Those steeped in the world of direct lending to sponsor-backed borrowers might find the term “investment-grade private credit” something of an oxymoron, like jumbo shrimp or old news.
After all, public debt capital markets traditionally have provided debt to high-grade borrowers. Private credit providers have focused on middle market borrowers, which couldn’t access other sources of financing or a rating.
But as zealous fundraising drives private credit’s growth, the areas that the asset class is targeting are likewise expanding. These now can include rated borrowers, including companies with investment-grade ratings.
This has opened a new path on direct lenders’ quest to lend to everything: investment-grade private credit.
The opportunity, depending on what types of financing are being included under the private credit umbrella, has the potential to be massive.
In a recent white paper, Apollo estimated the total addressable market, including asset-backed financing and commercial real estate, may be up to $40 trillion, with most of that investment-grade.
The firm’s list of targets, however, goes well beyond the traditional middle market sponsor lending that private credit is known for, a market that has grown to roughly $1.7 trillion of assets under management, according to a report by the Federal Reserve. Apollo is also including areas such as music royalties, auto loans, residential mortgages, franchise finance and infrastructure debt in its calculation.
Rah rah ratings!
Private credit borrowers have famously said that not having to go through the process of obtaining a rating is one of the perks of borrowing from direct lenders. It can be time-consuming to obtain ratings, with the process potentially slowing down competitive M&A transactions.
But some potential investors point to private credit’s opacity and lack of ratings as a weakness of the asset class. As investors grow more interested in private investment grade, there’s growing demand to make direct lenders’ investments more transparent.
Not everyone sees investment-grade private credit achieving this goal. The term “investment-grade private credit” is viewed by some as simply marketing language, designed to entice investors to the alternative asset class. Indeed, the definition can be different, depending on who you talk to.
Insurers move in
Insurers have become more involved in private credit in recent years, driving demand for higher-quality assets.
In September 2023, Blackstone (NYSE: BX) unveiled the creation of Blackstone Credit and Insurance (BXCI), as it aims to build another trillion-dollar business over the next 10 years by combining the firm’s corporate credit, asset-based finance and insurance groups into a single unit. Apollo Global Management, Brookfield and KKR & Co. have pursued majority stake purchases or full acquisitions of insurance companies, what Moody’s has called a “balance-sheet heavy approach.”
According to market participants, investment-grade private credit could touch any corner of asset-based finance and asset-based lending, including corporate loans, equipment finance, fund finance, inventory finance, aviation, consumer loans, infrastructure, and more.
Recent analysis of the insurance industry by Moody’s explains that, while insurers’ definition of investment-grade private credit varies, a focus is placed on commercial mortgage loans, infrastructure lending, private corporate placements, and asset-based finance.
“These assets are typically of investment grade, and are most attractive to insurers,” says Moody’s.
Some of the assets have a credit rating of BBB- or better. Others include higher-quality non-rated loans, with an “equivalent” rating based on an internal system by a debt provider.
If lenders rate the credit internally, this can limit which limited partners can invest in the asset, since some, like insurance companies, require formal ratings.
“It’s just a different way to finance assets which are typically financed in the public markets,” said co-head of KKR’s US asset-based finance business, Chris Mellia.
Less risk, more reward
The wide-ranging collateral, such as consumer assets and equipment, may help investors feel comfortable with the asset class, said insurers surveyed in the Moody’s report.
“Investment-grade private credit structures are robust. There’s huge demand to lean into an asset class which hasn’t seen many defaults or downgrades historically,” said KKR’s Mellia.
Another draw is the yield potential. Spread compression in the private credit market generally has sent credit investors searching for places to pick up yield. The trend is the same in other areas of credit.
“Companies that have cash in traditional corporate investment-grade can rotate into investment-grade private credit and earn excess spread,” said Rob Horn, Blackstone’s global head of infrastructure and asset-based credit.
Average spreads on investment-grade private credit can be 200 to 275 basis points over corporate investment grade credit, such as bonds. The gains can be much more due to the illiquid nature of the asset, or the complexity of the financing, according to market sources.
“Because public credit markets have opened back up in recent months, spreads have tightened, so anywhere you can pick up incrementally more spread matters,” said Mellia.
Wide open spaces
Of course, the private credit market is extremely competitive at the moment: Direct lenders are more numerous than ever, spreads are tight, and buyout activity is relatively low.
Some private credit lenders say that investment-grade private credit is an oasis in the dearth of investment options. Perhaps most appealing is that deal flow is uncorrelated with private equity activity.
“The private investment grade market is massive. We estimate the potential size at around $25 trillion. It is a target-rich environment where you might not see much competition on the largest transactions,” said Blackstone’s Horn.
There is a wide variety of investments available to those with the capacity to execute them. Some types of financing are very labor-intensive and require specialization from asset managers.
Traditionally, much of the financing was done by banks. The opportunity set for direct lenders only widened as banks stepped back as the recent spate of rate hikes, and specter of recession, overtook the market. Private credit managers say they are more efficient providers since they are not burdened by regulations that govern banks.
“I think that a lot of these areas, like equipment leasing or receivables financing, are areas where the regional banks are trying to trim exposure. These financings require hands-on asset-level expertise and labor that banks either might not be focused on, or simply no longer want to invest in,” said Mitch Soiefer, head of lender finance at SLR Capital Partners, a New York-based commercial finance platform that advises on over $12 billion in assets.
Featured image: PM Images/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.