Manhattan Borough President Mark Levine seen speaking to Holy Apostles volunteers

Erik McGregor/LightRocket via Getty Images

Capital Pool

NYC pensions’ $4B housing plan raises affordability questions

Comptroller Mark Levine’s new initiative will use pension fund money to invest in affordable housing, but there’s a risk the plan could have the opposite effect than intended.
Manhattan Borough President Mark Levine seen speaking to Holy Apostles volunteers

New York City Comptroller Mark Levine

Erik McGregor/Getty Images

Last week, New York City’s new comptroller, Mark Levine, announced a plan to invest $4 billion of the city’s pension dollars into building and preserving affordable housing.

The initiative aims to address one of the city’s biggest challenges. The unsheltered population in the five boroughs increased by 26% from the 2019 fiscal year to FY 2025, as housing costs have outpaced income growth, according to a New York State Comptroller report.

But the plan also raises questions about the impact that institutional investors can have on the affordable housing market, and the risk that their involvement might lead to the exact opposite of what is intended: higher rents.

Through what Levine has dubbed the “NYC Housing Investment Initiative,” the city will invest roughly $1 billion annually over the next four years in financing new mixed-income, workforce and affordable housing, maintaining existing affordable housing and converting office space into residential units.

Part of this means “using pension capital responsibly to generate risk-adjusted returns while addressing a critical city need,” the statement said. The move will more than double the investment exposure of New York City’s five public pension funds to affordable housing.

It should be noted that the question of whether institutions drive up the cost of affordable housing is hotly contested and highly context-specific.

In 2024, the US Government Accountability Office, for example, an independent agency known as the investigative arm of Congress, said the lack of data has made it difficult to spot the effects of institutional investments on rent.

For critics, a key issue is the mechanism for investing the money. Closed-end funds, managed by specialist real estate investment firms, are the easiest way to funnel pension money into affordable housing. In a 2024 New York Federal Reserve Bank survey of seven public pension plans, respondents reported allocating an average of 91% of their affordable housing commitments via closed-end vehicles.

But these structures are not ideal wrappers. They have a finite life, after which the fund manager is expected to sell the houses for a profit. The manager no longer controls whether the houses remain affordable. The new buyer can either maintain the existing affordability restrictions or shift rent to the regular market rate.

This is enabled by the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit, a federal law that provides tax credits to developers who agree to rent their properties to low-income tenants at reduced prices for 30 years. The loophole allows property owners to use a “qualified contract” to exit their investments at the 15-year mark, thereby no longer being obligated to keep the properties affordable.

Sign up for Capital Pool

Weekly commentary on what’s driving LP decision-making, with senior funds columnist Jessica Hamlin.

“The qualified contract formula price in nearly all cases significantly exceeds the market value of the property as affordable housing. As a result, it is rare for the allocating agency to find a buyer willing to pay the qualified contract price,” wrote the National Council of State Housing Agencies in a 2021 paper.

New York City’s pension funds already back certain real estate funds managed by Blackstone, a regular backer of affordable housing projects.

The investment firm bought 66 affordable rental properties in San Diego in 2021 and has since increased rent by 38%, as of 2024, according to an analysis from the Private Equity Stakeholder Project, an advocacy group for communities impacted by private equity, based on the Yardi Matrix Rent Survey.

Latest Research

Allocator Solutions: Does VC Improve Portfolio Outcomes or Complicate Them?

The Q1 2026 Allocator Solutions report evaluates whether venture capital improves portfolio outcomes by analyzing its returns, volatility, diversification benefits, and impact on portfolio efficiency.

At another Blackstone-backed property, the Mar at Cottonwood in San Ysidro, the PESP found that the investment manager raised rents by 79%, from an average of $1,429 in Q3 2021 to $2,558 in Q1 2024.

Jeffrey Kauth, a spokesperson for Blackstone’s real estate business, described its portfolio company April Housing as “the number-one owner and expected preserver” of LIHTC housing in the US.

For the San Diego properties, Kauth cited a 35% increase in resident satisfaction since the August 2021 acquisition and over $130 million invested to improve the housing.

In a 2025 brochure, Blackstone said the LIHTC buildings under its ownership had an average remaining term of 16 years. “We intend to keep them affordable for the long term, beyond when the programs expire,” the firm wrote.

It is unclear whether the New York pension funds are directly exposed to these affordable housing assets through their fund investments.

The comptroller’s office did not respond to PitchBook’s inquiry regarding how the funds would be invested and how it would seek to maintain affordability.

Recent News

Meet the 300+ investors who bet on Anthropic before everyone else

It takes a village—and a lot of startup capital—to build a company worth more than $1.7 trillion.

Anthropic’s historic IPO is the AI industry’s validation moment

Anthropic opened 34% above its IPO price in a blockbuster debut for AI frontier labs going public.

Learn about our editorial standards.