For the private credit market, August this year is not just about lobster rolls. It’s also about interest coverage ratios.
Interest coverage ratios are in focus because higher base rates on the floating-rate component of private credit loans are taking a toll on borrower companies. As interest rates have risen, fixed-charge coverage ratios, such as interest payments on debt, have declined, in the aggregate, to levels that some market watchers say are dangerously low.
This credit metric will be one to watch as business development companies (BDCs) begin reporting earnings for the quarter ended June 30. Many of them are scheduled for late July and the first half of August.
Some BDCs had begun to discuss the metric in recent quarters. Some of the companies are expected to point out what share of their total loan portfolio has declined below 1.0x, a key level for this ratio that may signal borrower stress.
In a report last month, Lincoln International called declines in fixed-charge coverage ratios (FCCRs) by private companies “notable and worrying,” as levered companies struggle to pay rising interest.
That analysis used a forward-looking approach to evaluate interest coverage which painted a dark picture of debt burdens. Many borrowers have seen interest expenses double since early 2022.
Using a backward-looking 12 months of interest expense, the average fixed-charge coverage ratio dropped from 1.40x in the first quarter of 2022 to 1.26x in the first quarter of 2023.
But when the higher interest costs are spun forward, calculated via a forward projection of base rates above 5% for 12 full months, the ratio for the first quarter of 2023 dropped to 1.04x, the Lincoln report said.
Companies are essentially “living paycheck to paycheck,” the Lincoln report said. “Essentially, the market is living on the edge of a payment default cycle.”
But although it’s an interesting talking point, some market observers point out that it is not a useful metric for private credit. Lenders will use all available tools, including cutting interest costs through PIK interest, to help a borrower company facing challenges. Such measures could boost interest coverage ratios.
“It’s a statistic that can be manipulated if needed, and the borrower will bank a nice fee. No lender is going to be the reason a borrower goes under. A borrower will only go under if there is a real fundamental problem with its business. If it’s a real, solid business, every lender we know would manufacture a solution to help that company through the cycle,” one credit analyst said.
Plumbing the depths
Nevertheless, last quarter, interest coverage was brought up often in BDC earnings calls.
Ares Capital said in a shareholder call on April 25 that its interest coverage in the quarter ended March 31 was roughly 1.7x. Ares Capital CEO Kipp deVeer pointed out that interest coverage was “good.”
On a May 11 shareholder call, Owl Rock Capital Corp. (NYSE: ORCC) CEO Craig Packer said he expects interest coverage to decline to around 1.5x toward the second half of this year. As of March 31, current median interest coverage for Owl Rock Capital’s portfolio was 2.2x.
Outside of BDCs, everyone’s talking about interest coverage. That goes for not only private credit, but also for leveraged loans.
Global asset management firm PineBridge Investments said last month that private credit investors should look hard at the health of loan portfolios. It considers interest coverage ratio at or above 2x and a minimum 1.25x fixed-charge ratio “as healthy and providing the flexibility needed to weather a downturn.”
John Czapla, head of the private portfolio group and chairman of the board at VRC, an independent valuation firm, said last month that interest coverage was declining to 1.5x-1.6x on deals originated before the interest rate run-up in 2Q22.
“Everyone’s very aware that if base rates continue to rise and EBITDA drops down, in two quarters, some of those will be 1x coverage, and that’s something they’ll need to figure out,” said Czapla.
Learn about our editorial standards.