The contrail of a high speed airplane

Featured image: Alexandrumagurean/Getty Images

Credit

PIK interest income surpasses $1B for top 15 BDCs in Q1 2025

Once the domain of distressed borrowers, PIK loans are now a favored lifeline for healthy companies. Will today’s cash flow cushion become tomorrow’s repayment crisis?

Want to see more? Fill out the form below.

I agree to PitchBook’s privacy policy

Paid-in-kind (PIK) interest income for the top 15 exchange-traded BDCs increased by 20% in the year to March 31, 2025, to $1 billion, as borrowers, squeezed by stubbornly high interest rates and inflation, increasingly opt to conserve cash by paying interest with more debt. Once the domain of distressed borrowers, PIK loans are now a favored lifeline for healthy companies navigating the punishing reality of high interest rates, raising questions about whether today’s cash flow cushion could become tomorrow’s repayment crisis. With that in mind, LCD examined the PIK loan profile of the 15 largest exchange-traded BDCs, based on their Q1 2025 portfolios.

Key findings:

  • Top 15 exchange-traded BDCs’ PIK interest income surged 20% year-over-year to $1 billion as of March 31, accounting for 8.7% of total interest income as of Q1 2025.
  • PIK loans, once tied to distressed markets, are now common with healthy borrowers, especially in first-lien debt (88% of PIK holdings).
  • Within the 15-BDC sample, FS KKR, Ares Capital and Blue Owl generated the most PIK income; Blue Owl had the lowest PIK proportion (7%), and Prospect Capital had the highest (34%).
  • First-lien/unitranche loans had the lowest PIK share (42% of interest), while junior debt had the highest (up to 95%).
  • Software, Healthcare and Commercial & Professional Services were the leading sectors in PIK loan count.
  • The average PIK holdings size is roughly $20 million; nearly half are under $5 million, only 4% are more than $100 million.
  • Risks: PIK accrual inflates principal over time, raising repayment risk if borrower value creation lags.
  • Opportunities: Lenders gain higher returns, but face potential equity-like risk if valuations drop and leverage rises.

As stated, PIK interest income for the top 15 exchange-traded BDCs increased 20% to $1 billion for the 12 months to March 31. Total interest income for these BDCs, the largest of the sample that LCD tracks, increased 12% in the same period to $11.8 billion — slower than the pace of PIK growth. As a result, PIK’s share of total interest income swelled to 8.7% at the end of Q1 2025, from 8.1% a year earlier, but remains below the 9.0% level recorded on March 31, 2023.

From niche to norm?
Persistently high interest rates — driven in part by sustained inflation — have fueled the growth of PIK loans, which were once largely confined to the distressed market. These days, however, loans with PIK features are prevalent, with healthy, performing borrowers considering debt financing with PIK features to help conserve and manage cash flow while executing upon a growth strategy, and eventually generating more value. This is evidenced by the approximately 88% of the PIK instruments for these 15 BDCs that are first-lien debt.

The growing popularity of PIK loan products has helped push BDC lender returns into the double-digits, driven by relatively higher-quality borrowers — unlike the distressed credit restructurings where PIK interest was traditionally employed. Some BDCs, such as Golub Capital, have also incorporated PIK features into one-stop shop unitranche products that have differing priority tranches within a first-lien facility.

With the ongoing US tariff policy exacerbating the effects of inflation and high interest rates, uncertainty is still rampant, and borrowers who have a loan with PIK features have access to a cash flow cushion to use as they weather the storm, while still trying to grow their business. While the borrowers benefit from lower cash interest payments, the PIK’d interest eventually does need to be repaid as it is added to the principal balance, increasing the overall interest burden.

To the extent that a borrower’s growth strategy does not translate into the hoped-for value creation (which often comes hand-in-hand with poor financial performance), going the PIK route can result in a significant increase in the borrower’s loan-to-value ratio. This could mean a sponsor’s equity investment is underwater. The sponsor may need to inject equity capital in order to save their investment. At the same time, lenders could be facing repayment risk and depressed recovery expectations, as enterprise valuations could deteriorate while loan balances continue to grow, with the compounding effect of interest on accrued interest.

PIK interest surges for most top BDCs
With that in mind, LCD examined the PIK loan profile of the 15 largest exchange-traded BDCs, based on their Q1 2025 portfolios. In total, these vehicles held nearly 900 debt instruments with a PIK interest component, representing $17.4 billion in debt outstanding (by amortized cost) issued to 408 unique borrowers.

Two-thirds of the largest 15 BDCs experienced double-digit increases in PIK interest income for the LTM Q1 2025 period, and all of them reported an increase, except for Prospect Capital, which decreased 13%. The top three BDCs with the highest PIK interest income generation were FS KKR Capital Corp., Ares Capital Corp. and Blue Owl Credit Income Corp., with $238 million, $208 million and $121 million, respectively, as of LTM Q1 2025, with respective two-year growth rates of 47%, 40% and 170%.

PIK chart 1A.png

To put the PIK loan cohort into perspective, the $17.4 billion of debt instruments represents 14% of the $124 billion in total investments held by the 15 largest BDCs. Ares Capital, FS KKR and Blackstone Secured Lending Fund rank as the top three in terms of largest PIK loan holdings, with $3.6 billion (13% of total investments), $2.7 billion (19%) and $2.6 billion (20%), respectively. Of note, even though Prospect Capital’s total investment holdings totaled just $6.9 billion, its share of PIK loans amounted to the highest proportionate share at 34%. In contrast, Blue Owl’s PIK loan holdings of 7% represented the lowest PIK loan proportion of its $29.5 billion of total investments.

