Private credit providers are fighting back. They needed to get creative to defend territory from an onslaught of repricings and refinancings unleashed in the first quarter, and it’s working. LCD data show that the volume of private credit loans taken out by broadly syndicated loans slowed in the second quarter.
Private credit lenders have employed myriad ways to avoid losing deals. First and foremost, they’ve given up spread.
Private credit loans have traditionally been known to be pricier than broadly syndicated loans. While this remains true, spreads are much tighter on private credit loans than during other periods in recent years. The data clearly demonstrates this: a direct lending loan with a spread of at least S+600 in H1 2024 was far less common than in both the first and second halves of 2023. Yet deals still got done in this range. Some were for dividend recapitalizations, highlighting another trend that accelerated in the second quarter.
While M&A is still less active than what private credit providers would prefer, spreads on broadly syndicated loans and direct loans for acquisition-related deals are converging, LCD data show.
One way private credit lenders are grappling with the new market reality is by agreeing to cut spreads within existing lender groups. This may be the simplest way administratively. Lenders report calls from sponsors and agents with requests for spread reduction. Eyewatering savings by borrowers of as much as 300 bps were available in the second quarter, with 175-250 bps easily chopped from spreads just by asking.
But there’s no denying that the savings wrought by moving over to the syndicated loan market, away from private credit, were also worthwhile. Many borrowers chose this route, refinancing private credit loans in the broadly syndicated loan market.
Particularly vulnerable were second-lien and unitranche loans that private credit lenders had provided in recent years, enjoying juicy spreads. Of course, for borrowers, that’s where the most cost savings were possible once other financing options emerged.
According to market participants, the potential for savings was less for the lower middle market. There, refinancing risk was less severe, according to those market participants. “We have to be competitive on pricing, but lower middle market borrowers are not going to go out and shop their current lender for 50 basis points — the juice is just not worth the squeeze,” was how Reed Van Gorden, head of originations at Deerpath Capital, described it. “It takes the same amount of time to refinance a $20 million deal as it does a $2 billion deal, and the interest savings on a $20 million deal are a lot smaller.”
But further upmarket, the hassle of drawing up new paperwork made sense. One of private credit’s favorite arguments in favor of the asset class — that smaller lender groups are easier to work with — may have worked against them in this market. Take Magnet Forensics Inc., a portfolio company of Thoma Bravo, which cut the spread on a $535 million term loan to S+500, from S+800, via an amendment. Blue Owl is the sole lender. Notably, the company had considered refinancing the debt in the syndicated loan market. Magnet Forensics develops digital investigation products.
The main driver behind the repricing and refinancing activity is that the syndicated loan market is again welcoming B-minus borrowers. As soon as the syndicated loan market got comfortable again with these lower-rated borrowers, the floodgates opened. The math was simply too compelling not to leave the private credit market behind, what with broadly syndicated loan spreads compressed to multiyear lows.
Data show that B-minus borrowers are refinancing broadly syndicated loans at the highest volume in years.
In sum, while the pace of direct loans refinancing in the syndicated loan market slowed, the volume of B-minus rated repricing increased in the second quarter, showing that more borrowers stayed put in the BSL market, LCD data indicated.
The full extent of damage done by the repricing and refinancing wave to private credit loan portfolios will emerge in the BDC earnings for the quarter ended June 30. But this may take a while, as the bulk of second-quarter BDC earnings typically appear in early August. According to market participants, the repricing phenomena may have been underreported, despite the preponderance of recent headlines. If there’s a silver lining to the trend, it may be that credit investors and lenders alike stand to benefit from easing the financial burden of borrower companies.
