barren-lake-alp.jpg
Leveraged Loans

Q4 US Volume Wrap: Refinancings grab record share as M&A withers

Any sound or fury in 2023’s syndicated loan market signified little, as lucrative LBO deals failed to emerge or were snapped up by private credit.

Want to see more? Fill out the form below.

I agree to PitchBook’s privacy policy

US leveraged loan new issuance remained steady in the fourth quarter as views that the Fed was done with rate hikes, and that there might indeed be an economic soft landing, sparked rallies across risk markets. In the loan market, the secondary sustained a rally into mid-December to top off an exceptionally strong year for the asset class, which produced its second-best annual return on record, of 12.75% as of Dec. 19.

At $55.3 billion, overall fourth-quarter loan volume was slightly ahead of the first two quarters of 2023 but well off the pace of Q3, which was bolstered by a surge of M&A deals in a frothy post-Labor Day window. That activity thinned what would have been a more robust Q4 pipeline, leaving M&A-related loan issuance during the final three months of the year at $16.2 billion, down from $27.5 billion in Q3, but still the second-highest total since Q2 2022.

Refinancing remained the main driver of volume for the quarter, at $31.4 billion, or 57% of the total. This was again mainly from higher-rated borrowers, those with BB-minus ratings or better, which account for 58% of that total refinancing figure. That is the second-highest share in four years, behind Q4 2022, when it was 60%.

In absolute terms, refinancing volume was not off the charts this year: There are three annual totals ahead of it since the Global Financial Crisis. However, with non-refinancing activity scarce — $96.9 billion is the lowest output for these purposes since 2009 — the refinancing share of total volume is the highest it has ever been, at 59% as of Dec. 14. In fact, this will be the second time in 20 years that refinancing volume has surpassed non-refinancing volume. It’s worth noting that in that other instance, 2011, volume totals for these categories were nearly even, with refinancing just slightly higher.

In the fourth quarter, a sustained rally in the secondary market, coupled with limited new-money deals in the primary market, opened the door to opportunism. Repricing activity resurfaced in earnest, and dividend recapitalizations also emerged. Regarding that secondary price movement, the average bid of the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index hit 96.03 on Dec. 19, a 2023 high, after rising steadily from a quarter low point of 94.73 on Nov. 1.

The demand side of the equation was supportive in the fourth quarter, with CLO issuance sustained at $29.1 billion, the second-highest quarterly volume this year (behind the $33.5 billion in Q1). As well, retail loan fund flows turned positive in the second half of Q4, with a net inflow of $862.4 million over the six weeks ended Dec. 6.

Looking at total institutional loan market activity, including amend-and-extend and repricing transactions done via amendment, which don’t count toward traditional new-issue volume, Q4 was the second-busiest since the first quarter of 2022. Deals done to extend maturities via amendment totaled $22.4 billion, down slightly from $24.9 billion in Q3, but pushing this category further into record territory on an annual basis, at $81.7 billion for 2023. In the higher yield environment, the need to address maturity pressure has been driving the heady pace of A&E activity for borrowers in 2023.

On the demand side, with 2023 running at the lowest volume for new-issue supply (excluding refinancings) since 2009, investors are keen to remain invested (for the right credit story, at least). Demand is also fueled by the CLO investor base, where 40% of vehicles will have reportedly exited their reinvestment periods by the end of this year, which has narrowed access for refinancings.

Indeed, issuers made headway on the maturity wall this year, but there is still wood to chop. Just $9.3 billion of loans are maturing in 2024, down from $74.9 billion as of December 2022. Looking past next year, the 2025-2026 maturity wall stands at $267 billion as of Dec. 15, with $89 billion of that due in 2025 and $178 billion in 2026. That combined maturity wall is down from $433 billion one year earlier, with the 2025 portion cut to less than half its $198 billion total. However, riskier credits constitute a larger portion of the remaining amounts — 51% of the 2025 maturity wall is from issuers with a B- rating.

After starting the year at elevated levels, straight new-issue spreads for BB/BB-minus issuers tracked lower, to 275 bps in December, versus 358 bps in January. The all-in spread, including the upfront fee amortized over three years and credit spread adjustment, if any, fell to 290 bps, from 451 bps.

That same trajectory is seen for B/B+ issuers. Though off its tightest sub-400 bps levels from mid-year, the straight spread sat at 394 bps in December, down from 453 bps in January. The all-in spread fell 121 bps from January’s 554 bps, to 432.5 bps.

Following a Q3 surge to a five-quarter high of $27.5 billion, M&A issuance tailed off in Q4 to $16.2 billion. LBO issuance was particularly stale at $2.2 billion, its lowest level since the comparable period in 2022. However, acquisitions by private equity-backed companies provided deal volume of $7.2 billion, the most since Q2 2022. That was bolstered by such deals as Cetera Financial ($1.7 billion) and Culligan International ($1.15 billion). Corporate M&A was also up, at a four-quarter high of $6.85 billion, featuring deals from Summit Materials ($1.01 billion) and TransDigm ($1 billion).

Overall, M&A supply remained constrained throughout 2023 as high rates deterred acquisition activity, leaving refinancing and extensions to take a larger share of new-issue volume. Through Dec. 14, M&A volume this year, including both sponsored and corporate activity, was $69.4 billion, its lowest level since 2010 ($62.8 billion) and down from an all-time high of $330.4 billion just two years prior, in 2021.

New LBO supply was also at a 13-year low this year, at just $30.7 billion. What new LBOs investors saw in 2023 featured lower leverage and higher equity checks, as deals were structured toward higher ratings. In fact, just three LBO deals from issuers rated B-minus were completed in the syndicated market in 2023: Aramsco, Cvent, and Fogo de Chao. LCD’s compilation of company financials at the time of issuance shows that the average debt/EBITDA ratio of newly minted US broadly syndicated LBO debt fell to 5x for large corporate borrowers as of Nov. 30 — the lowest annual reading since 2010. Equity contributions topped 50% for the first time on record.

By contrast, refinancing issuance was elevated as issuers focused on extending maturities of $137 billion of maturities, the fourth-largest annual total on record. Refinancing volume accounted for 59% of the annual total through Dec. 14, while M&A volume was 30%. That flipped the script from 2022, when just 26% was tied to refinancing, while acquisition-related issuance accounted for 63%. Total institutional loan issuance of $234 billion barely surpasses the 2022 total of $225.3 billion, and is well below the annual average of the prior 10 years of $380 billion.

That figure does not include a record amount of amend-and-extend volume that aggregated $81.7 billion for institutional loans, or $72.1 billion of repricing activity (via an amendment), which especially gathered steam later in the year.

In addition to the trough in LBO issuance, sponsored M&A financing in 2023 of $23.8 billion was at its lowest point since 2011 and marked the second consecutive annual decline. Instead, private equity-backed borrowers were managing maturities and refinancing debt to the tune of $59.8 billion. That is the second-highest annual total in 10 years and represents a 44% share of all sponsored issuance in 2023, the most since 2011.

Private credit continued to grow its presence, to the detriment of the broadly syndicated market, increasingly financing large LBO transactions, as well as refinancing existing institutional loans. Some examples of jumbo LBO loans in the private credit space in 2023: Merchants Fleet ($3 billion), New Relic ($2.65 billion), and Guidehouse ($1.9 billion). High-profile refinancings for Finastra ($5.3 billion), Hyland Software ($3.4 billion), and PetVet Care Centers ($3 billion) sapped some $8.5 billion of institutional first-lien loans from the market that were due in 2024 and 2025.

Learn about our editorial standards.