Texture split wall stones bricks

Aleksandr Bondar/Getty Images/iStockphoto

Private Credit

Private credit continuation vehicle pricing suggests secondaries bifurcation

Some continuation vehicles have managed to transact at headline premiums to par, but other processes are being pulled entirely after weak reception.

Pricing details have emerged on several private credit continuation vehicles that closed in the past year, showing that at least five of these secondaries transactions have priced at a nominal premium to par, according to market sources.

While pricing in credit secondaries is complex, as buyers typically receive effective discounts through indirect mechanisms that allow GPs to maintain headline pricing figures at or above par, the results suggest that continuation vehicles for top portfolios and GPs continue to receive a strong reception despite the multi-year lows seen in primary private credit market activity.

The most recent deal to price at a nominal premium to par was Audax’s $1 billion continuation vehicle earlier this year, led and structured by Pantheon.

Around the same time, there was the $2.5 billion Arcmont private credit continuation vehicle, which also transacted at a nominal premium to par, according to market sources. Ares Credit Secondaries funds led the European deal.

Sources indicated that Ares has reached out to other investors to syndicate some of its investment in the Arcmont continuation vehicle. The deal was oversubscribed.

Another example is TPG Twin Brook’s $3 billion continuation vehicle, led by secondaries investor Coller Capital, which also got done at a nominal premium to par.

The optics of apparent par (or above par) pricing on these deals are favorable for the primary market private credit firms pursuing them, as it makes the deals more palatable for their LPs. That is far from the full story, however.

Secondaries investors buying into these continuation funds accept this headline pricing because they can secure lower effective pricing through structures and arrangements that give secondaries buyers discounts through other financial mechanisms — such as delayed settlement and portfolio discounts to NAV. These serve to effectively boost returns and lower pricing.

The result is a compromise that works for both parties — GPs feel better about telling LPs that their continuation vehicle transacted above par, while buyers get the return they are looking for. And this recipe appears to be largely working for top senior direct lending funds.

However, the broader secondaries market has not been immune to the volatility of the primary market.

PitchBook LCD has also heard of several continuation vehicle processes that have been pulled by private credit GPs this year after pricing came in softer than expected.

The emerging dynamic is similar to the one seen in the primary market, where top assets are managing to clear at attractive pricing, while others are much harder to get done than they were this time last year.

Sign up for The Credit Pitch

Weekly coverage of US and European loans, bonds, private credit, and more.

“Continuation vehicles are becoming more prevalent, but we’re seeing significant dispersion in deal quality,” said Rakesh Jain, global head of private credit at Pantheon, in a statement to PitchBook LCD. He declined to comment on pricing.

“Attractive pricing and the most complex, differentiated deals still go to platforms with the deepest GP relationships and the underwriting capability to move efficiently on sophisticated structures — that’s increasingly where the real value is being created for investors,” Jain said.

Ares and Coller declined to comment.

Aleksandr Bondar/Getty Images/iStockphoto

Learn about our editorial standards.