While signing an executive order Feb. 3 calling for the creation of a US sovereign wealth fund, President Donald Trump pointed to successes like Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund, which says its AUM sits at $930 billion.
“The Saudi Arabia fund is on the large side, but eventually we’ll catch it. We’re going to create a lot of wealth for the fund,” he said.
The comparison to the Saudi fund raises concerns about the governance structure and funding sources for a potential US fund. Instead, the US might look to emulate state-backed funds in democratic nations, like Norway’s endowment-style fund or Ireland’s strategic investment vehicle.
Despite its name, PIF is controlled by the country’s ruling family under Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman Al Saud. Even when the PIF’s oversight panel weighs in—like when it questioned a $2 billion check for a PE venture run by Jared Kushner, Trump’s son-in-law—the crown prince has the final say.
Subscribe to the newsletter here
The object of Trump’s ambitions, PIF’s actual spending power, has also been a source of skepticism. After a series of high-profile investments, like a $45 billion allocation to SoftBank’s Vision Fund in 2016 and a $20 billion contribution to a Blackstone infrastructure fund in 2017, Riyadh has slowed its pace of deployment in recent years. A person who works directly with these funds said dealmakers speculate that the fund may not have the purchasing power it claims.
Typically, institutional investors use their AUM figures to communicate their spending power, or liquid assets they can use to buy into funds or companies. But many of PIF’s assets are tied up in illiquid investments and debt, according to the person.
Much of the fund is invested in state-owned businesses, like Aramco, the national oil company. In 2024, the Saudi Arabia fund doubled its stake in Aramco.
“When you take into account PIF’s 16% ownership in Aramco, worth $285 billion today, where PIF can technically only use its dividend income to make investments, as well as PIF’s stakes in a number of large unlisted Saudi government-owned companies, the real spending power of PIF could be considerably lower than the stated AUM,” the person said.
PIF has also poured more than $1 trillion into domestic real estate and infrastructure projects, including mega-development NEOM on the coast of the Red Sea.
Could a mini-PIF exist in the US?
Paul Rose, dean of Case Western Reserve University’s law school, who writes and teaches about corporate finance, governance and sovereign wealth funds, said he doubts a fund with PIF’s top-down governance structure—one that would give Trump the power to override the decisions of an independent board—would gain legislative approval in the US.
But it’s not impossible.
“I don’t think Congress would want to cede that kind of authority to the president, but it could,” said Rose.
While an executive order does not require congressional approval, Trump’s order is for the Treasury and Commerce secretaries to devise a blueprint for the fund within 90 days. If a long-term, state-backed fund is to be established, it will need congressional approval to use government funds.
Rose said a PIF-esque structure would challenge the sovereign wealth fund’s position as a quasi-public sector entity already susceptible to conflicts of interest and market distortions.
Democratic countries have widely tried to insulate their state-backed funds from political influence. For example, Norway’s trillion-dollar fund, the largest in the world, is managed by Norges Investment Bank. The asset manager works under risk assessment and investment guidelines set forth by the country’s Ministry of Finance, which has appointed an independent Council on Ethics to assess prospective target companies.
A strategic investment vehicle
Rose bets that a US sovereign wealth fund structured like a strategic investment vehicle, formed with outside capital and used to invest in specific projects, like infrastructure, would be more likely than a PIF-style (or even a Norges-style) fund to gain regulatory approval in the US.
Ireland’s government, for example, established the Ireland Strategic Investment Fund in 2014 using leftover capital from the country’s pay-as-you-go public pension system. At the time, the country’s economy was recovering moderately after being walloped by the global recession. €10.7 billion of the public pension’s systems assets were used to recapitalize Irish banks in 2009. The remaining pool of capital was used to establish the strategic investment fund to stimulate parts of the Irish economy and pay for the costs of social welfare and public service pensions.
“Anyone who has advised on the governance of a sovereign wealth fund would tell them 1) to identify the fund’s purpose and 2) that the governance should allow the fund to pursue policy objectives without political influence,” Rose said.
To uphold a democratic governance model at the scale of a PIF, the next 90 days will need to be spent answering some of the most critical questions about the realities of a US sovereign wealth fund.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent (L) and Howard Lutnick, nominee for Commerce secretary (R), stand behind President Donald Trump as he speaks to reporters in the Oval Office on Feb. 3.
Featured image by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.