Some relief is needed, too. To this end, private credit lenders are intently focused on the outcome for Pluralsight. The workforce development platform was acquired by Vista Equity Partners in December 2020, in what feels like a different lifetime for private credit lenders. At issue is a transaction that emerged in the second quarter that included a change in the collateral package for a private credit loan from Blue Owl, Ares, Goldman Sachs, Benefit Street Partners, BlackRock, Oaktree, and Golub Capital. In 2021, Pluralsight Inc. received a $1.175 billion recurring revenue term loan and a $100 million revolver backing the take-private buyout. Under terms of the recent transaction, Pluralsight raised new preferred equity financing through a drop-down transaction. Preferred equity has been a trend lately, of course. But in the case of Pluralsight, Vista moved intellectual property from the company to a restricted subsidiary to facilitate the transaction. Pluralsight used the financing to pay interest, while the private equity sponsor marked its equity position in Pluralsight to zero, according to media reports. This type of transaction has yet to be tested in the private credit market. The argument for investing in the alternative asset has long included the partnership approach of relationship lending, where private equity sponsors and lenders are naturally aligned in their motivation for good outcomes and often have many portfolio investments in common, further incentivizing good behavior from both sides. Private credit lenders are closely guarding the behind-the-scenes negotiations for Pluralsight, but it’s clear that it’s not pretty. According to media reports, the preferred equity transaction will buy the stressed company more time.
The case of Pluralsight is a special situation. For sure, software loans placed on deals at peak asset prices are on watch, of course. That is especially true about companies with recurring revenue loans, which are loans underwritten on revenue streams, rather than EBITDA. The loans are typically structured to switch to EBITDA-based covenants after a certain amount of time.
Perhaps more interesting than the trend of private credit loan borrowers refinancing in the syndicated loan market were the ones that went the other way, refinancing syndicated loans in the private credit market.
There are numerous reasons why borrowers would still choose the private credit market over the syndicated loan market. Private credit lenders have been willing to allow paying interest in-kind, sometimes even from the start. Private credit providers have also been generous with delayed-draw term loans (DDTLs), loans that a borrower can draw on for a fixed period, at a rate determined when the deal is closed. The syndicated loan market has not been willing to provide these. Private credit lenders have shown a willingness to allow “consensual layering” of new debt, such as an amortizing term loan, or a “creative retrenching,” generally offered to all the private credit lenders to a company.
Take orthopedic implant maker Orchid Orthopedic Solutions. The company obtained debt financing from private credit lenders to support the refinancing of the company’s broadly syndicated debt. Orchid’s $485 million term loan B due 2026 was a constituent of the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index. HPS was a lender on the new financing. That lender’s Form 10-K showed a $13.4 million piece of a revolving loan and a $137.6 million piece of a first-lien loan to Femur Buyer priced at S+825 with 4.5% PIK. Maturity is March 2030.
Another deal in the direction of BSL-to-private-credit in the second quarter was Ribbon Communications, which tested the market to place a syndicated deal, then opted for a term loan from private credit lenders, according to market sources. Also in May, Electrical Components International (ECI) refinanced broadly syndicated loans with a $1.1 billion senior secured credit from private credit lenders. ECI had loans maturing in 2025 and 2026. Similarly, in March, fitness facility operator Equinox Group obtained $1.8 billion in new capital, including a first-lien senior secured loan priced at S+825, plus 4.13% PIK, and a second-lien senior secured loan at 16% PIK, to support a refinancing and growth initiatives. Notable about the Equinox transaction is how close the borrower company came to risking default. In total, LCD tracked $8.7 billion of syndicated loans taken out by debt provided by direct lenders, down from $18.8 billion in the second half of 2023 but well above the $1.5 billion at this point last year.
Still, the deals headed to the private credit market are decidedly not fulfilling the buyout-and-M&A transaction volume that investors crave. Investors want new-money transactions, and there’s certainly enough new money to go around. Robust middle market and private credit CLO issuance is helping fuel demand for loans. Through June 17, managers priced $9.5 billion of these vehicles this quarter, on track to exceed the all-time high set in the first quarter ($9.6 billion). Year-to-date issuance is running at a record pace, at $19.1 billion, 62% ahead of this point last year.
The underlying trends suggest more activity ahead, even if it has not materialized. For instance, a mountain of dry powder from US private equity firms is expected to fuel demand for financing.
