When it comes to loan size, it’s still no contest between the syndicated loan market and private credit. Although the private credit market has grown to $1.7 trillion, private credit lenders have room to grow to compete for the largest-sized deals.
The record-breaking $55 billion LBO for Electronic Arts has stoked debate on just how large a loan the private credit market could muster. The EA buyout is backed by a $20 billion debt financing commitment from JPMorgan, of which $18 billion is expected to be funded at close.
Private credit lenders say that a $20 billion financing package is still not feasible. The next milestone is $10 billion, which several market participants say is within reach, although not imminent.
“Given the scale of current commitments and the depth of the market, a $10 billion transaction is potentially achievable for businesses with strong fundamental value,” said Doug Cannaliato, co-head of originations at Antares Capital.
“We’ve seen multiple multi-billion-dollar transactions successfully executed through club deals among relationship-driven private credit investors, including Antares. Private credit investors are increasingly taking on larger hold sizes, especially for high-quality credits,” Cannaliato added.
With M&A and buyout activity gathering steam, several significant take-private transactions are in the works, and some are likely to be financed by private credit, market sources say. Credit investors are starved for large buyouts.
Activity has improved in recent months, but the syndicated loan market, where record-setting spreads are enticing borrowers, has benefited more than private credit.
“Record tight liquid markets can provide an attractive option to sponsors and strategics for mega-deals,” said Valerie Kritsberg, global head of capital markets and trading at Blackstone Credit & Insurance.
A severe supply-demand imbalance in the market — where demand for private credit loans exceeds supply — has worsened this year.
“Though the syndicated markets offer very competitive pricing in the current market conditions, it is only a matter of time until the private credit market facilitates a $10 billion unitranche,” said Bill Eckmann, head of principal finance – Americas at Macquarie Capital.
With a little help
It was not too long ago that private credit lenders were aspirational about bringing a $5 billion unitranche to the market.
Many will remember that Qlik Technologies set a record when it raised a $1 billion unitranche to support a buyout in 2016, which was the largest-ever unitranche at that time. That deal was refinanced in 2017 in the syndicated loan market. In 2023, with ratings in hand, the borrower returned to the syndicated loan market.
The Qlik Technologies record now seems quaint, as evidenced by the table below.
“The largest private credit deal that could be done right now is probably around $10 billion, if the market really wanted to stretch itself, several of the largest players could put up a few billion each and make it happen,” said another private credit lender, who agreed to speak on the condition of anonymity.
European direct lending is not far behind US counterparts in terms of loan size. Among large private credit loans was the Goldman Sachs-led €6.5 billion loan backing Adevinta’s refinancing in May. The record-breaking European unitranche, which included €4.8 billion funded and a €1.7 billion upsize, was a win for direct lenders over banks.
The deal provided a datapoint regarding the sheer number of participants needed to close a large private credit loan: 19 direct lending funds were involved, according to sources.
So far, the largest private credit loans on both sides of the Atlantic have required a shared effort.
“When we see four, five, or six billion-dollar deals, those are mega-cap private deals to the point you need every lender and their brother around it to get the deal done,” one lender said of the mega private credit loans for US borrowers.
One of the largest attempted private credit deals escaped the market. Cotiviti had been in discussions with private credit providers for a $5.5 billion unitranche loan to support a transaction with The Carlyle Group that would have been the largest-ever private credit LBO financing. The facility was guided at S+650-675 with an OID of 97-97.5 before being scuttled.
But in early 2024, the syndicated loan market reopened to lower-rated borrowers, and Cotiviti moved there. The payment technology company completed a $5 billion term loan to complete a stake sale — this time with KKR as the equity investor. The financing was agented by JPMorgan; the larger floating-rate tranche priced at S+375, with an OID of 99.5.
Frenemies forever
One potential path to the first $10 billion unitranche could be via a collaboration between private credit lenders and public debt markets.
“As credit markets evolve, private credit continues to gain share, proving its ability to compete for large-scale transactions while also finding opportunities to partner with banks on major financing packages,” said Blackstone’s Kritsberg.
To this end, private credit lenders may co-underwrite deals alongside banks in situations where banks may want to share some of the risk by having private credit firms take down a riskier piece of a large financing.
“A deal the size of EA is part of the market where borrowers have multiple financing options. It’s a question of public, private and banks — or increasingly all of the above for larger transactions. Borrowers will make a choice based on speed of execution, flexibility, and pricing,” said Matt Bass, head of private alternatives at AB.
A few examples have emerged of private credit providers and banks collaborating on financing packages. One is the take-private buyout of Walgreens Boots Alliance by Sycamore Partners, backed by $18 billion in total financing, including syndicated loans and $4.5 billion of private debt, which is one of the largest healthcare LBOs since the global financial crisis, an LCD analysis showed.
Banks and private credit firms are also collaborating through partnerships, a trend expected to continue this year as banks seek to strengthen their presence in the private credit asset class.
While most of these partnerships don’t explicitly entail co-underwriting deals together, there are already examples of banks and direct lenders coming together to provide joint financing packages, according to Antares’ Cannaliato.
“In some cases, hybrid structures combining private and public credit markets have also enabled greater deal sizes,” said Cannaliato.
The myriad bank-private credit partnerships have provided a way for the two markets to collaborate rather than compete, often adding heft to each firm while capitalizing on specific strengths.
Featured image by PM Images/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.