Some publicly traded companies including Tesla and Dropbox have packed up and moved their legal homes from Delaware to Texas or Nevada, but the growing interest in relocating hasn’t turned into significant action among startups—yet.
The country’s second-smallest state has been the default corporate domicile for decades thanks to its robust body of business case law, experienced and specialized judges, and highly flexible corporate statutes. But ongoing business battles and vocal criticism from Elon Musk and other high-profile executives threaten to change that.
Thus far, listed companies are leading the charge. Nevada has won a big seal of approval from Musk, who has relocated most of his companies’ corporate entities to the state. Nevada is viewed as more founder-friendly than Delaware, with laws that favor majority shareholders and a company’s board. This is especially critical as a company adds more and more investors to its cap table.
In Nevada, “you have less risk to be sued by a minority shareholder [or lose the case]—at least that’s the perception,” explained Derek Colla, a partner at law firm Cooley.
Since a Delaware judge rejected Musk’s $56 billion pay package last year, Sequoia Capital and prominent VCs Bill Gurley and Mike Maples have voiced their support for Musk in the ongoing Chancery Court battle. Sequoia last month said in a court filing that denying Musk his compensation could limit the ability of “superstar CEOs” to innovate, Semafor reported.
“It’s time for every startup to reject Delaware,” Maples posted on X.
Over the past few years, Texas has also made efforts to rival Delaware as a good home for corporations. It set up its own state business courts, which began hearing cases in September, with judges appointed by the governor for two-year terms. The Fifth Circuit of Appeals, whose jurisdiction includes Texas, has also been gaining popularity among companies as its rulings tend to skew more conservative.
Among startups, the vibes, at least, are starting to shift away from Delaware.
AngelList, which provides investment management tools to startups and VCs, announced in February that it’s rolling out certain features, including better cap table management for C-corporations in Texas and Nevada. It’s also adjusting some of its prices for those states to align with what it charges Delaware-domiciled customers. The company told PitchBook that it did so after seeing a small uptick of interest from companies domiciled in those states, though the vast majority of monthly net new signups still originate from Delaware-incorporated startups.
Cooley, a major law firm popular among startups that provides an online incorporation tool, told PitchBook that 15% of documents generated have been for Nevada since it added the feature in December. However, the firm does not track whether those documents were ultimately filed.
“I’ve had two companies that formed as Nevada corporations, both very high-profile founders and not their first startups,” Colla told PitchBook.
He added that before last year, incorporating outside of Delaware came up in client conversations less than 5% of the time. Now? About a third of the time, and it “tends to skew to the most ambitious founders,” he said.
To be sure, Delaware still reigns supreme. Cap table management software provider Carta told PitchBook it’s not seeing material changes to where startups choose to incorporate. In the last two quarters of 2024, the portion of C-corp startups on its platform incorporated outside of Delaware ticked up to just over 12%, up from a range of 7.4% to 11% since 2019.
Should this shift pick up steam among venture-backed startups, it could spell a new regime for VCs with potentially fewer investor protections and judicial predictability in legal disputes. For better or worse, Delaware’s Chancery Court and its body of case law are well-established and concerned with protecting all investors.
“It’s like English—everyone speaks it,” said Colla. “Another state, you have to translate it, it’s an extra step.”
Of course, the vibes matter. “Part of it is also culture and narrative—that they’re part of this new thing, this new trajectory,” he said of the allure of alternative domiciles.
Any westward movement is still in its early days, but there could be a tipping point on the (distant) horizon, according to Colla. “I think we’re gonna find out in the next IPO wave.”
Featured image by Jenna O’Malley/PitchBook News
Learn about our editorial standards.