Fjord view from the Kjerac

Victor Cardoner/Getty Images

Private Credit

Price dispersion returning to private credit as spreads widen – New Mountain

New Mountain said that it opportunistically purchased several loans on the secondary market at discounts during the quarter.

Direct lending deal prices have begun to differentiate between asset quality with more precision, particularly in the software sector, according to New Mountain Finance Corporation.

Spread dispersion increased in Q1 amid the backdrop of heightened volatility, particularly compared to last year’s highly competitive environment, when “we saw really no dispersion,” said COO Laura Holson on the company’s Q1 earnings call.

“Everything was pricing in that Sofr+450 bps-475 bps band,” and lenders were not compensated for extra incremental risks on deals, said Holson.

Spreads on regular-way direct lending deals have since widened by about 25-50 bps, the company said. In software, dispersion has been especially pronounced, as spreads in new software loans can be anywhere from 550 bps to 1000 bps, according to NMFC CEO John R. Kline.

“That [software deal pricing] dispersion is driven by real and perceived views on the quality of the business model within the software ecosystem … Lenders will have the opportunity to take differentiated views in software and potentially get rewarded for making the good credit picks,” said Kline.

The company’s yield-to-maturity on Q1 originations was 15.5%, compared to 11.8% in Q4, an increase partially supported by spreads on loans purchased in the secondary market at discounts during the quarter, according to the company.

The company disclosed some of these discounted secondary purchases, including a $13.5 million investment in HR software company Alight’s first-lien debt, completed at a weighted average purchase price of 66.4 cents on the dollar. In January 2025, Alight placed a $2.03 billion, S+175 term loan at par via a syndicated loan transaction led by BofA Securities.

The company also invested $6 million in packaging company Resource Label Group’s first-lien debt at a weighted average purchase price of 46.1 cents. The loan is priced at S+425.

Resource Label Group was downgraded to Caa2 from Caa1 by Moody’s earlier this year, which revised its outlook to negative, from stable. The agency cited the company’s distressed credit metrics.

The company had net repayments of nearly $375 million in the quarter, as about $117 million of new originations was offset by $47 million in repayments and $445 million in sales, including the BDC’s $477 million secondary loan sale to Coller Capital, which transacted at a price of about 94 cents on the dollar.

M&A activity was seasonally slower in Q1 but has begun to pick up in recent weeks, the company said. Holson said she is not seeing any signs of systemic credit stress across the asset class.

Non-accruals increased to 2.6% at fair value and 5.6% at cost in Q1, compared to 1.4% and 3.2%, respectively, in Q4. The increase was driven by the addition of Affordable Care’s first-lien loan to non-accrual, as the company is undergoing a restructuring. Affordable Care’s first-lien debt was marked at about 66 cents in Q1, compared to 80 cents in Q4.

The company said that it expects Affordable Care to come off non-accrual in the coming quarters as the lending group effectuates a change in control and the company takes on a new capital structure which includes a smaller cash-pay first-lien loan and a large equity account controlled by the former lenders.

Healthcare services company Convey Health Solutions was also added to non-accrual in the quarter, as New Mountain said the business faced operational challenges. The company marked its first-lien loans in the company at about 65 cents in Q1, down from 73 cents in Q4. New Mountain said it has recruited a new leader for the business with the lender group.

Additionally, New Mountain said that it has seen forward momentum on restructured names including Benevis, UniTek Global Services, and Permian, which it plans to sell at above current valuations.

For our recently released “Peek under the Hood” report and more BDC analysis, see the PitchBook website under Private Credit: PitchBook Credit Research.

Sign up for The Credit Pitch

Weekly coverage of US and European loans, bonds, private credit, and more.

Victor Cardoner/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.