It has left private credit providers longing for the heady days of late 2021, when there were too many deals at once. Spreads were high, too. But that said, it could be worse. The second quarter of 2024 is on track to produce the highest quarterly volume of directly originated private credit loans in several years. Excluding buyouts, private credit activity is the busiest it’s been in at least five years. The volume is boosted by refinancing and recapitalization transactions, of course.
Indeed, the volume of buyouts has declined quarter over quarter in the Q2 2024 for both the broadly syndicated loan market and the private credit market. However, it’s still higher than average levels reached during the period of interest rate hikes that began in the second quarter of 2022 and ended in the fourth quarter of 2023.
Overall, estimated direct lending volume for sponsored borrowers in the second quarter is on track to reach the highest level in several years.
What’s more, expectations have brightened for deal activity in the second half of 2024, with some lenders reporting improved pipelines.
“We’ve consistently heard non-disclosure agreement volumes had a strong uptick in March and April … a lot of private equity firms are likely getting their businesses ready to sell, or are already ready to sell,” said Garrett Stephen, First Eagle Alternative Credit senior managing director and co-head of origination.
Even as banks are keen to showcase the comeback of the syndicated loan market, direct lenders continue to lock up $1 billion+ deals at a steady clip.
Among Q2 megadeals is CoreWeave, which received one of the largest private credit financings to date, at $7.5 billion, as investors jostle to provide capital to companies focused on artificial intelligence innovation. Blackstone led the CoreWeave financing, with its affiliates holding $4.5 billion of the private credit loans. Other lenders include Carlyle, CDPQ, DigitalBridge Credit, funds affiliated with BlackRock, Eldridge Industries and Great Elm Capital Corp. The debt facility is an additional financing to the $2.3 billion of loans that CoreWeave received in August 2023, market sources said. That loan was priced at S+875.
Lower middle market deals are helping with the number of buyout deals seeking financing, tracked by LCD. In this end of the market, lenders and borrowers play by different rules: Covenant packages are stronger, and spreads have not been under the same intense pressure to meet those in the syndicated loan market.
It’s no surprise that refinancings stole the show in the private credit market in the second quarter. Sensing opportunity, and with interest rates at multi-year lows, borrowers are seizing the moment.
Of course, in the search for new deals, lenders are looking at near-term maturities. BDC loan portfolios offer some helpful data points regarding the scope of these near-term maturities.
Away from refinancing and repricing transactions, another trend has been quietly building — dividend deals.
As exits remain elusive, the dividend trend that is gripping the broadly syndicated loan market has also moved down market, enabled by private credit providers. While dividend transactions are open even for the smallest borrowers, a size demarcation of $50 million in EBITDA will typically allow for terms in the private credit market that rival those available in the syndicated loan market, including spreads below S+500. One dividend transaction in the private credit market as of mid-June is for a private equity-owned borrower that has roughly tripled EBITDA in recent years, to $60 million. The performing borrower is marketing a covenant-lite dividend recap private credit loan at S+500, with 5x leverage, market sources said.
Moving upstream, the marquee issuer in the second quarter in the private credit market was data center services company Park Place Technologies, which received roughly $2 billion in private credit loans in April. Proceeds refinanced syndicated loans and funded a dividend to its private equity backers. Pricing on Park Place’s new funded term loan was S+525, replacing an S+500 first-lien and an S+900 second-lien loan structure. Financing included the term loan, a delayed-draw term loan and a revolver. Leverage was approximately 5x, sources said.
That deal came on the heels of one for NFL helmet maker Riddell. Riddell received $400 million in convertible preferred equity and debt to support a refinancing and fund a dividend to current investors. The Riddell deal consisted of a $250 million term loan and a $25 million delayed-draw term loan, which the company can use for future acquisitions. The rest of the financing included $125 million of convertible preferred equity. BC Partners Credit provided the financing, according to an April 3 company statement.
Featured image: Daniel B Begiato/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.