Toronto
Brady Baker/Getty Images
The Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan suffered the steepest private equity losses of any member of Canada’s Maple 8 to have reported annual results so far.
But all of Canada’s largest pension funds experienced losses or underperformance on the back of slow M&A and exit activity, longer holding periods and industrywide valuation corrections.
OTPP, with $279.4 billion in AUM, drew a 5.3% loss on its PE portfolio, significantly underperforming its 18% benchmark. In its annual report, the pension manager attributed the loss to challenges in the broader PE industry and valuation pressures across certain portfolio assets, which the fund addressed with markdowns. At the end of 2025, OTPP’s PE portfolio was valued at $50.8 billion, a nearly 10 percentage point drop from $60.4 billion in 2024.
“We responded with disciplined year-end valuation adjustments to reflect current market conditions, which weighed on performance,” president and CEO Jo Taylor said in a statement.
The same market dynamics impacted the returns of OTPP’s peers.
Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System recorded a 2.5% loss in its PE portfolio, which it chalked up to slow dealmaking and valuation declines.
And while Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec, the province’s $517.3 billion pension fund, didn’t report negative growth, its PE portfolio returned 2.3% for 2025, underperforming a 12.6% benchmark. The fund manager attributed the return to slow earnings growth for portfolio companies and lower multiples in the technology and healthcare sectors.
Like other Canadian and American pension funds that saw lagging PE returns over the past year, CDPQ pointed out that public equities are factored into its PE benchmark, which means that an outsized concentration and outperformance of the Magnificent 7 technology stocks during the period made PE returns look worse by comparison.
While the other members of Canada’s Maple 8 have yet to report full-year figures, fiscal-year and midyear returns are early indications that their PE portfolios have underperformed benchmarks.
British Columbia Investment Management Corporation, for example, cited public equities’ outperformance as the main reason its PE portfolio missed its benchmark by more than 50% for the one-year period ending March 31, 2025.
Poor PE performance dragged down overall returns for all of the Canadian pension plans that have reported 2025 returns so far. OTPP trailed its 11.7% benchmark by five percentage points, the widest gap of the four members of the Maple 8 that have reported.
Learn about our editorial standards.