Jenna O’Malley/PitchBook News
Despite high-profile mega-deals keeping the mood up, sentiment at the smaller end of the private equity market remains muted. Concerningly, it’s not clear how or when this might change.
The pace of capital deployment and exits in the middle market has yet to catch up with the upper end, while anecdotes from dealmakers, banks and advisers to PE firms point to a lack of animal spirits across the market and to sharply contrasting fates of pristine assets and the rest.
Companies considered high-quality are still trading at premium multiples, while there was agreement that those with “some hair on them” barely attract any interest or draw bids that come in at a significant discount to sellers’ expectations.
High customer concentration, the perceived risk of management turnover and operating in a sector whose fortunes are closely linked to the wider economic cycle are enough to derail deals in today’s middle market.
“Buyer mentality is still quite disciplined, so you end up seeing a tale of two cities,” said Jared Stein, the co-founder of Monogram Capital Partners, a PE firm that focuses on consumer and retail companies in the lower middle market.
As a buyer in many of these transactions, Stein said he often sees a disconnect between asset quality and the price demanded by sellers. There has been “a good number of broken processes that result just from that schism in expectations,” he said.
Concerns around the management team are a common source of friction, said one partner with an international law firm, citing a recent attempted sale of a company in the business services sector.
While the company’s financial performance tracked roughly in line with projections, its chief executive told potential buyers he might not remain in the role. Buyer interest waned, and the transaction stalled. Only one bidder ultimately submitted a letter of intent, but offered a valuation below the seller’s expectations, according to the adviser, who did not wish to be named due to the sensitivity of the subject.
A similar sentiment permeated the automotive collision repair industry, which had a challenging year in 2025. Skyrocketing insurance premiums, rising expenses for auto parts and higher labor costs jacked up repair bills and led more customers to postpone getting work done. Assets in the sector that were not considered premium saw virtually no buyer interest, a senior M&A dealmaker at a PE-backed regional consolidator told PitchBook. This marks a contrast to previous cycles, when there was always one or two bidders.
“In 2021, … it was almost like the dot-com boom era where you had all these assets that needed some work but continued to be powered by the sheer exuberance of the market,” said Alain Dermarkar, the US head of PE and US co-head of M&A at A&O Shearman. This is no longer the case, he added.
The divergence in the fortunes of premium assets and the rest is partly explained by financial sponsors in the middle market becoming more selective.
For smaller and emerging managers, the competition for capital is intense, especially when more capital is flowing to mega-funds and managers with strong brand recognition, said David Conrod, the co-founder and CEO of placement agent FocusPoint Private Capital Group. LPs are therefore increasingly unforgiving of subpar investments.
"[GPs] have to demonstrate a history of high financial returns and prove that they can deliver operational value creation, generate co-investment opportunities and have strong sector specialization,” Conrod said.
Stein said he sees LPs demanding stronger performance from lower-middle-market funds to compensate for the additional risk premium they assume. LPs’ target returns for these vehicles often exceed a 3x gross multiple on invested capital and a 20% IRR, in contrast with 2x to 2.5x MOIC and mid-teens IRR expected from mega-funds.
With financial sponsors becoming more selective, a reasonable question is who will step in to acquire those blemished assets. Some are hoping that deep-pocketed strategic buyers, unconstrained by return hurdles and more willing to take a long-term view, will absorb them. In other cases, PE funds under pressure to deploy capital may be compelled to step in.
But if that fails to materialize, managers could find themselves having to exit at prices below prior marks or even stuck with stranded assets, making the illiquidity strain even worse.
Learn about our editorial standards.