PIK share lowest in first-lien loans, highest in junior debt
As of Q1 2025, first-lien and unitranche loans with a PIK component carried an average total interest rate of 11%, of which 4.6% was paid in-kind — equating to 42% of total interest, the lowest PIK share among debt classes. By contrast, junior debt instruments such as second-lien facilities, unsecured loans and subordinated loans not only bore higher total interest rates but also a much larger PIK component, representing 78%, 95%, and 86% of total interest, respectively.

Most of the junior-level debt was fixed-rate loans, although there were also first-lien loans at fixed rates. For fixed-rate loans, the average PIK interest rate was 10.2% and the average total interest rate was 12%. For Sofr-based loans, the average PIK interest rate was 4.5% and the average total interest rate was 11.3%.

PIK chart 2A.png

About 85% of the 876 instruments featuring PIK interest were first-lien debt or unitranche facilities, with second-lien and subordinated debt making up about 5% and 7%, respectively. Note on methodology for certain PIK debt instruments, for which a total PIK interest rate and total interest rate were not reported, and if the debt was variable-rate based, we estimated it using the respective reference rate as of March 31, 2025, to calculate the total PIK interest rate and total interest rate.

Breaking down the overall average PIK interest rates, we note that the distribution (by count) skews to the lower end, with 61% carrying a total PIK interest rate of less than 5%. This likely reflects debt priority, as most of these loans are first-lien, benefiting from stronger credit quality compared to higher PIK rate loans, which are primarily junior debt — though some first-liens do indeed carry high PIK interest rates.

PIK chart 4A.png

PIK-intensive sectors
By industry, Software, Healthcare, and Commercial & Professional Services borrowers accounted for the largest number of loans with a PIK component, reflecting their prominent role in the direct lending market. The share of PIK within total interest, however, varied significantly by sector.

In Software, loans with a PIK feature derived 43% of total interest from PIK (4.55% of a 10.6% yield), with Commercial & Professional Services close behind at 42%. Healthcare Equipment & Services was more PIK-heavy, with 53% of interest coming from PIK. In contrast, Capital Goods — representing a smaller slice of the market with 79 BDC holdings featuring PIK — showed a higher reliance on cash interest, with PIK making up just 27% of total interest for loans with a PIK component.

Other sectors with above-average reliance on PIK — though representing a smaller share of the direct lending market — include Media & Entertainment, Consumer Discretionary, Distribution & Retail and Pharma, Biotech & Life Sciences. Each of these industries has roughly 30 instruments with a PIK component, with PIK accounting for 62% to 80% of total interest.

PIK chart 3A.png

On a loan outstanding basis (by amortized cost), Software, Healthcare and Commercial & Professional Services have the three largest concentrations, with $3.7 billion, $2.8 billion and $1.9 billion, respectively. The average loan size was about $18-21 million for the top three and roughly $20 million overall. Equity REITs had the largest average loan size of $237 million (consisting of four loans) associated with National Property REIT Corp., with a total exposure of nearly $950 million held by Prospect Capital.

Few large PIK positions
While PIK is increasingly common in BDC portfolios, large-scale positions remain rare. Across the 876 PIK debt instruments held by the 15 largest BDCs, the average loan size was roughly $20 million. Breaking this down, nearly half (47% by count) were under $5 million, while roughly one-fifth exceeded $25 million. At the top end, 4% — or 36 investments — were more than $100 million. However, it’s worth noting that BDCs only tell part of the story. Usually, an asset manager’s BDC only holds part of the total facility, as it is held across various funds and other entities.

PIK chart 5B.png

About 88% ($15.3 billion) of the $17.4 billion in PIK loans were represented by first-lien debt, with subordinated debt trailing far behind as the second-highest class at 7% and second-lien debt at 3%. Out of total first-lien debt aggregate holdings of $97.3 billion, the share of PIK first-lien debt was 16% as of Q1 2025.

PIK chart 6A.png

Risks and opportunities
Loans with PIK features have attracted borrowers across industries. In the long term, the accrual of interest into the principal balance means paying interest on interest and ultimately, the ballooning of the outstanding balance. This could become a large burden as the loan-to-value ratio rises, possibly to the extent that value of the business does not rise at the same pace. PIK loans also provide benefits to PE sponsors in that they can be used as a tool to manage capital requirements and optimize returns on investments. While in some cases PIK loans allow sponsors to assist borrower companies and delay a need to inject equity capital into portfolio companies, eventually, they may need to do so anyway if their value proposition fails to reach its target metrics, and they need to save their investment.

For lenders, PIK loans can be lucrative, with higher interest charges and higher returns. However, credit risk could rise steeply, and there could be elements of taking on equity risk to the extent that loan outstandings exceed a borrower’s respective debt capacity. This is especially true if the value of the business hits roadblocks and the borrower enters distress, with the loan-to-value ratio rising to inadequate levels.

While the use of PIK loans is rising significantly, we will also consider the performance of these loans over time, especially as borrowers navigate through uncertainty into the second half of 2025. Time will tell whether lenders can maintain high returns or face heightened credit risk with potential for losses.

Featured image: Alexandrumagurean/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.