loan meeting.jpg
Private Credit

Pension fund EBMUD scraps $140M private credit allocation citing lower returns, “hassle” of asset class

The board made the decision to cancel its target allocation of 5% of total portfolio assets on its March 19 meeting, according to market sources.

California’s East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD) Employees’ Retirement System canceled its planned $140 million allocation to private credit in light of lower expected returns for the asset class and concerns about headline risk.

The board decided to cancel its target allocation of 5% of total portfolio assets at its March 19 meeting, according to market sources. The allocation, which was created in May 2024, will remain invested in covered calls.

The board voted to cancel the search after Colin Bebee, managing principal at Meketa Investment Group who was advising EBMUD on the search, noted that the firm had reduced its private credit return expectations by around 90 basis points for this year and said that the pension’s existing 5% allocation to covered calls would likely provide similar returns with similar volatility.

“Basically, is the marginal benefit (of private credit) worth a meaningful headline risk and, for lack of a better phrase, hassle of being in that space?” Bebee said.

He ultimately suggested that remaining allocated to covered calls rather than private credit would mitigate headline risk, saying that the returns are similar and moving into private credit “would be a ton of work for no discernible difference in what you’d actually be seeing at the end of the day.”

Sources noted that EBMUD has no dedicated investment staff. The retirement plan has also never been a prominent user of private markets, as its only existing private markets allocation is 2.5% to private core real estate.

Sources also said the decision was not simply a comparison of private credit versus covered calls, but more broadly considered the portfolio’s expected return and volatility under different allocation options.

Oakland, Calif.-based EBMUD is a major Bay Area employer that manages drinking water and energy investments. Its retirement system’s investment portfolio had a market value of nearly $3 billion as of Sept. 30, 2025.

Learn about our editorial standards.