shutterstock-1472711903.jpg
Fund Performance

Private market investor sentiment holds strong, LP survey shows

Despite headwinds, a State Street survey shows that institutional investors remain bullish on the private markets.

Despite mounting challenges to the private market landscape, institutional investors remain bullish on its asset classes, particularly private equity.

In a State Street survey of 480 asset owners and managers, 68% of respondents said they plan to keep their allocations to the private markets in line with current targets over the next two to three years. Out of all private market asset classes, respondents were most optimistic about private equity: 63% said they expect that their largest allocation will be to PE in the next couple years. In the survey, State Street grouped private equity and venture capital together under the PE umbrella.

These responses are an optimistic sign for an asset class that faces growing pressure from rising interest rates, anxieties about inflation, and the aftermath of the denominator effect, which hit institutional portfolios hard when the public market took a nosedive last year.

“Institutional investors have allocated enormous amounts to PE for the past three decades with their allocations ever-increasing,” said Alexis Weber, CIO and founder of PM Alpha, a digital platform that caters to asset and wealth managers, in an email. Despite growing headwinds, the private markets have remained profitable over the last 15 years, with many of the strongest vintages arising from recessionary periods. Institutional investors, therefore, will continue to allocate to private market asset classes to gain exposure to what are expected to be some of the best vintages to come, Weber added.

Still the survey’s findings come at a time when institutions are concerned about PE asset valuations. State Street said 52% of asset owners’ responses indicated that they believe PE valuations haven’t yet adjusted to new market conditions.

What’s more, for an asset class whose primary transaction type—leveraged buyouts—depends on debt, rising interest rates pose a growing challenge to financing. In recent months, private debt has gained traction among pensions, endowments and other institutional investors. With the rising price of public debt and a constrained syndicated loan market, PE firms stepped up their exposure to private debt options to finance their deals in the second half of 2022. In Q3 2022, private debt saw a preliminary quarterly return of 1.3%, placing it above private equity (-0.6%), venture capital (-4.8%), and real estate (0.5%), according to PitchBook’s latest Global Fund Performance Report.

Institutions and their asset managers are well aware of this dilemma. Indeed, the State Street survey found 81% of asset owners agreed that the higher cost of borrowing is likely to negatively impact the attractiveness of private market investments that are highly leveraged.

But that sentiment isn’t swaying investors’ long-term allocations to private debt. According to the survey, only 42.5% of respondents said they plan to make their largest allocations to private credit, making it the asset class to which investors are least likely to dedicate large swaths of their portfolios.

“For LPs, from a return standpoint, private equity has higher and more consistent returns than its fixed-income counterpart private credit, making it more attractive to investors,” said Kyle Walters, a PitchBook analyst. “You know what you’re going to get compared to, with private debt, if rates go back down over the next several years, investors might choose to allocate toward more traditional fixed income strategies while keeping private equity allocations the same if not higher.”

For example, at the onset of the pandemic, private debt saw a -6.8% return, according to PitchBook analysts, a product of declining valuations during a period of falling interest rates, diminishing credit quality and increasing loan defaults.


Featured image by oatawa/Shutterstock

Learn about our editorial standards.