Kingsley in 2017. PitchBook spoke with Beall about how infrastructure assets have managed to weather the current environment. This interview has been condensed and edited for clarity.

PitchBook: What makes infrastructure investing uniquely resistant to inflation?

Beall

Beall


Beall: Because infrastructure is very hard to replicate—in many cases, it is a monopoly or an oligopoly—if you decide not to use an infrastructure asset today, frequently there are people waiting in the wings to take up that capacity. And if I do so, and you come back in a year and say, “Okay, I’m ready to take it up,” well—that’s not an option because I put a contract in place for the rest of the capacity.

People want to do that because the cost to build a new bridge, road or railroad terminal is very high—prohibitively high in almost every case. The use of that asset is coveted. Therefore, you have these contracts in place. So it’s not the contracts that really provide the inflation hedge in many cases. It’s the scarcity value of the asset, and the challenging expense time needed to replicate that asset. Customers put contracts in place because they want the benefit of that asset—there’s no way they could go build their own railroad, port or airport. That scarcity value provides the downside protection.

Let’s say you did have the money and you wanted to go build a replacement airport. In an inflationary environment, it would get more expensive to build it because your labor, steel and land costs are inflating, and your financing cost is higher. That increasingly higher replacement cost means that you can charge more for the use of the asset that exists today. That’s another reason people want contracts: They don’t want to have to try to find an alternative or replacement in an environment where the cost is increasing. It’s that inherent characteristic of these assets and companies that really creates the leverage to provide a contract structure that is the inflation hedge.

How has the CPI component of contracts changed over the course of your career?

If you go back about 15 years, there were contracts that were simply linked to CPI inflation. As we got into periods where inflation was very low for a long period of time, people started to say, “I’m willing to accept [inflation-adjusted price increases], but I’d like to cap it or limit it somehow.” In some cases, you have contracts that say, “Inflation may go up at the greater of CPI [or a set percentage such as] 3% or 4%.” Or you had some revenue contracts that grow with inflation, but only up to a cap.

Those are the ones now that are particularly problematic, because if you have a contract that has a CPI inflator, but it’s subject to a cap of 3% or 4%, well, you’re not recovering 100% of the amount. If you have costs that are going up at the rate of inflation and revenue that’s going up to a cap of 3%, over the last seven to eight quarters, you would likely have margin compression. That’s the dynamic that you see a lot in the market.

I think infrastructure is inflation-protected, but it’s dynamically protected, not passively protected. A contract is only as good as its term. You have to really look asset by asset, contract by contract to know what level of protection you have. In many cases, because customer relationships are always dynamic, regulatory relationships are dynamic, and cost structures are dynamic, it’s got to be very actively managed. The more you’re looking into the future, saying, “What happens if interest rates go up? What happens if inflation goes up? What happens if volumes go down and inflation goes up?” All of those dynamic situations flow into how well the asset protects against inflation.

Why has the inflation protection in revenue contracts declined over the past decade?

It’s been a long time since we’ve had a really inflationary environment, and with asset owners’ desire to secure a customer under a long-duration contract, a little bit of risk was sacrificed and viewed as not important. Some people said, ''We haven’t had inflation above 4% in 15 years, so why would I worry about a 4% environment?” So I think a little bit of it is a lack of discipline.

In some cases, you had turnover in the ownership of the asset—it changed hands. The original builders were willing to take higher rates in the short term and sacrifice some of the inflation protection in the long term because they were thinking about sale price, not long-term risk. In contracts, there are always trade-offs. The customer may say, “I will take $5 today with CPI capped at 3%, or I’ll take $4 today, but I want uncapped CPI.” Those two lines cross somewhere in the future, but we don’t know when, and it’s a judgment call. I think sometimes people made short-term trade-offs and sacrificed some long-term downside protection for that.

In some cases, there are perceptions about competition. Maybe you think that, actually, someone is willing to build a new terminal. Therefore, you may have a perception that your oligopoly or monopoly is not as stable as you might otherwise think it is. So you make a rational business decision to accept a lower level of risk to lock a customer up, versus exposing them to competition where you might get a worse deal.

I generally think people are smart and they get to the right answer, but maybe, sometimes, people just didn’t think of it. Maybe they were in a new sector that they’d never worked in before and they just perceived a different level of risk, and they messed up. If you were in the middle part of your career in the 1970s, you’re probably 80 to 100 years old today. You’re not working. A lot of the people in this business are mid-40s and younger, so they probably haven’t had the experience with inflation that prior generations of investors had, and they’re just a little bit less concerned about it.

How do you manage inflation today in revenue and cost-side contracts?

Without pointing to a specific situation or portfolio, there are a few ways to manage it. One is looking for investments in sectors that have shorter-duration contracts, which allow you to reset price more frequently. That’s one of the reasons you see a lot of investors going into the telecommunication space, because it’s a very high demand area. People want access to fiber; they want access to cell towers. Growing demand with limited supply and shorter duration contracts is good for pricing dynamics, and it’s good for fighting against inflationary dynamics.

Having access to multiple customers and not being reliant on any one particular customer is helpful. Same with regulatory frameworks—diversification of customers and diversification of jurisdiction, I think, are helpful, versus having exposure to one national regulator. The US is particularly good for that because we have state-level regulation in many cases, not federal. Sometimes, it even goes down to local regulation at the city, county or port authority level.

It’s been a long time since we were in a high interest rate environment. You’re going to have a whole new generation of entrepreneurs and managers who are learning how this impacts businesses. Sometimes they’re learning lessons of what to do. Sometimes they’re learning lessons of what not to do. But I think having good, experienced people around the business as independent directors is very helpful for looking around corners.

Featured image by Roschetzky Photography/Shutterstock

Learn about our editorial standards.