buildingripple-xhc-vgg-rzo.jpg
Leveraged Loans

Private credit borrowers turn to structured capital, PIK with debt costs on the rise

Stress is rising in the private credit market as debt issuers grapple with higher interest costs, just as earnings may be slowing. Many of these loans were done using EBITDA “add-backs.”

As the market turns, structured capital is in vogue.

Stress is increasing on borrower companies as they grapple with higher interest and input costs just as earnings may be slowing. In many cases, loans were underwritten when credit market conditions were more borrower-friendly, using complex EBITDA definitions such as “add-backs,” which may not have materialized.

At the same time, lenders are increasingly holding a line at the prospect of adding debt to a company’s balance sheet. They may be open for credit amendments or waivers, but these are short-term fixes.

Enter preferred equity and holdco PIK notes to the rescue.

“Certain companies right now are bringing in a layer of capital that sits between debt and equity,” said Christine Tiseo, co-head of Lincoln International’s Debt Advisory Group.

“These are still good companies. They are typically cash flow positive. They are not candidates for bankruptcy nor are they distressed. But company performance may not be what it used to be under the current macro backdrop. With interest rates continuing to rise, it is pressuring cash flows and [the] ability to service debt or clear covenants,” Tiseo said.

Key to these investments is that they are structured without cash interest payments, as mezzanine debt may require. Similar to what occurred with revenue shortfalls during the Covid-19 pandemic, borrower companies need to find creative ways to conserve cash.

Indeed, lenders are increasingly focused on fixed-charge analyses of their portfolios. They are increasingly examining the metric based on expectations for the coming 12 months of earnings and interest expense, rather than the traditional lagging 12 months, Tiseo noted.

“Companies are starting to trickle in saying they have balance sheet problems they are trying to solve. Without a solution, they will be in default on a loan agreement. And existing lenders are fatigued in some cases,” Tiseo said.

Asset managers and private equity firms have been preparing for this moment. A parade of funds for just these purposes are lining up, marketing themselves as “special opportunities,” “tactical value,” and “credit solutions” funds. They are targeting mid-teens yields on investments.

“These are firms that are saying ‘we’re not here to own your company — we’re softer, gentler capital’,” Tiseo said. “Lenders usually like it because it means yet another deep-pocketed institutional investor in the mix.”

Looking for cash
Signs of stress in credit are increasing. For example, Proskauer’s Private Credit Default Index showed defaults of private credit senior secured and unitranche loans reached 2.06% in the fourth quarter of 2022, the second consecutive quarter the default rate has increased. The Index peaked at 8.1% in Q2 2020.

The default rate of the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index increased to 0.83% by dollar amount in January, from 0.72% in December, following bankruptcy filings by Serta Simmons Bedding and Heritage Power.

Some private equity sponsors have added debt to transactions via “silent” second-lien loans to cope with current challenges, market participants say. Some borrowers have negotiated to PIK a portion of existing loans. Clothing rental service Rent the Runway Inc. amended a term loan agreement last month, doubling the PIK component of its loan. Fitness franchisor F45 Training Holdings Inc. received a new $90 million subordinated debt facility structured with 12% PIK with an OID of 3%, also PIK, according to a public filing.

“The next six months are going to be tricky to navigate for all parties involved,” said Bill Brady, head of the alternative lender and private debt group and member of the special situations group at Paul Hastings.

“We’ve seen some private equity firms put in equity to avoid springing revolver covenant breaches, just before quarter end, and in some cases only to take it out shortly thereafter,” Brady said.

In one potential measure of what’s around the corner, business in front of Brady at the moment roughly comprises 70% restructurings and 30% new issuance based on hundreds of deals in his portfolio. A year ago, new loans accounted for about 90% of his workload, he said.

A well-flagged problem with the recent vintage of loans will likely be EBITDA add-backs that were allowed when credit market conditions were frothy. Certain transactions that were calculated at 6.5x leverage may be closer to 10x, in actuality, taking into account EBITDA add-backs, Brady said.

“For some borrowers, a liquidity crisis is coming or has already arrived. The question is ‘who’s going to put in the cash and where in the capital structure?’” Brady asked.

Subtle signs of stress
Private credit providers honed portfolio management skills through the chaos wrought by the Covid-19 pandemic outbreak, as well as other periods of volatility of the past decade. With default rates rising, many say portfolio management is the top priority for 2023. Investors are watching for increased revolver draws, growth of non-accruals, changes to internal ratings systems, credit amendments, changes in fair value marks in BDC portfolios and mounting near-term maturities.

But many signs of loan portfolio stress this time around are subtle.

Wells Fargo recently highlighted instances of increased pay in-kind components of interest on BDC loans. The firm also noted “a concerning trend in recent quarters, where companies with near-term maturities take deeper and deeper marks, only to move to non-accrual just before the loan’s slated maturity.”

“This is an industry-wide phenomenon, where negative credit developments are largely shrugged off until assets near their due date,” said Wells Fargo analyst Finian O’Shea in a Feb. 9 research note.

Learn about our editorial standards.