While private equity firms aren’t required to disclose their environmental, social, and governance practices, they have increased their transparency voluntarily over the last two decades, and it has led to better returns for investors.
Over the last two decades, private equity firms have increased their ESG disclosure, regardless of the firms’ investment strategy, listing status, size, location or industry focus, according to a London Business School research paper by Jefferson Abraham, Marcel Olbert and Florin Vasvari. The paper, which used a count of ESG-related words on private equity firms’ websites to gauge disclosure rates, found that from 2000 to 2020, the usage of these words on PE firms’ websites grew 200%.
The authors found that this increase in ESG disclosure was associated with a 4.9% increase in the net IRR of a fund.
The increased disclosure is a spillover effect of increased mandatory disclosure among public firms onto unregulated private equity firms. In other words, the industry has started to voluntarily self-disclose ESG information to keep up with public competitors, the paper said.
Using data on global ESG disclosure mandates, the authors found that private equity firms with portfolio companies based in countries with mandatory ESG disclosures for public companies were associated with increased ESG disclosure. For instance, a 10-percentage-point uptick in a firm’s investments in portfolio companies in countries with mandatory reporting was associated with a 2.3% increase in PE firms’ environmental disclosures.
The authors speculated the connection between geographical reporting requirements and increased voluntary disclosure among private equity firms was a result of private equity firms responding to this increased awareness and attempting to remain competitive with publicly listed firms that are required to be ESG compliant.
Sophie Durham, managing director and head of ESG at Igneo Infrastructure Partners, said her firm has seen increased investor, regulator and stakeholder demand for transparency and reporting on ESG in recent years.
“It can be challenging to keep up with the evolving regulations and the many voluntary reporting frameworks out there on ESG, but we hope to start to see more convergence, particularly in Europe,” Durham told PitchBook in an email.
Paul Yett, director of ESG and sustainability at Hamilton Lane, said his firm has also observed an increase in investor inquiries about ESG practices.
“Twelve years ago, the responses to those [ESG] questionnaires were pretty light,” Yett said. “Fast forward to today, ESG is everywhere.”
Another factor contributing to increased ESG disclosures is the growing network of PE firms and other investors that have committed to the United Nations’ Principles for Responsible Investment, which seek to incorporate ESG and responsible investing principles into investment and ownership decisions. PE firms that committed to the UN PRI standards increased their ESG disclosures by around 30%, according to the paper.
“This suggests that PE firms’ management of ESG risks and the pursuit of ESG opportunities have potentially become increasingly relevant to their value creation, potentially by reducing investment risks, identifying new sources of growth for portfolio companies and increasing the resilience to long-term changes in the political and regulatory environment,” the paper’s authors wrote.
Increased voluntary disclosure is also a way for PE firms to prepare themselves for a shifting regulatory environment. While private market ESG disclosures are voluntary today, Yett said he expects increased regulation to eventually make these disclosures mandatory.
Additionally, Yett said he expects to see more ESG disclosure requirements in limited partnership agreements. “We’re at the beginning stages of seeing that,” he said.
What’s more, PE firms that have higher rates of disclosure are more likely to invest in portfolio companies with lower levels of environmental pollution. Specifically, Abraham, Olbert and Vasvari found that a 10% higher-than-average disclosure rate is associated with a 2% to 3% lower level of chemical releases from facilities that the firm has acquired.
“This evidence indicates that PE firms ‘walk the environmental talk,’” the paper’s authors wrote.
Featured image by Avigator Fortuner/Shutterstock
Learn about our editorial standards.