Tug of War Contest

Featured image: Gannet77/Getty Images

Credit

Syndicated loan market strikes back, refinances private credit deals

The syndicated market is attracting borrower companies back to the fold with tighter pricing spreads.

Want to see more? Fill out the form below.

I agree to PitchBook’s privacy policy

If turnabout is fair play then no one should be surprised as the syndicated loan market takes deals from private credit lenders.

Avalara is currently in market with a proposed $2.5 billion term loan B through a Morgan Stanley-led arranger group to refinance the company’s private credit facilities. This deal follows a transaction for Kaseya completed earlier this month, also through a Morgan Stanley-led line-up, that refinanced debt held by private credit firms. Finastra could be another, according to a Bloomberg report. Chase Corp. is also looking to replace private credit with a syndicated loan. And with a host of other private credit borrowers eyeing the opportunity to cut costs on existing debt there might well be more of these transactions down the road.

It’s worth noting that the original transactions were considered major wins by private credit lenders, which began taking market share from the syndicated loan world in 2020. For a spell in mid-2022, private credit was financing nearly all new deals.

So far in 2025, however, companies have refinanced their direct lending deals with syndicated loans totaling $7.3 billion, the second-highest quarterly volume in at least four years, behind $11.7 billion in the first quarter of 2024. Borrowers that switched to syndicated financing achieved significant spread savings, averaging 263 bps, ranging from 200 bps on the low end to 375 bps on the high end. Direct lending takeouts by BSL deals in the first three months of 2024 featured even larger spread reductions, averaging 290 bps, because 44% of those transactions replaced more expensive privately placed second-lien debt with a syndicated first-lien term loan.

Avalara, rated B-minus by S&P Global and B2 by Moody’s, is the latest borrower looking to refinance pricey private credit loans in the broadly syndicated market. The provider of tax compliance automation software pitched a $2.5 billion, seven-year term loan B at S+325, with a 0% floor and an OID of 99-99.5. The company is looking to refinance a unitranche facility due October 2028 that totaled $2.5 billion when it was placed in 2022 to finance the company’s $8.4 billion take-private buyout by Vista Equity Partners. Initial pricing was S+725, with a 0.75% floor, but the spread had been reduced to S+625 as of Dec. 31, 2024, lender filings show.

The persistent technical imbalance in the BSL market has compressed new-issue spreads to the lowest level in over a decade across the full credit quality spectrum. Most borrowers migrating from private credit to a syndicated solution received a B-minus corporate credit rating once they tapped the BSL market. This year, new-issue spreads for this cohort have tightened to S+367 on average, a post-GFC low.

However, market sentiment has soured in recent weeks amid a massive sell-off in the equity markets and growing uncertainty, sidelining a handful of loan syndications and requiring arrangers on some transactions to flex wider in a concession to help deals get across the line. Investor demand has cooled — US leveraged loan retail funds and ETFs posted an outflow of $1.7 billion for the week ended March 12, the largest weekly outflow since August, according to Morningstar. With the month-to-date return for the loan asset class in the red for the first time since October 2023, executing a refinancing at attractive terms has become less certain — especially for the riskiest borrowers.

Sizing the refinancing opportunity
Despite less accommodating market conditions, private debt borrowers still have opportunities for significant spread savings. LCD identified 35 companies besides Kaseya and Avalara that raised at least $1 billion from direct lenders in 2022 and 2023 whose loans were still outstanding based on Q4 2024 BDC filings. This cohort, which includes loans with spreads of S+500 or higher, represents over $76 billion of debt. At issuance, these mega-sized loans had a median spread of S+600. However, by the end of 2024, the median retreated to S+544 as some deals were repriced amid increased competition from the BSL market.

Typically, lenders reset prepayment protection during a repricing transaction. Thus, not every borrower in the 35-name cohort is a potential target for a BSL refinancing. It all depends on the timing of these amendments: For example, in July 2022, Zendesk Inc. received roughly $5 billion in loans backing a $10.2 billion take-private buyout of the company by a private equity group led by Hellman & Friedman and Permira. According to LCD News, Blackstone Credit led the financing, which also included Apollo, Blue Owl, HPS, and Ares. The first-lien senior secured loan due 2028 carried a spread of S+650, according to Ares Capital’s 10-Q in the quarter ended Dec. 31, 2023, but pricing fell to S+500 during the third quarter of 2024 based on multiple BDC filings.

Similarly, in May 2022, Tivity Health received a $1.125 billion term loan backing a take-private acquisition of the company by Stone Point Capital. The term loan carried an initial spread of S+600. By the third quarter of last year, the spread had declined to S+500, based on BDC filings.

Of the 35 outstanding $1 billion-plus private credit transactions closed in 2022 and 2023, a dozen have spreads of at least S+600 currently, putting them more than 200 bps above current B-minus clearing levels in the BSL market. Collectively, these 12 borrowers account for roughly $27 billion of debt and have a heavy concentration in the Software sector.

Five out of the 12 companies are no strangers to the liquid markets and were former issuers of syndicated loans before switching to a direct lending solution — Tank Holding, Hyland Software, PetVet Care Centers, Finastra and Consolidated Precision Products. The latter four borrowers tapped direct lenders in 2023 to address near-term maturities when the BSL market had no appetite for risky, lower-rated paper. Hyland Software and PetVet Care carried a B-minus rating prior to repayment, while Consolidated Precision Products and Finastra fell into the CCC-plus bucket. The latter borrower’s August 2023 landmark $4.8 billion unitranche credit facility was the largest takeout of an institutional loan by private credit on record by a large margin, according to LCD.

Not just spreads
The syndicated market can attract borrower companies back to the fold with much tighter spreads. Still, not every borrower and their private-equity sponsor can or will choose this route. Ratings are one consideration — large transactions for CCC rated companies are extremely rare in the syndicated loan market. The last time a loan exceeded $1 billion for this cohort was in November 2017. Besides costing money, ratings take time. One major argument in favor of the private credit market is speed of execution: without having to obtain ratings, deals can close much faster.

Aside from ratings, borrowers often choose to stay with private credit for the same key advantages it has long provided: private credit eliminates syndication risk and ensures that loans close at spreads and terms agreed upon by lender and borrower. Also, a smaller, single group of lenders — like those found in the private credit market — are far easier for a borrower to work with than a large lender group of dozens or hundreds of lenders. A syndicated loan deal may also have a complex capital structure, possibly entailing multiple debt tranches that could have competing interests in a workout situation. The favorite structure of the private credit market, the unitranche, combines senior and junior debt into a single, more efficient loan, market participants say.

Private credit providers have also been generous with delayed-draw term loans, which a borrower can draw on for a fixed period, at a rate determined when the deal is closed — which could come in handy as market conditions change. In addition, direct lenders can offer a PIK option (paying interest in kind), a feature generally unavailable in the syndicated loan market.

Featured image: Gannet77/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.